Fierro’s Pizza Montauk

54 S Erie Ave, Montauk
(631) 668-8084

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pizza

Menu

Pizza
Pizza
Gluten Free 12"

Specialty Pizza
Margherita pie
Fresh garlic, basil, tomatoes, and mozzarella.
Meat Lovers Pie
Sweet Italian sausage, pepperoni, meatball, mozzarella, and sauce.
Hawaiian Pie
Pineapple, cooked ham, mozzarella, and sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Chicken, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella, and sauce.
Vegetarian Pie
A medley of vegetables, mozzarella, and sauce.
White Pizza
Ricotta, mozzarella, Romano cheese, and garlic.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Spicy chicken, cheddar, mozzarella, and blue cheese sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana Pie
Breaded chicken, mozzarella, and marinara sauce.
BBQ Chicken Pie
Chicken, mozzarella, and BBQ sauce.
Gluten-Free (12")

Square Pizza
Grandma's Pizza (8 Slices)
Pesto, garlic, marinara, mozzarella, and Romano cheese
Sicilian Pizza (12 Slices)
Fierro's pizza sauce and mozzarella.
Grandpa's Pie (8 slices)
Marinara, fresh mozzarella, basil

Heros
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Meatball & Peppers Hero
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Sausage & Peppers Hero
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Sausage Parmigiana Hero

Wraps
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Mozzarella, roasted peppers, and pesto.
Crispy Chicken BLT Wrap
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Grilled Veggie Wrap
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Wrap

Sides
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Garlic Knots (3)
Garlic Bread
Broccoli or Spinach with Garlic & Olive Oil
Meatballs (3 pcs)
Sausage (3 pcs)

Entrees
Chicken & Spinach
Grilled chicken, sauteed spinach and cherry tomatoes tossed with olive oil, garlic, and fresh squeezed lemon juice
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken breast covered in a savory tomato sauce and mozzarella
Shrimp Parmigiana
Lightly fried and topped w/ homemade marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella
Eggplant Parmigiana
Thin sliced eggplant breaded w/ seasoned panko breadcrumbs, savory tomato sauce and mozzarella
Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions
Sweet Italian sausage w/ peppers and onions in our savory tomato sauce
Pasta Marinara
Pasta with Butter
Chicken w/ Broccoli
Grilled chicken topped w/ tomatoes, mozzarella, and pesto served w/ parmesan garlic broccoli
Pasta Bolognese
Ground beef and pork, fresh herbs, onions, and savory tomato sauce; finished with red wine and parmigiana cheese
Penne alla Vodka
Sweet and salty pancetta lightly sauteed in olive oil, then cooked in vodka, tomato sauce, and cream over penne
Baked Ziti
Fierro's famous house sauce with fresh mozzarella and ricotta
Pasta Primavera
a delicious medley of vegetables with penne

Calzones & Rolls
Cheese Calzone
Ricotta, mozzarella, and Romano.
Sausage Roll
Sausage, peppers, onions, and mozzarella.
Chicken Roll
Breaded chicken and mozzarella.
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni and mozzarella.
Build Your Own Roll
Includes mozzarella cheese and up to 3 fillings.

Salads
Garden Salad
Caesar Salad
Gorgonzola Salad
Greek Salad
Antipasto Salad
Pasta Salad
Bow tie pasta, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, broccoli, and basil tossed in olive oil. Served with a side of balsamic vinaigrette
Buffalo Chicken Salad

Wings & Things
Chicken Wings
Chicken Tenders
Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara
French Fries
Cheese Fries
Shrimp & Fries
Onion Rings
Fish & Chips

Desserts
Cannoli
Cheese Cake
Chocolate Cake
Tiramisu
Carrot Cake

Drinks
2L Pepsi
2L Diet Pepsi
2L Starry
20oz Aquafina
Gatorade 20oz
20oz San Pelligrino
20oz Evian Water
Apple Juice
Cranberry Juice
Pure Leaf Iced Tea
20oz Soda

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+17 photos
Photo credit: google
+16 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

$60+ for two orders of penne alla vodka and an order of garlic knots. Btw an order of garlic knots only comes with 3… . The vodka sauce didn’t have any heavy cream so it was basically marinara. They have a cute seating arrangement but only if it’s nice outside.
August 2025
Huge variety of excellent pizza. Grab a beer next door at Montauk Brewery, sit on a bench or one of their Adirondack chairs and let your cares melt away. BTW: very friendly staff and the pizza is very fairly priced. I went twice this week
June 2025
Best pizza ever! The Sicilian pizza was fluffy, spongy with the perfect about of crunch to the bread base topped with a delicious slightly sweet tomatoes sauce and perfect amount of cheese. Pepe's Pizza has nothing on these guys.
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

El Taco Ole Montauk - 805 Montauk Hwy
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Montauk Market Café and Deli - 805 Montauk Hwy
Deli, Grocery, Cafe, Gluten-Free
Street Food - 58 S Erie Ave
Chinese, Asian Fusion, Pan Asian

Fierro’s Pizza Montauk

54 S Erie Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
(631) 668-8084