The BlackSheep at Miller Place
$$ • American, Pet Friendly
Hours:
465 NY-25A, Miller Place
(631) 828-5554
About The BlackSheep at Miller Place
Customers' Favorites
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about The BlackSheep at Miller Place
We found this place after seeing it on Facebook. This place is incredible, great staff, super professional & friendly, and the food is incredible. My husband is gluten free, and the owner reviewed the menu with us to let us know what was and wasn’t. There are so many GF options. Everything fried is fried with rice flour, which is incredible. We order the Lillys little pickle, grilled cheese with bacon on gluten free bread, with the soup of the day which was split pea soup. And...read full review
Wow wow wow.
Just went there for a party, the pulled pork was crazy! Mac and cheese: insane. But the leader in the clubhouse was the beef on a Stick. Great food. Fun atmosphere. Amazing experience, I’ll be back.
The Black Sheep is a new restaurant in Miller Place on Rt. 25A that I heard of from a friend of 30 years. The food is outstanding delightful and every order is prepared with Heart and Soul of the Owner. Anyone that can create magical dishes and make everyone happy from his decades of experiences is a true businessman and cares about all the customers that enjoy his creative dishes. I am salivating as I write this review not because of the plethora of selections, but because we...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 3PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Miller Place Also Viewed
The BlackSheep at Miller Place is a highly praised restaurant known for its fresh, made-to-order food and friendly service. Guests enjoy a variety of creative dishes, including pulled pork, pesto chicken, grilled vegetables, steak and chicken tacos, and Mac n cheese. Many reviews highlight the chef’s talent for blending herbs and spices to create unique flavors, making each meal special. The restaurant offers gourmet options like the chicken and pesto with goat cheese sandwich and the Cubano special, impressing diners with their flavor and originality.
The staff is consistently described as friendly, attentive, and accommodating, especially to families with young children. The restaurant is clean and welcoming, with efforts made to ensure young guests are comfortable, including providing highchairs, toys, coloring books, and Disney music. Guests appreciate the personalized experience, noting that service feels warm and local, similar to a neighborhood diner or deli.
Whether dining in or ordering takeout, visitors are impressed by the quality and taste of the food. Many plan to return, citing the chef’s talent, the creative menu, and the excellent service as reasons to revisit. Overall, The BlackSheep offers a memorable, kid-friendly dining experience with outstanding food and a welcoming atmosphere.