Eduardo's Trattoria

115 Secor Rd, Mahopac
(845) 628-8888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Richard England

Sometimes it's good sometimes it's bad. No consistency.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Michele Caplan

Always get great food. Great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Casabianca

Good food. Pizzeria type atmosphere

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

April K

The arugula pesto chicken salad is the best salad maybe ever in the world.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cane GJ

I ordered a chicken parm hero and order of fries I will never eat there food ever!! Completely tasteless..bread was hard as tack bread and fries were those baked type u buy from the supermarket completely a waste of money !! Stay away from this place!! Not joking

Stacy Panzanaro

This quaint Italian restaurant was a great find. The food was DELICIOUS. The service was great, especially for a small business. It has a family vibe, but it also has a bar you can chill at and watch sports. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexis Doscas

This spot is my go to for amazing food and wonderful atmosphere. But what really makes it special is Kayleigh, the best waitress ever! She's super friendly, remembers my order every time, and just makes the whole experience way better. If you want great service and tasty dishes, this place is a must visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marlon H

I am a Chicken Francese haunter, and..
This place was FANTASTIC
Their food and preparation was absolutely astonishing that I really needed to give this comment because of the great experience in flavours and rich cuisine that me and my Fiancé had the pleasure to experience.
Without the need to exagerare I will give this place 6 stars!

What did we eat?
1 Chicken Francese
Extra lime✅
1 Caesar Salad
1 Order garlic knots
And a Cappuccino.

Don’t ask for how much, believe me you wont even care. It was delicious you will say.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sairis brito

Truly excellent work, guys. The food had a great flavor. The bread they gave me as an appetizer was delicious. I was served from the moment I arrived. Jose and Eduardo, keep doing a good job. And with this restaurant, I won't miss the Italian food from the Bronx.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fshah88

Such a great spot for group dinners or date night. I really enjoyed the vibe and the ambiance. It’s a very lively restaurant, they had great music and a nice crowd. I really liked the decor, felt very old school Italian but also had a modern twinkly feeling. Food: They started us off with bread and olives. The olives were really food had a nice flavoring to it and they also gave us olive oil. The bread was soft and nicely salted. I got the Penne alla Norma but switched it out for the pappardelle pasta. The pasta was freshly made and the sauce was well seasoned. The vegetables were well cooked and enhanced the flavors of the pasta. The dessert was AMAZING and memorable. We got the Caramello al cioccolato. It came out nice and hot and had a nice balance of chocolate and nuts. Service: Our waiter was hilarious. He had such a bold personality and was always joking with us.

Diane Gibbs

Went there last night with eight family members for a special occasion. The food was absolutely delicious and so much of it. The waitress was wonderful and so helpful.Will definitely be going back and am telling all our friends ,! Give it a try you will love it!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heather H

For the last three years I have catered food from Eduardo’s for my son’s birthday, and every time the food and service is exceptional. They are attentive to my requests for food allergies within the party, and I have never had a problem with cross contamination. Once again, the guests loved the food and we thank you Eduardo’s for all the great experiences!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bob Athanasidy

Perfect fried Calamari, the BEST homemade tomato sauce in the valley and excellent entrees and pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Marsala, Assorted Specialty Pizza by the Slice, Lasagna Di Casa

Johanna Tacuri

I love their food and is close to my house, the people are so nice and friendly

Corrine Pecoraro

We having been going to Eduardo’s for many years, I can say they consistently deliver! We decided about a year ago to stop ordering our usual and rotate to try everything on the menu. Of course, we were not disappointed, one of our new favorite’s for an Appetizer The burrata and beet salad and the steak, potato’s and broccoli entree! You want a good steak, don’t go to Char, go to Eduardo’s, you won’t be disappointed, the staff is amazing Kayleigh is one of our fav’s. Burgers are really good, all the pasta
Dishes… fish’s special’s…..Pizza all really good!

Loading...