Athens Diner
$ • Diners, American, Greek
Hours:
837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
(631) 775-9888
About Athens Diner
Customers' Favorites
Athens Diner Reviews
Share your opinion about Athens Diner
This place was a terrible disappointment. My mother and I ordered burgers to take out and they were just AWFUL. The burger was more fat than meat, there was PAPER in two bites that I took. I even felt a little sick after eating it, I had to take TUMS to settle my stomach. This was a hole in the wall I almost turned around just because it looked sketchy (should have trusted my instincts). The ONLY good thing was the service the people were very nice. But the food- I just cannot justify ever returning for that quality.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 3PM |
People in Middle Island Also Viewed
The Athens Diner is a welcoming restaurant known for its delicious and attractively presented food, offering large portions and friendly service. The diner provides a classic diner experience with great breakfast options, including the best bacon and a very good breakfast that customers love. Many enjoy items like corned beef, breakfast potatoes, chicken salad sandwiches, Greek salad, spinach pie, and the homemade dressing, which is highly praised. The chef's meals, such as sauteed liver with bacon and onions, are cooked perfectly and served with tasty sauces, french fries, corn, and fresh Greek salad, with many dishes finished completely. The baklava for dessert remains a favorite among customers. The restaurant is clean, with convenient parking. Reviewers appreciate the warm atmosphere created by the staff, including a beautiful older waitress who adds a homey touch, making guests feel at ease. The staff, including the manager, is praised for being patient and kind, often feeling like a family restaurant. Overall, the Athens Diner is highly recommended for its awesome food and wonderful service, making it a place customers want to revisit.