Bennett Shellfish
2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk
(631) 903-5817
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Absolutely excellent gem in Montauk! Locally owned and sourced sea food caught daily by family that has been doing it right for generations. Open year round . They also have homemade famous clam pies, smoked fish dip, lobster rolls and more. I recommend stopping by ! A++
Bennett Shellfish is truly a hidden gem in the local area! The owner Kim is incredibly friendly and genuine, making you feel right at home. The oysters here are hands down the best I've ever had—so fresh and bursting with the flavor of the sea. The warm service provided by the kim makes the whole experience even more delightful. Highly recommended for all seafood lovers! 🦪💯
Bennett Shellfish is truly a local treasure store! Kim, the proprietress,...
Bennett Shellfish is truly a local treasure store! Kim, the proprietress,...
Family owned seafood store operating out of their own home. Prices are very fair. Given its location in the now super expensive Montauk, New York area. Always fresh, always good. Try the two for one lobster roll. It’s the best deal on the East End.
You May Also Like
Navy Beach Restaurant, Montauk - 16 Navy Rd
![]()
Seafood, American, Bar, New American
Harvest On Fort Pond - 11 S Emery St
![]()
Italian, Seafood, Pizza, Vegan