Sister's Island Cuisine

180 Wickham Ave, Middletown
(845) 343-8650

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jean Bellevue

Oxtail was great.

Kiya Rheubottom

Sister's has completely fell off! I visited on 6/13/2025 and purchased Jerk Pork to go. I arrived home and the pork wasn't the pork they would usually sell! It was fatty, it was pork but something wasn't right with this pork! We consumed more before throwing the entire meal out! About 24 hours later my husband and I fell sick! I mean stomach sickness, diarrhea, and headaches. We were baffled and then remembered the nasty JERK PORK that could have been contaminated or uncooked! Please be careful because this used to be our favorite spot for sometime, but idk what's going on with the food anymore! I miss when Mario cooked the food it was fresher!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Shawn Williams

The food is authentic Jamaican food it good 👍 some of employees are pleasant

update on my review my husband just came back with oxtails and food 5 pieces of oxtails this is ridiculous I will be making my own no more eating out in officially done spending money out to eat and be giving scraps

The taste is okay for the value of money it’s short

Want to put up this picture

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Fay Lewis

If you’re going to charge $11 for a soup, it should have food and meat in it. I purchased a large soup, and all it had in it was two dumplings and hardly any meat. The little meat that was in it were scraps. If I lived closer I would have returned it to the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Rida Bouharoun

I ordered jerk chicken with rice and vegetables and they were out of vegetables and plantain and they still charged me full price. No hot sauce either !

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ven W.

Food wasn't the best. Barbi fry chicken tasted a bit old and was dry. The oxtail was decent, but the rice was soft. Needs to upgrade quality.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Oxtail \u0026 Rice and Peas

Augie R.

I've had dinner twice from here,,, the jerk chicken, rice with peas, sweet plantains, and steamed cabbage and a Arizona Iced Tea. I have zero complaints. Everything was seasoned well and they give you plenty. Everything I mentioned was less than $20 dollars and I paid with my debit card, not sure if there's a price difference with cash. Either way, where are you going to eat dinner for less than $20 dollars and it's all cooked from scratch, can't even go get fast food in the equal amount of food they give for that price.
The restaurant is very clean, you can smell the food when you go in and there's a variety of food to choose from. Get there early cause if you want oxtail it goes quick, but there's plenty of food to choose from. You will not be disappointed I can assure you that. I highly recommend checking this place out, bring your family and bring your appetite or you will have lunch for the next day. The staff is pleasant, it's clean and nice to get a home cooked meal not some processed garbage from the chain restaurants around here. By the way I ordered a "Large" so that's the size you see in the picture I posted, but they have medium and small so order accordingly.

Vegetarian options: Very few vegan items,,, but im not vegan so it doesn't matter to me.

Parking: Plenty of parking !

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly for sure !

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, it is wheelchair accessible!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jerk Chicken, Steamed Cabbage, Rice and Peas

greg nyce

The owner of the store was very rude! Because of my dietary needs, I asked her to separate the food, and asked for smaller portions, although I was willing to pay for it . She yelled at me and practically threw me out. I only go there for the jerk, chicken, but everything else, especially the rice always seem to taste unfresh.

C Rollins

The first time I purchased oxtails from this establishment was back in June and they were absolutely delicious. The second time I purchased oxtails a month later in July they were OK. The third time being today October 24, 2024 the oxtails did not pass the test. They were very tough and did not fall off the bone at all. The rest of the meal was OK, but I was extremely disappointed. So now I’m forced to look for another place.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Danny G

Excellent jerk chicken

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dolores Leger

Oxtail was uncooked
no taste or flavor rice was not good cheap parboiled rice
fried chicken was not well seasoned .

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

P.O Santiago Sr

The food and, the service sucks. The young girl that was there doesn’t smile doesn’t say hi. she walks up and down with out asking if you need help. . She won’t even ask you if you’re ready. customer service there sucks I will not be buying anything there no more. The chicken was disgusting did not have any flavor, But it’s my fault for trying new places.I stick with yardee

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Greg Jones

Good food and good people. I definitely recommend this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef Patty, Stewed Chicken, Oxtail & Rice and Peas, Steamed Cabbage, Rice and Peas

Saran Smith

Got the oxtail with white rice and was a little disappointed by the white rice. Went before and got the rice and peas and enjoyed this a lot more.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Karen Sherrod

Food is always great ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...