Really disappointing experience. The hostess and servers were not only unfriendly, it was as if they made an effort to be rude. When you drop $200 for a meal you expect service to be a little better than what you would get at an airport fast food restaurant. My husband and I got our food fast but my daughter got her pizza after waiting 40 minutes. No explanations or excuses from the staff and had to wait long after our table had been bussed to get our receipt and card back.
PEL Laura
Absolutely the best pizza in Montauk, hands-down! These people get it! The dough, the sauce, and the mozzarella are on point! The appetizers were awesome! The service and the vibe are great!!! Will definitely be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
george O
Nice buzzy atmosphere however the food was extremely poor and the manager was obnoxious. Food came out at various times for the three of us. The tomato and squash salad had no tomatoes and no squash but three large burnt peppers and very hot courgettes. When I sent it back to ask for what was on the menu , the same plate came back with a half a tomato and no squash. The pasta was so spicy it was sickening. When I complained the manager told me to stop talking. She took the "tomato" salad off the bill but the bill was still $100 (for the above plus a plate with ham). When we left she then yelled at the top of her voice "you are welcome" which I found humiliating in front of my family and the guests in the restaurant. All around, stick to selling overpriced and raw pizzas.
Marta Waszkiewicz
Tastes as good as the OG location in Bushwick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lloyd
Roberta's Montauk proved to be a late-night savior during our Hamptons escapade. While the prices reflected the Hamptons standard, the pizza was solid. The fact that they remained open late was the cherry on top. If you find yourself in the area with late-night cravings, Roberta's Montauk is a great go-to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vibe Check
Roberta's Montauk proved to be a late-night savior during our Hamptons escapade. While the prices reflected the Hamptons standard, the pizza was solid. The fact that they remained open late was the cherry on top. If you find yourself in the area with late-night cravings, Roberta's Montauk is a great go-to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stacey Corrigan
The servers were very nice but our food came out at completely different times. The kids pasta came out 15 mins before they delivered 1 or our pizzas for a party of 5. We then waited another 20 minutes before I had to ask the busy boy who was clearing our table to check on our food. Then the find out the kitchen forgot our order. Pizza was yummy but would never come back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
The BTONE Show
Great atmosphere and very good pizza and drinks right off the Montauk train line. 1 minute walk from the train station.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bee Sting
Presley Strong
Incredible atmosphere, perfect pizza and wine. Gabriel at the bar took really great care of us we love him.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Niclas Hell
Calm, nice vibe, a bit on the expensive side. Pizza and drinks were good.
Kind of rude staff. Tough location not many make it there past a year. Having a rude staff won’t help. Also how can you be in Montauk and not offer the local Montauk Beer. Huge miss
Mike Jabroni
Extremely rude staff, mediocre $25 personal pizzas with inconsistent ingredients. Great music.
Ezio Mirarchi
Love the place. Great food, Great drinks, Great service!
Zuzana Tuskova
Good food, nice place, friendly staff, delish margaritas ??
Marek Waldin
I decided to come for one hour while waiting for my train. The service was incredible, and the staff made me feel at home. They were smiley and also kind.The only thing I observed was that the pizza I chose was slightly salty; however, it was not a big deal because I had a great time there.
Really disappointing experience. The hostess and servers were not only unfriendly, it was as if they made an effort to be rude. When you drop $200 for a meal you expect service to be a little better than what you would get at an airport fast food restaurant. My husband and I got our food fast but my daughter got her pizza after waiting 40 minutes. No explanations or excuses from the staff and had to wait long after our table had been bussed to get our receipt and card back.
Absolutely the best pizza in Montauk, hands-down! These people get it! The dough, the sauce, and the mozzarella are on point! The appetizers were awesome! The service and the vibe are great!!! Will definitely be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice buzzy atmosphere however the food was extremely poor and the manager was obnoxious. Food came out at various times for the three of us. The tomato and squash salad had no tomatoes and no squash but three large burnt peppers and very hot courgettes. When I sent it back to ask for what was on the menu , the same plate came back with a half a tomato and no squash. The pasta was so spicy it was sickening. When I complained the manager told me to stop talking. She took the "tomato" salad off the bill but the bill was still $100 (for the above plus a plate with ham). When we left she then yelled at the top of her voice "you are welcome" which I found humiliating in front of my family and the guests in the restaurant. All around, stick to selling overpriced and raw pizzas.
Tastes as good as the OG location in Bushwick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roberta's Montauk proved to be a late-night savior during our Hamptons escapade. While the prices reflected the Hamptons standard, the pizza was solid. The fact that they remained open late was the cherry on top. If you find yourself in the area with late-night cravings, Roberta's Montauk is a great go-to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roberta's Montauk proved to be a late-night savior during our Hamptons escapade. While the prices reflected the Hamptons standard, the pizza was solid. The fact that they remained open late was the cherry on top. If you find yourself in the area with late-night cravings, Roberta's Montauk is a great go-to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The servers were very nice but our food came out at completely different times. The kids pasta came out 15 mins before they delivered 1 or our pizzas for a party of 5. We then waited another 20 minutes before I had to ask the busy boy who was clearing our table to check on our food. Then the find out the kitchen forgot our order. Pizza was yummy but would never come back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great atmosphere and very good pizza and drinks right off the Montauk train line. 1 minute walk from the train station.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bee Sting
Incredible atmosphere, perfect pizza and wine. Gabriel at the bar took really great care of us we love him.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Calm, nice vibe, a bit on the expensive side. Pizza and drinks were good.
Restaurantji Recommends
Kind of rude staff. Tough location not many make it there past a year. Having a rude staff won’t help. Also how can you be in Montauk and not offer the local Montauk Beer. Huge miss
Extremely rude staff, mediocre $25 personal pizzas with inconsistent ingredients. Great music.
Love the place. Great food, Great drinks, Great service!
Good food, nice place, friendly staff, delish margaritas ??
I decided to come for one hour while waiting for my train. The service was incredible, and the staff made me feel at home. They were smiley and also kind.The only thing I observed was that the pizza I chose was slightly salty; however, it was not a big deal because I had a great time there.
Loading...