The ambiance and food were amazing. Service was spectacular. Wine list and recommendations great. The only down side was the amount of people who brought their dogs in. One barked a lot, one peed under table behind us. Food exceptional! Nice surprise.
Daniel
Very much appreciated the ability to make a reservation for Sunday brunch for 12 people on relatively short notice! As we were nearing the end of the 2025 summer season and it was very windy and rainy, we were the only group in the restaurant, except some folks from a wedding hosted by the hotel the prior night. The oysters were very large and delicious! Look forward to returning in 2026 and enjoying a meal outside with warm and sunny weather.
jeanne
The skirt steak was the size of a fist accompanied by an entire plate of fries. We ordered it medium rare and it came out well. I ordered a tuna and got swordfish. I happen to like both, so it was fine, but it was wrong. The restaurant was understaffed the Saturday night we went because a wedding was going on directly next door which was loud and competed with the music in the restaurant the whole night. It took a long time to get a drink after being seated. Overall, I would not go back. It was expensive for mediocre food and service.
Paige
The host was very hospitable. We wanted a quiet romantic dinner and had just that! Highly recommend.
Amy
The food was great. Had the flatbread, oysters, Black Sea bass, braised ribs. All delicious. The Arugula salad was a bit simple and the tuna was decent but not our favorite. Service was good and everyone was very friendly. Really great atmosphere. We ate early - my guess is it gets lively later on.
cory
The food was amazing! We enjoyed the outside patio. The service was friendly and efficient. We would definitely come back to Sea Salt!
Cynthia
Atmosphere was very nice. Service was good Chicken and steak didn't have any taste. Short ribs were excellent. Drinks were made well
Marnie
We had such a lovely evening here. After asking to be seated outside I found myself chilly. The staff were so accommodating moving us inside to be a little warmer. The waitress offered suggestions that were delicious. All the food was cooked perfectly with ample portions. The setting was beautiful and being a Tuesday evening, pretty quiet. Definitely a good place for date night. Will be going back again
Bob Cozzi
We celebrated our anniversary with our family
The food & service were top notch
Beautiful environment as well
The menu had a number of tempting choices.
Rosa our server helped us with recommendations which turned out to be wonderful
Definitely planning to dine there again
Had a wonderful evening - Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony
best short braised plate ever!!! First time at this place and as good as it gets in Montauk
great atmosphere, great service food pairings were a little strange ( entrees/side choices) charcuterie board was great!
Deborah
Our server Rosa was excellent...the advertised new chef Melissa is no longer with them despite a recent write up in the Southforker Magazine all about her farm to table new menu. Apps were fresh local clams and oysters...and quickly delivered....dinner took longer and mine was cold. I noticed that everyone was waiting quite awhile between apps and dinner. I would go back for a drink at the bar and oysters but probably not for dinner.
marlene
It's beautiful. The food and service were excellent. We had 7 people including 2 young children and we all had a lovely relaxing time. It's expensive but worth it
Robin-Anne
This was our Anniversary dinner and it was clearly stated on our reservation, we were both dressed in white to celebrate, but it was not mentioned nor recognized by the venue. The waiter was EXCELLENT! However, the runners and bus staff were extremely friendly & busy, BUT were consistently LOST bringing food to the incorrect tables, o Dr & over again. Showing up with deserts at tables who were eating their main courses. Bringing appetizers to tables eating desserts. Staring around the dining room with hot meals in their hand not knowing which table to deliver them too. I ordered oysters on the half shell for my appetizer and woke up violently ill early this morning with lower GI issues that lasted from about 4am-1pm today. It's unfortunate because the meal was delicious & the atmosphere was so lovely.
Nicole
Arrived for more than half the tables being uncleared at 8pm on a Sunday night. Food all over the floor. We feigned illness and left immediately. If this is what they're willing to show you, can you imagine the filth behind the scenes?
The ambiance and food were amazing. Service was spectacular. Wine list and recommendations great. The only down side was the amount of people who brought their dogs in. One barked a lot, one peed under table behind us. Food exceptional! Nice surprise.
Very much appreciated the ability to make a reservation for Sunday brunch for 12 people on relatively short notice! As we were nearing the end of the 2025 summer season and it was very windy and rainy, we were the only group in the restaurant, except some folks from a wedding hosted by the hotel the prior night. The oysters were very large and delicious! Look forward to returning in 2026 and enjoying a meal outside with warm and sunny weather.
The skirt steak was the size of a fist accompanied by an entire plate of fries. We ordered it medium rare and it came out well. I ordered a tuna and got swordfish. I happen to like both, so it was fine, but it was wrong. The restaurant was understaffed the Saturday night we went because a wedding was going on directly next door which was loud and competed with the music in the restaurant the whole night. It took a long time to get a drink after being seated. Overall, I would not go back. It was expensive for mediocre food and service.
The host was very hospitable. We wanted a quiet romantic dinner and had just that! Highly recommend.
The food was great. Had the flatbread, oysters, Black Sea bass, braised ribs. All delicious. The Arugula salad was a bit simple and the tuna was decent but not our favorite. Service was good and everyone was very friendly. Really great atmosphere. We ate early - my guess is it gets lively later on.
The food was amazing! We enjoyed the outside patio. The service was friendly and efficient. We would definitely come back to Sea Salt!
Atmosphere was very nice. Service was good Chicken and steak didn't have any taste. Short ribs were excellent. Drinks were made well
We had such a lovely evening here. After asking to be seated outside I found myself chilly. The staff were so accommodating moving us inside to be a little warmer. The waitress offered suggestions that were delicious. All the food was cooked perfectly with ample portions. The setting was beautiful and being a Tuesday evening, pretty quiet. Definitely a good place for date night. Will be going back again
We celebrated our anniversary with our family
The food & service were top notch
Beautiful environment as well
The menu had a number of tempting choices.
Rosa our server helped us with recommendations which turned out to be wonderful
Definitely planning to dine there again
Had a wonderful evening - Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
best short braised plate ever!!! First time at this place and as good as it gets in Montauk
Restaurantji Recommends
great atmosphere, great service food pairings were a little strange ( entrees/side choices) charcuterie board was great!
Our server Rosa was excellent...the advertised new chef Melissa is no longer with them despite a recent write up in the Southforker Magazine all about her farm to table new menu. Apps were fresh local clams and oysters...and quickly delivered....dinner took longer and mine was cold. I noticed that everyone was waiting quite awhile between apps and dinner. I would go back for a drink at the bar and oysters but probably not for dinner.
It's beautiful. The food and service were excellent. We had 7 people including 2 young children and we all had a lovely relaxing time. It's expensive but worth it
This was our Anniversary dinner and it was clearly stated on our reservation, we were both dressed in white to celebrate, but it was not mentioned nor recognized by the venue. The waiter was EXCELLENT! However, the runners and bus staff were extremely friendly & busy, BUT were consistently LOST bringing food to the incorrect tables, o Dr & over again. Showing up with deserts at tables who were eating their main courses. Bringing appetizers to tables eating desserts. Staring around the dining room with hot meals in their hand not knowing which table to deliver them too. I ordered oysters on the half shell for my appetizer and woke up violently ill early this morning with lower GI issues that lasted from about 4am-1pm today. It's unfortunate because the meal was delicious & the atmosphere was so lovely.
Arrived for more than half the tables being uncleared at 8pm on a Sunday night. Food all over the floor. We feigned illness and left immediately. If this is what they're willing to show you, can you imagine the filth behind the scenes?
Loading...