pretentious/over priced -tone it down. became like the Surf Lodge. Montauk needs to stay laid back&welcoming.
Mariam Mtchedlishvili
I had been wanting to visit this place for a long time, but honestly, it was a big disappointment. It doesn’t look or feel anything like Mykonos, and the quality is far below what we expected. The lobster had no flavor, and most of the food was bland and unseasoned. Prices are even higher than in New York City. There was no real vibe—no music, no energy. They served me a dry lobster roll, and when I asked for some mayo, the server said they didn’t have any … seriously?! The manager promised to bring it, but never came back. In the end, this “fake Mykonos” spot is all about high prices and low quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Michelle Fralley
One of if not the best in Montauk! Abundant food made deliciously. Don’t be a whiner about the prices, it’s worth every delicious bite. The views are beautiful as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ada S
New York City prices without the quality. Servers and staff very nice over all and so was the atmosphere. There could have been a little more explanation for the menu, as it wasn’t clear which items were family style and which weren’t. The food was genuinely shocking for the price on the menu. Bread was not properly baked, ceviche was lackluster, and a tiny portion for what you pay, comes with nothing else on the side. Clam bake was rubbery, honestly seemed like some items were frozen, not fresh. Not much you can do since you do pay when you order.
Bartender did have a great mustache.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 4
Vena Sewnarine
The END! Best atmosphere and food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
isai canela (Sinderr)
$2 a head for unlimited tap water is such a joke.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Sypek Law \u0026 Insurance
Perfect location to watch the setting sun. Great young vibe. Food well prepared with nice presentation. Good sized portions. A bit pricey but that’s the Hamptons in August. Will definitely go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
N C
What a vibe. Great food and wine menu. Steven is the best. Hugo, yahia and guleitte and dezz are very polite and nice people there. A very happy customer I am.
Patrick D
In all my years, 30, in the Hamptons this is my favorite restaurant hands down. It is a quintessential summer spot that truly makes summer memorable. Weather you pull up in a car or a boat, it is always fanrltastic
The view was one of the best we’ve experienced, but the food was terrible despite the price.
John Zavolas
I went to Montauk for my birthday weekend with people who grew up going there for 20 years and Dureya’s was hyped up to me for months and it absolutely over delivered and captured the essence of the entire weekend (we went July 2024). It’s a market and restaurant on the water with a super casual vibe that draws a great crowd. We started with the sunset seafood tower while we waited for a table and then we ordered the heirloom tomato salad, the tuna tartare, the fresh corn, and the belle of the ball- the Lobster Cobb. The ingredients were all so fresh and flavorful and even though we ordered a good amount of food, it was also light and clean. I still dream about the tomatoes, corn, and the salad. That birthday lunch was a core summer memory for me that I can’t wait to recreate.
April J. Barber
This is a staple in our rotation. The seafood is incredible! Most dishes are intended for sharing so the portions are large. Don't skip the lobster salad and the clam bake (and order bread to finish off the sauce!). The service is professional and accommodating and management always swings by to ask how it's going.
Please ignore the reviews knocking this place because they have to actively take part in the ordering process (laziness breeds resentment!), you fill out a menu (similar to Dim Sum) and take it to the counter to pay. It's great because after you've finished eating, you can leave so there's no need to play tag with the wait staff to pay your bill. I find the process efficient and that adds to my love of the place. The prices are reflective of the quality and the location and are 100% worth it. Come if you love seafood and bring your appetite. You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spandan
Nice place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alon Juwal
Perfect atmosphere right on the water! Food is great but definitely overpriced.
The food and everything was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
pretentious/over priced
-tone it down.
became like the Surf Lodge.
Montauk needs to stay laid back&welcoming.
I had been wanting to visit this place for a long time, but honestly, it was a big disappointment. It doesn’t look or feel anything like Mykonos, and the quality is far below what we expected. The lobster had no flavor, and most of the food was bland and unseasoned. Prices are even higher than in New York City.
There was no real vibe—no music, no energy. They served me a dry lobster roll, and when I asked for some mayo, the server said they didn’t have any … seriously?!
The manager promised to bring it, but never came back.
In the end, this “fake Mykonos” spot is all about high prices and low quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
One of if not the best in Montauk! Abundant food made deliciously. Don’t be a whiner about the prices, it’s worth every delicious bite. The views are beautiful as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New York City prices without the quality. Servers and staff very nice over all and so was the atmosphere. There could have been a little more explanation for the menu, as it wasn’t clear which items were family style and which weren’t.
The food was genuinely shocking for the price on the menu. Bread was not properly baked, ceviche was lackluster, and a tiny portion for what you pay, comes with nothing else on the side. Clam bake was rubbery, honestly seemed like some items were frozen, not fresh. Not much you can do since you do pay when you order.
Bartender did have a great mustache.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 4
The END! Best atmosphere and food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
$2 a head for unlimited tap water is such a joke.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Perfect location to watch the setting sun. Great young vibe. Food well prepared with nice presentation. Good sized portions. A bit pricey but that’s the Hamptons in August. Will definitely go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
What a vibe. Great food and wine menu. Steven is the best. Hugo, yahia and guleitte and dezz are very polite and nice people there. A very happy customer I am.
In all my years, 30, in the Hamptons this is my favorite restaurant hands down. It is a quintessential summer spot that truly makes summer memorable. Weather you pull up in a car or a boat, it is always fanrltastic
Restaurantji Recommends
The view was one of the best we’ve experienced, but the food was terrible despite the price.
I went to Montauk for my birthday weekend with people who grew up going there for 20 years and Dureya’s was hyped up to me for months and it absolutely over delivered and captured the essence of the entire weekend (we went July 2024). It’s a market and restaurant on the water with a super casual vibe that draws a great crowd. We started with the sunset seafood tower while we waited for a table and then we ordered the heirloom tomato salad, the tuna tartare, the fresh corn, and the belle of the ball- the Lobster Cobb. The ingredients were all so fresh and flavorful and even though we ordered a good amount of food, it was also light and clean. I still dream about the tomatoes, corn, and the salad. That birthday lunch was a core summer memory for me that I can’t wait to recreate.
This is a staple in our rotation. The seafood is incredible! Most dishes are intended for sharing so the portions are large. Don't skip the lobster salad and the clam bake (and order bread to finish off the sauce!).
The service is professional and accommodating and management always swings by to ask how it's going.
Please ignore the reviews knocking this place because they have to actively take part in the ordering process (laziness breeds resentment!), you fill out a menu (similar to Dim Sum) and take it to the counter to pay. It's great because after you've finished eating, you can leave so there's no need to play tag with the wait staff to pay your bill. I find the process efficient and that adds to my love of the place.
The prices are reflective of the quality and the location and are 100% worth it.
Come if you love seafood and bring your appetite. You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perfect atmosphere right on the water! Food is great but definitely overpriced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...