The Kaatskeller
$$ • Pizza, Ice Cream, Cocktail Bar Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout The Kaatskeller
Customers' Favorites
Arugula Salad with Apples and Walnuts
Wood Fired Cinnamon Crumb Apple Pie
Sausage & Peppers Calzone
Dreaming of Buffalo Pizza
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Wood Fired Rosso Pizza
Brook Trout Rillettes
Burrata Caponatina
Skillet Meatballs
The Manor Pizza
The Kaatskeller Reviews
283 ratings
Share your opinion about The Kaatskeller
Absolutely delicious!!!!!!
2nd time here. must say, very surprised. pizza was so so good. staff is super friendly. this will definitely be a place we go everytime we are up in ny…. manager/owner not sure who he is, what a riot😂😂. keep staying consistent
your friendly “JERSEY”😂😂
your friendly “JERSEY”😂😂
This place is a gem! We ate here last and had the trout dip, wild one pizza 💯 , the Cesar salad. Everything was delicious. The vegan cheese actually tastes like cheese - perfect for someone who is lactose intolerant but loves pizza.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 5 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 4PM 5 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 4PM 5 - 8PM |
The Kaatskeller is a restaurant that offers a variety of delicious dishes, including tasty pizzas. The food is generally praised, and customers have found it to be a gem for new flavors inspired by traditional local favorites. The shareable quarter cider chicken was out of this world, and the brook trout dip was a really approachable take on a craveable Catskill culinary classic. The panko crusted trout and the Caesar salad with vegan dressing were also amazing, and the kids portion pizzas were enjoyed by young guests. The oatmilk gelato is exceptional, and the sundaes are very unique and refreshing. Some customers have noted that the pricing is a bit high for the location. The staff is described as kind and accommodating, but the dining experience can be impacted by factors such as uneven service, loud music, and an inconvenient seating arrangement.
The restaurant has received positive reviews from recent customers. The wood-fired pizzas are absolutely delicious and out of this world, with perfectly blistered crusts and a rich, flavorful sauce. The menu is uncomplicated and delicious, with some lovely twists on classic flavors and a strong focus on local ingredients, with each menu item highlighting its establishment by name and location. The outdoor seating is comfortable and quaint, and the atmosphere is a perfect mix of cozy mountain charm and elevated dining, reminiscent of a European old cabin converted into a warm, cozy restaurant. The staff is warm, gracious, and genuinely seems to care. It is an absolute gem and a great spot in the area.