Village Pizzeria

4 State St, Middleport
(716) 735-7621

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Pizza Steak Sub Yummmmm

Garlic Bread Supreme

Fisherman's Platter

Chicken Fingers

Fish Fry Dinner

Pretzel Sticks

Chicken Wings

The Big Hoagie

Breaded Wings

White Pizza

Photos

+43 photos

+42 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Just ordered for the first time. Was told the hometown sauce was just like pony’s original from before the new owners changed it. Let me tell you we are not disappointed!! We got both wings and fingers. By far blows pony’s out of the water!! We’re customers for life now!! My son says it’s his new favorite wings from anywhere around. We will definitely be back!!

March 2025

We were in the area after my son's basketball game and decided to give this place a try based on their reviews. I'm so glad that we did. I ordered during the game, so there was a lot of noise in the background, but the young girl who took my order was very patient and understanding. When I went in to pick up my order, there were two girls behind the counter, the one who took my order and another. These girls were both so friendly, big smiles, and they made me feel like...

February 2025

The pizza here is my go to spot for good pizza. I have closer pizzerias I can go to but to me it's worth the couple extra minutes drive. I have been going here for many many years and will continue to.

December 2023

More Reviews

Restaurants in Middleport, NY

Village Pizzeria

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Village Pizzeria