15 Best Diners near Middle Island

“We have eaten in the Athens Diner a number of times, for breakfast, this time lunch. It is clean, the staff are happy to serve, the food is delicious and served attractively. I had a roast beef on whole wheat bread, so good! Thank you so much! Oh! Parking has always been esay!“

“This is the best kept secret in PJS. The owners and staff are incredible. The food is always delicious and the portions are huge. They treat everyone like family and know everyone by name. My husband and I go there at least once a week. I can't say enough about this place.“

“I haven't been to Jimmy's in a while. My breakfast was exactly the same as it was the last time I was there. I used to eat there almost every weekend.The food is cooked perfectly every single time. I have never once had something I did not like. Always a warm feeling when you dine at Jimmy's!!“

“Go there… this place is great! Hey, guess what… it’s a Diner!Great food… welcoming and friendly staff and wait til you taste the food…Now… a lot of people go through their doors and they are very busy… but that’s what makes ‘em great! The cacaphony of happy people, and a professional team dazzling you with their smiles!Sure… try the rest…BUT, THEN GO TO THE BEST!Sorry to hear about the “grumpy pusses” out there but don’t believe em…“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We love the Holbrook diner! When you walk in, you’re instantly greeted with kindness and a very friendly genuine, positive vibe from the staff. The owners are extremely friendly and accommodating.Food is incredible and freshly made. The diner has a wide assortment of choices at reasonable prices. Place is very clean and modern.Service is impeccable. Highly recommend the Holbrook diner ❤️“

“Normally service is very good 5 stars, but this visit the girl was not friendly or helpful. She couldn’t remember what toast I ordered and the potatoes were soggy and when I said something about it, she just walked away when she could have offered a replacement. We asked for napkins and she brought them when she brought the check. We will have to stay with our regular server Mike next time.“

“Have only gone for breakfast. Always consistent. Eggs over always perfect.French Toast is as good as homemade. I'm very picky about sausage links. Love them here.Parking: Located in small strip mall. Vertical parking out front more in back.“

“The place, food and environments is excellent. Price is ok. One detail , after one hour and a half , they bring you the ticket to pay . We spent $600 hundred dollars for 6 members. The manager came to the table, and asked us to leave or stay in the bar. They needed the table for others who were waiting. I feel it is an inconvenience, they clocking your time,. You have to wait for the food to be prepared and that is half an hour of the time they give you which it is 1 1/2 hr. I did not like that approach . Next time, will only go to the bar.“

“Pleased to say I’ve had an amazing experience at this diner. My server Jessica was super sweet. The entire staff is extremely attentive and friendly, making my visit extra special. The chopped steak I ordered was cooked to perfection, juicy and flavorful. Everything from the welcoming atmosphere to the top-notch service made my meal memorable. Definitely a five-star experience! Can't wait to go back!"“

“The place is immaculate, the espresso machine looked like a mirror it was so clean, and the food was delicious, we had corn beef hash and eggs ? the coffee was on point and the waitress Lauren did not let our coffee go low. Definitely recommend this “

“This place has stepped up its game and is back to being a top Long Island contender. The new menu items are glorious and none of the classics are gone. Giant upgrade for the Dennys franchise overall. Go ahead and check it out,I am very impressed with what they have done there.“

“We were greeted with smiling faces and promptly seated. We both ordered patty melt sandwiches. Although we weren't asked how we wanted them cooked, they were cooked medium rare and were perfect! Ample sauted onions. Lovely dill pickle, fresh crunchy Cole slaw that tasted home made. Delicious coffee. The French fries were cooked crisp on the outside, fluffy on inside. The diner was clean. Chicken orzo soup came with the meal and had a full chicken flavor. Very satisfying meal at this diner!“

“Absolutely love this diner! It’s become a family favorite and weekly stop!! Great place to come as a family or just as a date night. Amazing staff and friendly, clean place also quick service! We will always love this diner ❤️“

“We have come to the Heritage Diner multiple times and were never disappointed. I was surprised when I noticed that I'd not left a review. The inside has three sections all equally comfortable. We sat in the room to the right of the register. It was quiet and welcoming. Lucille, our server was patient and helpful in answering all our questions. She checked in with us without being overbearing. The food was fabulous! I haven't had a grilled cheese sandwich in years but they had a page in the menu with an assortment of options and pictures! I really enjoyed the creamy cheese and crispy toast. Plus, perfect fries. My husband’s salad was unique and delicious. Highly recommend the Heritage Diner.“

“I really enjoyed my experience. The atmosphere was light & fun. We had a great server, he was friendly, & knowledgeable. I can honestly say, that the French toast was one of the best tasting I've ever had..The fruit was fresh! We had a lovely time, we will definitely be back!“