Bagel Plaza of South Merrick
1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
(516) 378-3455
Customers' Favorites
Poached Salmon Salad Sandwich with Dill Celery and a Drop of Mayo
Was and Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese with Diced Scallions
Any Sandwich on the Flat
Baker's Dozen of Bagels
Bagel and Lox Sandwich
Freshly Baked Pastries
Whole-Wheat Bagel
Apple Turnovers
Egg Salad
Bagels & Bagel Products
Bagels
Pick you own bagel(s)Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Everything, whole wheat everything, egg, egg onion, egg everything, salt, rye, pumpernickel, raisin, pumpernickel onion, garlic, and onion.
Bagel Flats
Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, salt, sunflower seed, and whole wheat.
Bagel Twist
Rye with salt; rye no salt, pumpernickel with plain, and pumpernickel with plain no salt.
Gluten Free Flat
Plain or everything bagel flats made in house * please note, although we do have careful, we are not a gluten free facility.
Mini Bagels
Plain, poppy, sesame, whole wheat, plain bialys, and everything.
Soy Bagels
Plain, sesame, everything low carb bagels made with soy flour.
Mini Twists
Plain or salt.
Baker's Dozen
Plain, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, garlic, whole-wheat, pumpernickel, salt, egg, egg onion, egg everything, and rye.
Bagel Packages
Small Brunch Package
6 bagels, ½ pound of plain, ½ pound of nova Scotia lox sliced thin, ½ pound tuna salad, 1/2 pound egg salad, 1/2 Gallon OJ, 1/2 pound signature in house made ruggelah .
Medium Brunch Package
1 dozen bagels, ½ pound plain cream cheese, ½ veggies or scallion cream cheese, 1 pound tuna, 1 pound egg salad, 1/2 nova scotia sliced thin, 12 mini muffins assorted.
Homemade Soup
Homemade Soup
Please call for our daily soup selections.
Salad Bar Station
Fruit Salad
1 lb.
Tossed Salad Large
Chef Salad Small
House Special Salad Large
Greek Salad Large
Salads | ½ Pound
Egg Mushroom Salad
With sauteed mushrooms and onions.
Egg Whites Spinach Salad
With a drop of mayo and lemon juice.
Eggs, Lox & Scallions Salad
egg salad with nova and scallions.
Egg Salad
Eggs, mayonnaise, salt and pepper.
Tuna & Vegetable Salad
Carrots, celery, and very little mayo.
White Fish Salad
The finest whitefish chopped with eggs and mayo.
Tuna Salad
Chunk white tuna with mayonnaise.
Chunky White Fish Salad
With a touch of mayo.
Baked Salmon Salad
Chopped with eggs and mayo.
Egg Whites Salad
With a touch of mayo, carrots and celery.
Garden Tuna Salad
Carrots, broccoli, raisins and red cabbage, touch of mayo.
"Seafood" Salad
Imitation of crab meat, celery and a little mayo.
Potato Salad
Potatoes, carrots, peppers, eggs, mayonnaise.
Poached Salmon Salad
With dill, celery and a drop of mayo.
Honey Mustard Tuna Salad
With real honey and mustard.
Israeli Salad
Diced tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and peppers with balsamic vinegar.
Chopped Nova Salad
Chopped or Creamed Herring Salad
House Special Sandwiches
Thinly Hand Sliced Nova or Belly Lox Sandwich
Your choice of any cream cheese on a bagel with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion and side.
If you want it open faced, must specify and it is $1.50 extra.
Avocado Nova Toast (Open Face)
Toasted onion or plain bialy lightly buttered with sliced nova, avocado topped with sea salt.
Grandpa Special with Nova Sandwich
Choice of bagel with egg salad and smooth whitefish and thinly hand-sliced Nova Scotia.
Request if you want open face, extra 1.50
Kippered Salmon or Sable Sandwich
Your choice of any cream cheese on a any bagel or bialy with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion.
Nova with Fried Eggs Sandwich (Open Face)
Your choice of bagel flavor toasted with a schmear of cream cheese, thinly hand-sliced.
Butter Bagel
Bagel & Butter
Cream Cheese Sandwich
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
With carrots, celery, peppers and radish.
Regular Cream Cheese Sandwich
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
With diced scallions.
Nova Cream Cheese Sandwich
With smoked nova bits.
Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese Sandwich
With brown sugar, cinnamon, raisins and walnuts.
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich
With black and green stuffed olives.
Low Fat Nova Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
Low fat nova scallion cream cheese sandwich.
Chocolate Cream Cheese Sandwich
With sugar, vanilla, liquid chocolate.
Low Fat Cream Cheese Sandwich
Twist with Butter
Twist with Cream Cheese
Blueberry Cream Cheese Sandwich
With real blueberries, sugar and vanilla.
Salads Sandwich
Garden Tuna Sandwich
Carrots, broccoli, raisins and red cabbage, touch of mayo.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Chunk white tuna with mayonnaise.
Egg Mushroom Salad Sandwich
With sauteed mushrooms and onions.
Tuna & Vegetables Sandwich
Carrots, celery, and very little mayo.
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
Chopped with eggs and mayo.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Eggs, mayonnaise, salt and pepper.
Egg Whites Salad Sandwich
With a touch of mayo, carrots and celery.
Egg Whites Spinach Salad Sandwich
With a drop of mayo and lemon juice.
Chopped Nova Salad Sandwich
Chopped or Creamed Herring Salad Sandwich
Chunky White Fish Salad Sandwich
Poached Salmon Salad Sandwich
With dill, celery and a drop of mayo.
White Fish Salad Sandwich
The finest whitefish is chopped with eggs and mayo.
"Seafood" Salad Sandwich
Imitation of crab meat, celery, drop of mayo.
Eggs, Lox & Scallions Sandwich
Honey Mustard Tuna Sandwich
With real honey and mustard.
From Grandma's Kitchen
French Toast
Challah French toast served with powdered sugar and syrup on side.
Blintzes
Cheese, cherry cheese, blueberry cheese.
Latkes
Homemade latkes.
Smoked Fish
Nova Lox
Thinly hand-sliced nova per ¼ pound.
Pickled Lox
¼ lb. with onions and cream sauce.
Sable Plate
Thinly hand-sliced sable per ¼ lb pound.
Belly Lox
¼ lb thinly hand-sliced belly lox.
Herring Fillet
Per piece includes homemade cream sauce and onions.
Kippered Salmon
¼ lb.
Whole White Fish
¼ lb filet.
Cream Cheese | ½ Pound
Plain Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
With diced scallions.
Vegetable Cream Cheese
With carrots, celery, peppers and radish.
Olive Cream Cheese
With black and green stuffed olives.
Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese
With brown sugar, cinnamon, raisins and walnuts.
Blueberry Cream Cheese
With real blueberries, sugar and vanilla.
Nova Cream Cheese
With smoked nova bits.
Butter
Chocolate Cream Cheese
With sugar, vanilla, liquid chocolate.
Low Fat Cream Cheese
Low Fat Cream Cheese | ½Pound
Nova Scallion Cream Cheese
With smoked nova bits and scallions.
Baked Goods
Cigars
Each.
Apple Turnovers
Each.
Black & Whites
Each.
Ruggulah
Our signature ruggelah made in house: raisin with walnuts, powdered chocolate, raspberry walnut, chocolate raspberry raisin.
Mini Home Made Cookies
Mini rainbow sprinkle, chocolate sprinkle, chocolate chip cookie.
Mini Cookies
Linzer stars.
Linzer Tarts
Each.
Large Cookies
Each. Sprinkle, (chocolate or multi-color); large chocolate chips cookies or croissants.
Gourmet Cookies
1 lb. home made chocolate chunk cookies.
French Cookies
1 lb. assortment of delicious butter cookies included pink and green leaf cookies, chocolate.
Sugar Free Ruggulah
1 lb. apricot or raspberry.
Gourmet Muffins
Muffins
Homemade muffins baked daily.
Corn, Blue berry, Cinn. Chip, Marble, Banana nut, Cranberry walnut, Cranberry mandarin walnut, choc. chip, double choc chip, double choc cheesecake, bran, red velvet.
Mini muffins - Choose flavors
Corn, cinn chip, choc. chip, blueberry, banana nut, double choc. and double choc cheese.
Challah
Challah
Plain, raisin.
Challah Rolls
Plain or raisin.
Pretzels Challah
Bialys & Bialy Products
Onion Bialys
Stix & Onion Roll
Onion Boards
Plain Bialys
Mini Bialys
Extras
Tomato
Lettuce
Onion
Open Face Sandwich
Avocado
Pickle
On a Twist
Any Sandwich On the Flat
Coffee
Iced Coffee
Hot Coffee
Drinks & Grocery Items
Tropicana Orange Juice
Pints.
Snapple
Lemon, peach, raspberry, half and half, diet lemon, diet peach, diet raspberry, diet h&h.
Tropicana ½ Gallons
Gatorade Red
Chocolate Ouicks
Temptee Cream Cheese
Sport Cap Water
Half & Half
Strawberry Quicks
½ Gallon Milk
Tropicana Apple Juice
Low Fat Philadelphia
8 oz.
Gatorade Blue
Philadelphia Cream Cheese
Small Poland Spring
Breakstone Salted Butter Tubs
8 oz.
Fruit Cup
½ Skim
Dozen Eggs
Large or jumbo eggs.
20 Oz. Bottles Soda
Coke, diet coke, diet Pepsi, ginger ale, seltzers.
Juices
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice 1/2 Pint
Freshly Squeezed Grape Fruit Juice 1/2 Pint
Freshly Squeezed OJ Full Pint
Freshly Squeezed OJ Full Pint
Freshly Squeezed Grapefruit Juice Full Pint
Freshly Squeezed Grapefruit Juice Full Pint
From the Grill
Egg & Cheese
American, swiss or muenster on a bagel or challah roll.
Any Melted Cheese Bagels
Open face melted cheese sandwich with either: American, swiss or muenster cheese.
2 Eggs Any Style
Includes your choice of bagel or a challah roll.
Omelettes
With your choice of veggies: red or green peppers, onions, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli and tomatoes.
Eggs, Lox & Onions Omlette
Please specify if you would like a bagel on side.
Egg-White, Spinach, Feta, Avocado Omelette
Includes a bagel, please specify if want a bagel on side and which flavor. We do not use butter.
1 Egg Any Style
Includes a bagel of your choice.
2 Egg Whites On a Roll
Includes your choice of bagel or a challah roll.
Tuna Melted Cheese
Open-faced tuna salad with melted cheese. Please specify America, swiss or muenster.
Photos
+70 photos
+69 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I love the bagels and lox from here. It's been a family tradition, and has been one of the things that has held us together. Thank you, Bagel Plaza. Your everything bagels are everything.
October 2024
The food and the service was very very nice, they know their stuff here, great bakers and recipe makers, try any of the salads or spreads you won't be disappointed
Wheelchair accessibility: To put in an order yes it has two big doors ?
Wheelchair accessibility: To put in an order yes it has two big doors ?
July 2024
I am always in the mood for a bagel, but am fearful of new bagel stores, because a lot of them do not offer what I call a bagel. This place does. A real old-time establishment, with seating, bathrooms, and really excellent bagels and coffee. At least a half dozen employees behind the counter, all of whom were very helpful and personable. Separate room with tables & chairs & two bathrooms. Food and coffee were really delicious. Huge free parking area right around the corner....
January 2024
You May Also Like
China Garden - 1700 Merrick Rd
![]()
Chinese
Frankie’s Pizzeria & Restaurant - 1696 Merrick Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Burger King - 1727 Merrick Rd
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food