Milk N Cookies - Cookie Café & Cereal Bar

270 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck
(914) 630-7276

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Custom Milkshake Vanilla Ice Cream Caramel Drizzle
Cookie Monster Stuffed Cookie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Ruby Red Velvet Cookie
Galaxy Stuffed Cookie
Cookie Monster Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Churro Stuffed Cookie
Cookies on Display
Assorted Cookies

Menu

Stuffed Cookies
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
Chocolate peanut butter cup cookie is dark chocolate and is studded with Reese's Pieces and filled with a creamy peanut butter.
Cookie Monster Stuffed Cookie
Blue sugar cookie stuffed with edible cookie dough right in the middle.
Oreo Cheese Cake Stuffed Cookie
Delicious dark chocolate cookie with large chunks of real Oreo pieces, and if that wasn't enough, it's filled with a warm creamy Oreo cheesecake.
Unicorn Stuffed Cookie
A creamy strawberry cheesecake finds a home in a colorful rainbow sugar cookie and sprinkled with sparkly edible magic.
Oatmeal Apple Pie Crumble Stuffed Cookie
A warm delicious apple pie center encrusted in a crispy gooey cinnamon oatmeal cookie.
Oatmeal Raisin
Oatmeal in a brown sugar cookie with sweet and fruity raisins throughout.
Grape Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie
Delicious peanut butter cookie, purple sprinkles, and luscious grape jelly.
Brookie
A chocolate chip cookie twisted with a chocolate cookie studded with white chocolate chips, and filled with brownie batter.
Churro Cookie
Our traditional snickerdoodle cookie gets a punch of Latin flavor with a creamy warm dulce de leche center.
Churro Nutella Cookie
Traditional snickerdoodle cookies marries beautifully with its nutty and creamy Nutella center.
Red Velvet White Chocolate Cheesecake Cookie
These treats feature a classic red velvet cookie with creamy white chocolate chips and are filled with cheesecake.
Banana Nut Cookie Butter Cookie
Delicious brown sugar banana cookie gets a healthy handful of crunchy walnuts and is jam-packed full with Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter.

Non-Stuffed Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Gooey traditional chocolate chip cookie with the finest quality semi sweet chocolate drops, and baked to perfection.
Smores Cookie
The chocolate chip cookie gets a twist of cinnamon and a healthy heap of marshmallows on top to round out this campfire favorite.
Triple Chocolate Cookie
This is a dark chocolate cookie mixed with the finest of white and milk chocolate chips drops.
Chocolate Chip Walnut
A twist on our traditional chocolate chip who doesn't enjoy some extra crunch in their warm and gooey chocolate chip cookie.
Funfetti Cookie
Traditional sugar cookie with sprinkles baked right in.

Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cup

Beverages

Cereal Infused Milkshake
Cereal infused milk shake. Pick your favorite cereal. Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry.
Whole Milk
Chocolate Milk
Strawberry Milk
Almond Milk (Vanilla)
Coca Cola
Diet Coca Cola
Grape Soda
Orange Soda
A&W Root Beer
Dr. Pepper
Sprite
A&W Root Beer Float
Bottle of Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Came here with the family, Tyler was so sweet charismatic and helpful. Made my daughter feel very welcome. The cookies and milk were perfect after dinner sweets. Thank you Tyler for the hospitality.
July 2025
The cookies are good, but Taj's customer service was better! He was friendly, accommodating, and sweet.
Get the cookie monster cookie, it's so tasty! Best shared with folks you love.
May 2025
My husband and I were visiting the town and craving something sweet. Luckily, we stumbled upon this dessert cookie shop with an inviting exterior, so we decided to check it out—and it did not disappoint!

Yes, the cookies are on the pricier side, but honestly, they’re even better than the famous (and overrated) Crumbl!

Please don’t ever take the Churro Nutella Cookies off the menu—those are my absolute favorite! I even told my husband...
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Green Life - 266 Mamaroneck Ave
Health Food, Salad, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Healthy, Pet Friendly
Tentempie Madrid - 260 Mamaroneck Ave
Tapas Bar, Tapas/Small Plates, Spanish
Boiano Bakery - 258 Mamaroneck Ave
Bakery, Custom Cakes, Vegetarian

Milk N Cookies - Cookie Café & Cereal Bar

270 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543
(914) 630-7276