Pony's Irish Pub
$ • Bars, Irish Pub, Pubs
Hours:
23 Main St Suite 1, Middleport
(716) 735-9989
About Pony's Irish Pub
Customers' Favorites
Pony's Irish Pub Reviews
Share your opinion about Pony's Irish Pub
Very uncomfortable experience at Pony’s. Was the community yard sale day In middleport so would obviously be busy and they had only one girl running the entire place. This particular girl was also VERY pregnant and had her tank top hiked up with her entire belly showing. It was strange to see at a bar, as a waitress serving people and taking orders. Felt very uncomfortable. And service was incredibly slow.
Their chicken fingers are totally different then the once were! Not even close to the ones Mr Ed’s and early pony’s once served and it’s expensive asf
Place is horrible. First time I ordered they messed up the order.. second time they over charged me and the rude blonde bartender got pissed when something was said and smacked the money down rolled her eyes and went and ran her mouth with the other girl. Avoid this dump.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Middleport Also Viewed
Pony's Irish Pub is a recently remodeled establishment with a bright and modern atmosphere, featuring an updated bar and multiple TVs. The owners are friendly and welcoming, and the staff provides good service. The menu offers a range of tasty options, including the crispiest fish fry and great-sized portions. Prices are reasonable, with meals starting at $65 for four people. The kids' menu features popular items like burgers and chicken fingers, which are a hit with kids. Customers praise the excellent drinks, delicious food, and the new family boxes that include 2lbs of tenders, 2lbs of fries, mozzarella sticks, and pretzel sticks—enough to feed a family of five for less than $60. The pub has a friendly, sports bar vibe, and while it has multiple TVs, some guests wish there were more in the dining area so they could see the game while eating. Overall, Pony's Irish Pub offers a good atmosphere, tasty food, and friendly staff, making it a place worth visiting.