Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar

211 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck
(914) 899-3130

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dr Iyad

Excellent menu options, tried most of the dishes and all were cooked to perfection ! Very hospitable & welcoming! Excellent & attentive service !

Stephen

Nonna is consistently on top of their game. From food quality to quantity to service — all around it's a fabulous establishment. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Soon Seng

Service is very bad. We asked for some additional bread like 5 times but never came. Also, it takes like 15 minutes to get a menu, order and check

Audrey

Everyone in our group enjoyed their meal.. the veal chop was cooked right and delicious . Chicken martini and chicken Marsala were very good. The pasta condole was delicious. The endive salad was good , the Cesare salad was excellent as was the beef carpaccio. Chicken soup was so so. Service was ok for a busy Saturday night. Will return for sure!

Erica K

Dined here on Sunday 8/31st, dinner reservation for a party of 10 ladies celebrating a friend's MBA graduation.
We were greeted and seated promptly upon arrival. We sat in the back outdoor/patio area.
Elvis and all staffed that tended to our table were phenomenal!
Tiger shrimp appetizer serving size was generous, taste lacked some flavor.
Cocktails - pretty but inconsistent, could use some improvement here.
Truffle Trenette - absolutely perfection 👌🏽 (chef's kiss!). We added shrimp and mushrooms to the entree.

I'd absolutely recommend this restaurant and return very soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jose Taveras

Sublime.
I was not expecting it. The setting is gorgeous. The food was perfect and the service was just right. This is a place for something special

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

L V

This is a pretty and romantic Albanian-owned Italian restaurant with attentive service, some unique fresh-made pasta dishes, and generous portions — which is a good thing given the higher than average cost for the meal. But our fare went from excellent to disappointing. The cracker bread starter made in-house was crispy and yummy. The riceball appetizer was fresh and delicious as was the roasted artichoke with arugula salad side, which was perfectly seasoned with a lovely balsamic vinaigrette. The fresh-made mushroom ravioli were good but they were swimming in a bland cream sauce that could have been reduced and used more cognac flavor and spice; and the tomatoes and spinach topping just didn’t mesh with the dish. Finally, our lemon sole was overcooked and dry, very disappointing, although the roast potatoes and spinach sides were tasty. For the price, we expected much better but it was a nice enough experience given the atmosphere that we’d consider returning to try other dishes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Al

Went with the extended family of adult children and spouses for our anniversary dinner. Wait staff was attentitive, food timely and very good. overall a great expeience and highly recommend.

A C

Enjoyed the hospitality from the hostess, service was professional. Food was delicious and accommodating to assist. Handicap accessible. Parking either at the lot or the street, pay at the meter or through the app.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jeffrey N Sayegh

First time here, and I must say I was impressed.
The food was spectacular, the service was great, the prices are fair 👍 the quality is great. Good job guys. I will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dmitri

We've been to Nonna Carola many times over the past couple of years and it never falls short of excellent.

Steven

Food was superb. Bottle of wine had started to turn to vinegar. Waiter was unsure what to do. But maitre d was spot on offering us a replacement bottle. Just a delight of an evening in the outdoor patio.

Dr Richard

Very attentive staff. Beautiful ambiance Food was pretty good not outstanding but prices were in line with what we ordered. Would go again. Drinks were very good

BB

Beautiful atmosphere with great vibes. Awesome menu and food. I think the portions could be slightly larger, but looking forward to going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mercy Graciano

Food was delicious. Service for our private event was amazing. The place has a chic and classic anesthetic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Loading...