Bennett Shellfish
2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk
(631) 903-5817
Menu
Photos
+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We had the best lobster roll and experience at Bennett’s that we had to go back again in the same week! This time we ordered the lobster rolls and tried the lobster bisque as well and oh my goodness it was delicious and we’re so glad we did! Everything we ordered the main ingredient is actually fresh lobster, and they don’t hold back on the amount and you can’t beat the price! The owners are so beyond kind and the place is so cute and clean. You definitely have repeat...
We camp every October in Montauk. Always ready for a stop at Bennetts Shellfish. Delicious smoked fish dip and a nice piece of smoked bluefish to enjoy with crackers at the campground. Stopped another day for fresh fluke, yum! Best price around for lobster rolls. Got home tonight and warmed up the clam sauce and served it over linguine, husband loved the flavor. May have to drive out over the winter to restock.
You May Also Like
Ruschmeyers - 161 2nd House Rd
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, New American
Navy Beach Restaurant, Montauk - 16 Navy Rd
![]()
Seafood, American, Bar, New American
The owners are some of the kindest, most genuine people you will ever meet. They make you feel welcome the moment you walk in, and it is clear they pour their hearts into everything they do.
May...