Milk N Cookies - Cookie Café & Cereal Bar

Really good cookies here for the most part. Soft and chewy, so it makes it easier to share. I think it's the best out of the local spots. They use a heating lamp to keep the cookies warm, so it's always ready to go with no wait. The parking can be hit or miss on this busy street. If you go down the road past here and make a right at the traffic light, there's more street parking and a parking garage. The pro is parking is free on Sundays and I believe after a certain time on the weekdays. I'd recommend the oreo cheesecake, cookie monster, red velvet, and the recess cookies.

Pretty good!

my experience was amazing! gavin and friend were really helpful and served us the right cookie. they were very nice and kind. they are our friends!!

We stopped in after dinner across the street for some sweet treats to go. It was close to closing so we were limited to what they had left.

I decided to go with the Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie. Like a few other cookies shops the cookies are meant to share or eat in more than one sitting. My cookie was ok the flavor combo of oatmeal and chocolate chip was different. I would like to try them again when they have more menu options available and the cookies are freshly out the oven. I think that may enhance the experience.

Just A Note:

Parking can be hard to come by.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Once I order 2 chocolate Milkshake and paid, I was inform, that they run out of chocolate ice cream. The girl in charge didn’t know how handle the devolution to my card. This is insane. Eventually the owner have to train their employees for more likely situations.

THE BEST COOKIES EVER! When I say these are the best cookies, I MEAN IT. They’re so soft and taste delicious. Each cookie has as a different flavor and there are quite a few different options. The cookies aren’t too big and are the perfect size to eat at least two. Our favorite cookies are: Funfetti, Cookie Monster, Brookie, and the Italian Rainbow. They taste great with a nice cup of milk, hot or cold. They also make these delicious milkshakes where you can combine your favorite ice cream with your favorite cereal to blend, and then add a topping to it. You can also make a cookie Sunday with the cookie of your choice. This place is WAY better than the Crumbl Cookies. These cookies aren’t so sweet and sugary as the ones from Crumbl. Those are nothing compared to Milk N Cookies. They have multiple locations and are open until late which is great for a late night snack.

Parking: You can park on the street.

Kid-friendliness: Children will love the delicious cookies

Wheelchair accessibility: There are no steps so wheelchairs will have no problem coming in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Churro Stuffed Cookie, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Custom Milkshake Vanilla Ice Cream Caramel Drizzle, Funfetti Cookie, Cookie Monster Cookie, Churro, S'More Cookie, Cookie Monster Stuffed Cookie, Galaxy Stuffed Cookie, Assorted Cookies

I can tell all of you, that great cookies make people happy. A child is always happier when seeing artisian cookies like these. You eat with your eyes first. These are exciting cookies, visually stunning. an assortmant that I am sure, satisfies the vast tastes of the cookie public. Owners son Louis, & the workers, Vinnie, Justin, & Luca, are the nicest & polite people that I know. Phone orders are always ready upon customer arrival, to satisfy the busy world we all have to navigate. I have eaten cookies everywhere. These have the freshest ingredients in them. I suggest you have to go for a cold milk with them, great for dunking . Also for the adults who want to be taken back to their childhood, there are cereal combinations that blow away that supermarket commerical stuff we all ate as children

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A bit pricey but delicious....
Crumble who.. ?

I went in twice now on different days with an hour and more before they close. And they refused to make my girlfriend a milkshake. Tell your employees to stop being lazy and closing early.

Service: 1

Soft delicious cookies of your choice and vanilla ice cream, infused with apple jacks cereal or whatever cereal you like. The staff is friendly and welcoming, that's always nice. Very cute set up.

Parking: There is parking right there.

Kid-friendliness: Most kids like ice cream and cookies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie, Cookies on Display, Custom Milkshake Vanilla Ice Cream Caramel Drizzle, Cookies Are, Oreo Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip, Assorted Cookies

100% better than crumbl cookies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time going! The atmosphere was very clean and the smell of fresh cookies was great. The guy attending was very nice and patient with me as I made my decision on what cookies I wanted to try. Overall, the cookies are a nice size, soft and taste good. I was expecting to be wowed but none the less they were good cookies. I tried the Red Velvet, Peanut Butter Chip, Oatmeal and Confetti cookies. My fav was the Confetti Cookie! I'll try the ice cream next time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Funfetti Cookie, Ruby Red Velvet Cookie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

I ordered cookies last night for pick up and when they got home it just reminded me how amazing these cookies taste. I’ve been a fan for years now but last night was the first time in a few months that I had it again. Best cookie spot I’ve ever had in my life. ?

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Funfetti Cookie

Just picked up my order and my cookies were sooooo good and so fresh & hot. Thank you guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kudos on the creative aspect...great concept.

We had the plain chocolate chip and trip chocolate...they were good...but not great. I prefer the consistency of Crumbl
a bit better. The stuffed cookies may have a better consistency. I'll be sure to try one of those next time.

We also had a vanilla cone which was about $7 regardless of the amount of topping you add...or none at all. We decided to get a plain cone...and didn't sit well to pay $7 for a plain cone. But the concept of having unlimited topping for a set price may be appeaking to some...especially those who like to load up on toppings. On a good note, the soft serve vanilla was very good.

Large open and clean space with a few barstools and counter along the sides.

Metered parking along Mamaroneck Avenue.