The food is mediocre at best, but when you factor in the terrible service and obscene prices it becomes downright criminal. I would suggest avoiding this restaurant altogether and selecting one of the many restaurants in town.
Debbie
Food and service were very good but, I was definitely turned off by the restaurant allowing dogs in the dining room. Sorry but not at this price point. This was not a casual, outdoor setting where pets should be permitted.
Joshua
Filet was perfect, oysters were flavorful and fresh. Overall great experience. Could use a little more decor in the dining room.
Ayesha
My first time at Gigi's. Loved it. I had the shrimp saganaki and a 6 oz filet mignon along with the beignets. Everything was delicious. I plan to go back as much as possible before the busy summer season when it becomes harder to get a spot.
shelley
First time to Montauk, we stumbled across Gigi's and it was an amazing meal. We would definitely recommend it.
Frank
The food was excellent, service was great. The only problem was the music that was playing. Very poor choice for dining.....
Anastasiia
I bought tickets for dinner and NYE celebration. Dinner was excellent while party was absolutely not. I attended NYE party at Gurneys few years ago and it was fun: they had James Bond theme, entertainment, casino with fake money,. Overall my group had a blast. This year it was very simple, no theme, bad music, impossible to get a drink (open bar included in ticket) - understaffed bar and way too many people for the venue. I wouldn't recommend it for the price, isn't worth it.
Christina
We rang in the New Year's Eve at Gigi's and the experience was exceptional from start to finish. Mimmo and his team offered a gracious welcome that immediately made us feel like cherished guests rather than diners. Lunch featured a beautifully prepared shrimp cocktail, pristine fresh oysters, and a standout hamachi crudo accented with crispy garlic, capers, and sea salt. Service throughout was seamless and attentive, complementing a menu that was both refined and deeply flavorful. What truly set the experience apart was the care extended to our two children—the team went above and beyond to ensure they felt comfortable and included, and they are already asking when we can return. Special thanks to Mimmo for his thoughtful personal touches and remarkable hospitality. Grazie dal cuore.
Belinda
I was with a party of four any everyone's meal (from appetizers to entrees and dessert) was amazing. The staff was super attentive and friendly which just made the experience that much better!
eloise
The ambience was excellent but the food was average for the cost. We did come for lunch so cannot comment on dinner selections. The host was fantastatic.
The food was delightful from the second the bread and mascarpone butter arrived! Felix provided excellent service and always took care of us. Love the restaurant since the renovation. Cocktails were 10/10.
Emily
Everything was perfect! Gigi's was a great place to celebrate a romantic Christmas dinner. Food and service were top notch. One of the most memorable meals I've ever had!
Marc
The settings in Guerney's is always a treat. Beautiful ocean views. Came for Christmas Eve dinner. The restaurant was packed. Service was great but kitchen was backed up. Food took longer than expected but our waiter kept us informed and apologized for the delay. They made up for it on the bill. Food was excellent. We all loved our dishes. While prices are high portions were big. Loved the lamb, chicken and pasta. Onion rings were perfectly done. The cheesecake and strawberry gelato were outstanding. All in all a nice holiday dinner.
Cornelia
Delicious food and an exceptional service. Beautiful ambiance in this newly done restaurant.
Gordon
Great experience. It was a quiet night as it is off-season, but the food was excellent, the staff were attentive, the pricing was fair, and the whole experience was thoroughly enjoyable! Well done!
The food is mediocre at best, but when you factor in the terrible service and obscene prices it becomes downright criminal. I would suggest avoiding this restaurant altogether and selecting one of the many restaurants in town.
Food and service were very good but, I was definitely turned off by the restaurant allowing dogs in the dining room. Sorry but not at this price point. This was not a casual, outdoor setting where pets should be permitted.
Filet was perfect, oysters were flavorful and fresh. Overall great experience. Could use a little more decor in the dining room.
My first time at Gigi's. Loved it. I had the shrimp saganaki and a 6 oz filet mignon along with the beignets. Everything was delicious. I plan to go back as much as possible before the busy summer season when it becomes harder to get a spot.
First time to Montauk, we stumbled across Gigi's and it was an amazing meal. We would definitely recommend it.
The food was excellent, service was great. The only problem was the music that was playing. Very poor choice for dining.....
I bought tickets for dinner and NYE celebration. Dinner was excellent while party was absolutely not. I attended NYE party at Gurneys few years ago and it was fun: they had James Bond theme, entertainment, casino with fake money,. Overall my group had a blast. This year it was very simple, no theme, bad music, impossible to get a drink (open bar included in ticket) - understaffed bar and way too many people for the venue. I wouldn't recommend it for the price, isn't worth it.
We rang in the New Year's Eve at Gigi's and the experience was exceptional from start to finish. Mimmo and his team offered a gracious welcome that immediately made us feel like cherished guests rather than diners. Lunch featured a beautifully prepared shrimp cocktail, pristine fresh oysters, and a standout hamachi crudo accented with crispy garlic, capers, and sea salt. Service throughout was seamless and attentive, complementing a menu that was both refined and deeply flavorful. What truly set the experience apart was the care extended to our two children—the team went above and beyond to ensure they felt comfortable and included, and they are already asking when we can return. Special thanks to Mimmo for his thoughtful personal touches and remarkable hospitality. Grazie dal cuore.
I was with a party of four any everyone's meal (from appetizers to entrees and dessert) was amazing. The staff was super attentive and friendly which just made the experience that much better!
The ambience was excellent but the food was average for the cost. We did come for lunch so cannot comment on dinner selections. The host was fantastatic.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was delightful from the second the bread and mascarpone butter arrived! Felix provided excellent service and always took care of us. Love the restaurant since the renovation. Cocktails were 10/10.
Everything was perfect! Gigi's was a great place to celebrate a romantic Christmas dinner. Food and service were top notch. One of the most memorable meals I've ever had!
The settings in Guerney's is always a treat. Beautiful ocean views. Came for Christmas Eve dinner. The restaurant was packed. Service was great but kitchen was backed up. Food took longer than expected but our waiter kept us informed and apologized for the delay. They made up for it on the bill. Food was excellent. We all loved our dishes. While prices are high portions were big. Loved the lamb, chicken and pasta. Onion rings were perfectly done. The cheesecake and strawberry gelato were outstanding. All in all a nice holiday dinner.
Delicious food and an exceptional service. Beautiful ambiance in this newly done restaurant.
Great experience. It was a quiet night as it is off-season, but the food was excellent, the staff were attentive, the pricing was fair, and the whole experience was thoroughly enjoyable! Well done!
Loading...