I ordered large pizzasw mushrooms&meatballs, wow . it was delicious ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Scricca
Best Pizza within delivery distance to Garden City! I'm a Pizza snob it's good!No joke we order at least once a week.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Mauricio Zapata
Great variety of food and delicious pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mikey Laterza jr
This place was awesome, stopped there right before closing hour , After doing a job in the area . Pizza was top tier .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony G
Hands down the best pizza in town and the best Argentinian skirt steak sandwich with chimi churri sauce. Omar and Ivy are very friendly and their portions are generous. Highly recommend!
I tried the Chicken Valdestano Entree. The portion was very big with two sliced chicken breast over a bed of pasta farfalla. The sauce was a little thin and watered down but had great flavor. Just wished sauce was a little thicker with more mushrooms. Very friendly staff and would recommend.
Paco Diaz
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes have ramp
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Empanadas
Dev M.
Solid pizza and ingredients. We ordered a Grandma pie and a few slices of white and eggplant+ricotta. The marinara and cheese on the grandma were good. The grandma is also 12 slices which is a nice bump in size compared to other shops which make 9 slices pies. My only knock on their pizza is the crust. It tastes like a low protein/gluten content flour, almost like all purpose or maybe a little cake flour mixed in. So it's not as chewy as I think pizza crust should be. That said, it's still got a solid crispy layer.
Steffie Argañaraz
mama gina’s has the almost authentic Argentinian pizza i’ve had! incredible empanadas, and even better service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Empanadas
Ben S.
Upon arriving at parking lot. The shop is on the corner of a super market. Once inside. The place was pretty busy with multiple tables occupied. As for the service, the gentlemen behind the counter cheerful and ready to serve. As we waited for the fresh pie we ordered a slice to snack on. One bite....... everyone knows the rules!! I have to say I've never had such an airy and light slice in my enter life. It looked like a regular slice, tasted like a regular slice but did not weigh like a regular slice. If you're looking for a solid slice, give these folks a try.
Our family came from new York to just try this fantastic pizza we all people loved it and it was very well cooked also the service was good. Thank You we loved your food
Yvette G.
The garlic knots and tomato sauce is delicious. Fresh dough and the sauce is oooo la la.
AJ L.
Ordered one Sicilian pie and one regular cheese pie and was underwhelmed. The regular pie was very average - not exceptional and not awful. If you're looking for a quick bite, a slice of cheese pizza would suffice. The Sicilian tasted a bit more artificial and not as authentic as some as the other pizzerias in the area. The sauce (in my opinion), was too sweet, The garlic knots we ordered were pretty sizable, but did lack garlic, cheese and parsley, so essentially, we got over cooked rolls. They didn't taste like anything. The staff was friendly and the food was out pretty quickly. When placing the order via-phone they let us negotiate the price of the meal which to me was a bit odd, but hey, we saved $10! The place itself is a hole-in-the-wall place with a decent selection of pies and entrees. It's also quite clean.
Lorna T.
The BEST pizza ever! Plus the staff is super friendly, not to mention an outdoor section for those warmer days
Nancy H.
Long Island's best kept pizza secret. Absolutely perfection. I have had Brooklyn, Bronx, Little Italy, Chicago, and the country of Italy pizza and none as good as Mamma Gina's. The best!!! And everything else they make is just as good.
I ordered large pizzasw mushrooms&meatballs, wow . it was delicious ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza within delivery distance to Garden City! I'm a Pizza snob it's good!No joke we order at least once a week.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Great variety of food and delicious pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was awesome, stopped there right before closing hour , After doing a job in the area . Pizza was top tier .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best pizza in town and the best Argentinian skirt steak sandwich with chimi churri sauce. Omar and Ivy are very friendly and their portions are generous. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Encaldo Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Roll, Chicken Wings, Chicken Parmigiana, Salad, Gluten Free Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Roll, Buffalo Chicken, Empanadas, Grandma Pizza, Stracciatella Ala Romana, Fried Chicken, Greek Salad
I tried the Chicken Valdestano Entree. The portion was very big with two sliced chicken breast over a bed of pasta farfalla. The sauce was a little thin and watered down but had great flavor. Just wished sauce was a little thicker with more mushrooms. Very friendly staff and would recommend.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes have ramp
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Empanadas
Solid pizza and ingredients. We ordered a Grandma pie and a few slices of white and eggplant+ricotta. The marinara and cheese on the grandma were good. The grandma is also 12 slices which is a nice bump in size compared to other shops which make 9 slices pies. My only knock on their pizza is the crust. It tastes like a low protein/gluten content flour, almost like all purpose or maybe a little cake flour mixed in. So it's not as chewy as I think pizza crust should be. That said, it's still got a solid crispy layer.
mama gina’s has the almost authentic Argentinian pizza i’ve had! incredible empanadas, and even better service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Empanadas
Upon arriving at parking lot. The shop is on the corner of a super market. Once inside. The place was pretty busy with multiple tables occupied. As for the service, the gentlemen behind the counter cheerful and ready to serve. As we waited for the fresh pie we ordered a slice to snack on. One bite....... everyone knows the rules!! I have to say I've never had such an airy and light slice in my enter life. It looked like a regular slice, tasted like a regular slice but did not weigh like a regular slice. If you're looking for a solid slice, give these folks a try.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our family came from new York to just try this fantastic pizza we all people loved it and it was very well cooked also the service was good. Thank You we loved your food
The garlic knots and tomato sauce is delicious. Fresh dough and the sauce is oooo la la.
Ordered one Sicilian pie and one regular cheese pie and was underwhelmed. The regular pie was very average - not exceptional and not awful. If you're looking for a quick bite, a slice of cheese pizza would suffice. The Sicilian tasted a bit more artificial and not as authentic as some as the other pizzerias in the area. The sauce (in my opinion), was too sweet, The garlic knots we ordered were pretty sizable, but did lack garlic, cheese and parsley, so essentially, we got over cooked rolls. They didn't taste like anything. The staff was friendly and the food was out pretty quickly. When placing the order via-phone they let us negotiate the price of the meal which to me was a bit odd, but hey, we saved $10! The place itself is a hole-in-the-wall place with a decent selection of pies and entrees. It's also quite clean.
The BEST pizza ever! Plus the staff is super friendly, not to mention an outdoor section for those warmer days
Long Island's best kept pizza secret. Absolutely perfection. I have had Brooklyn, Bronx, Little Italy, Chicago, and the country of Italy pizza and none as good as Mamma Gina's. The best!!! And everything else they make is just as good.