Five Guys

2099 Merrick Rd, Merrick
(516) 208-8601

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nicole A M

The Arab guy who's the cashier and cook was so welcoming, polite and easy going. Burgers were hot & tasty and fries are always fried upon arrival so they're always hot. Best location in Nassau County.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Bonner

Service was nice, it was clean, foods good. but the prices are outrageous. Trust me you'll be better off taking your date to a diner or a sit-in restaurant. Just way too much for just a burger and fries.

Soul Imagens

Update 2, yesterday and today I've been there and the new person that is serving fried is fulfilling ONLY the paper cup. Yesterday I ordered a small it came only the cup with fries. Today I said to myself if it's the same person, I Will order a regular cause there will be more fries. NO! There was only the cup with the frfriesi paid a regular and got the same than the small. Only the cup with fries. Can someone teach this person the 5guys standards?

Update 1 everything went to normal. Yasmin is great and fulfill the bag with fries!

I just go there because of the fries and today I got a regular size one, but it was exactly like the small size portion. That is happening for a while I waited to make a review hoping it would not happen again, but yes, seems that the quantity of fries in the bag are much less now than it used to be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Laura Ejiofor

The variety of the shakes are great and it always tastes great!

Food: 5

Marc H

One thing is always certain with Five Guys: the quality of the ingredients is lockstep consistent and the food is always very good, even if the price is a bit steep. The hamburgers always taste great, fries are served in (over)abundance and drinks are always great thanks to the Coca-Cola custom drink machines. Shakes are also great. Easy to beat on price, sure, but nearly impossible to beat on quality of the products.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Their Cheeseburger, Bacon Burger

Martin Jablonski

Really good burgers and fries
Always friendly workers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Five Guys Style, Cheeseburger

J B

Good food. But $46 for 2 plain burgers, 2 small fries, and one drink?! WHAT?
We'll never go back. Five guys is a rip-off. 😧

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Hank Adler

They gave me wrong items!

Mike Hauben

I love getting home 30 min away and aeeibg half my food missing.

jconthegreat

It’s just a cheeseburger how great can it be? The answer, just fine, because it’s a cheeseburger. $12 for a burger, just the burger. Want fries and a drink, you’re looking at lunch for upwards of $25, ridiculous you can go to any restaurant for less than that. I ordered a cheeseburger, I specifically said “I only want a cheeseburger, all the way, and nothing else” what does the lady at the register ask in broken English?

Want any fries? No, just the burger.
Want a drink? No, just the burger.
Want a milkshake? NO, just the burger.

STOP TRYING TO UPSELL ME! Especially on such highway robbery prices that they’re expecting here. It’s ground beef and potatoes, not expensive at all. Maybe if the prices were reasonable I’d consider one of your multiple attempts to suck more money out of me. But as for now, just a small cheeseburger and NOTHING else.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Melissa Johnson

Staff was friendly and the Reese's milkshake was awesome

Parking: It's in a little strip mall.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Cheese, Bacon Burger

Patrick I.

Yesterday my coworkers and I went to Five Guys for lunch. This place was great. Very clean. Nothing fancy. Great service. Especially the girl in the black shirt who took our order, which makes the place a little different than what is in Merrick. Really good food. What else is there to say? 100%

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheeseburger

Tamika Cox

Food was great. I just love the old school burger joint vibe.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Five Guys Style, Hot Dog, Hamburger, Cheeseburger

Jay Greenblatt

I was very dissatisfied and disappointed at the end of all of it and won’t be going back anytime soon because even though the fries are good, “they ain’t all that.”

My wife and I haven’t been to Five Guys in quite some time and paid over $40 for two kind of overdone double burgers, two shakes (There is only one size, if that is of any interest) and one large order of fries. The fries and shakes were decent. To say that my wife and I had some degree of stickers shock is an understatement.

We both agreed that for that much money we could have gone to quite a few sit down restaurants, all within a few minutes of this location, AND not only have been served at a table but also gotten a couple of beers and much better food and atmosphere.

The interior was clean in a general sense, mostly due to how much white is visible in their decor but the tables were definitely much less than clean. It seemed like they rely on their patrons to wipe them down with the dry napkins after they eat, which we did as a matter of habit. The problem is that the peanut shell creates crumbs and dust and peanut shell skins, along with the spilled salt and other things from the food needs more than that.

I also had to ask after our shakes when I saw, a few minutes after getting our food, that no one was even looking at or attending to the shake making station. The person giving out the food had to double back after I asked about them to make our shakes.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Gizem Nacir

So so delicious. The burger is so fresh and good. Definitely feels healthier than many other burger chains because it isn’t as oily.
Just a tip for first time visitors, the hamburger is actually huge, get the little hamburger if you want it to be regular sized.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...