Bennett Shellfish
Seafood, BakeryAbout Bennett Shellfish
Bennett Shellfish Reviews
159 ratings
Share your opinion about Bennett Shellfish
Delicious 2-for-1 lobster rolls! Lots of lobster and not too much mayo. Extensive fresh, prepared and "frozen-fresh" seafood and desserts.
We bought the lobster moray pie and the baked clams. Both were exceptionally delicious. We will definitely be returning…this week. SO yummy!
My boyfriend and I came here thinking it was a restaurant, and then realized it was a fresh fish market.
We had some fresh oysters, sushi tuna, and their delicious smoked fish dip, as we sat out front.
Totally recommended for a fresh quick bite. I think the smoked fish dip was our favorite- AMAZING is an understatement!
We had some fresh oysters, sushi tuna, and their delicious smoked fish dip, as we sat out front.
Totally recommended for a fresh quick bite. I think the smoked fish dip was our favorite- AMAZING is an understatement!
Hours
| Monday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 6:30PM |
Bennett Shellfish offers a water-to-table experience rooted in 14th generation bayman traditions and sustainable practices. This family-oriented market provides friendly customer service, taking time to answer questions and give advice. Their menu includes fresh, high-quality seafood such as smoked bluefish, lobster rolls, oysters, and decadent lobster white pizza. Customers praise the lobster roll for its freshness and taste, with lots of lobster meat, a light touch of mayo, and subtle flavors. The potato bun and Cape Cod chips make it a perfect lunch. Visitors often stop here before heading home, confident in the quality and fair prices. With great service, fresh seafood, and a welcoming atmosphere, Bennett Shellfish is a top choice for seafood lovers in the area.
The owners are described as some of the kindest, most genuine people, making customers feel welcome the moment they walk in. The lobster bisque is particularly praised for being fresh, creamy, and perfectly seasoned. Customers have become repeat visitors, calling Bennett Shellfish a "true Montauk gem and staple" known for its delicious smoked fish dip, smoked bluefish, and affordable lobster rolls.