I was disappointed that my entrée of halibut did not allow me to sub the vegetable. Lentils are not my favorite so therefore I had nothing but halibut. Lack of flexibility in October when there is very little customers was disappointing.
Rob
The place was spectacular! The hostesses and waitstaff were all great looking and full of themselves. Very Vanderpump-esque vibes! We watched them set and reset and adjust a table for a large group 5 times. Lots of primping but no real substance. Drinks were good food was tasty but portions on the small side. For the price point- not worth the trip. Better places in Montauk even off season.
Sam
My wife and I had a wonderful experience with you and we will bring our daughters there next! Very special day!
Therese
Ambience was beautiful. The service was very good. However, the food quality was not as expected for a place like that. The lobster roll bun was completely stale.
Norma
Food and service was wonderful. Everything was prepared perfectly. Service was on point. Will continue to make reservations.
Briana
Great drinks and food. Steak was cooked perfectly. Desert was delicious. Atmosphere was aesthetically pleasing.
Chris
The view from the patio is spectacular, and the wait staff was professional and accommodating. We really enjoyed our shrimp cocktail and oysters. A little different take on an old staple and it definitely made it memorable. My chicken sandwich was so good. Loved how nicely everything was presented and even the fries were perfect. My wife had a watermelon salad and she said it was the best she's ever had. Loved everything about this place.
Nicole
I dined at Gigi's by myself on a Saturday night in semi-off season. I had booked an outside table and when I got to my reservation time, they said they wouldn't have an outside table for me for another 20-25 minutes but could seat me inside. I was hungry so I chose an inside table but I wish I could've sat outside because inside was very wide and open and I felt very "alone" inside. My steak I ordered and onion rings were amazing. They were perfectly cooked. However, they arrived before my soda. I did feel like because I did not order alcohol, my service was not as good. It was odd that a diet coke was delivered a few minutes after my food arrived and no waiter came back to my table in time for me to ask for it. When my food arrived, my waiter did not come to ask if I needed anything else. He only came when I was just about done and he asked how the temperature was. So, overall, I had mixed feelings about Gigi's but I had a wonderful meal and I guess that's what is most important.
william
Food was very good, particularly the lobster tagliatelle. We also had scallops, very good but small , and a filet mignon .Delicious tuna tartar and mediocre grilled octopus, nicely charred but not much taste.Dessert was great , beignets and a caramel mousse.
Ginger
After a long tradition of eating at Gurney's each summer for many years... we couldn't wait to check out the renovation. We sat outside at Golden Hour admiring the magnificent views. The renovation is fabulous- outside lounge and bar is stunning with fire pits. Our food was exceptional and service very attentive. We will be back again.
The food was excellent! The vibe was great! The service was terrific! Great night!! A little pricy, but would go back in a heartbeat!
Barbara
Wonderful cocktails and beautiful restaurant! Food and service wonderful - had the perfect table with view for our anniversary!
mary
Great food as always and the epitome of good service..a very nice woman found a hair tie for me because the wind was blowing my hair in my face. And then she offered a pashmina
adam
Great food, service and location. The beignets were awful. Only real constructive criticism, everyone around us had their cell phone lights on, looking at the menu. We were getting blinded from all sides, very annoying. If you want to elevate your game, get illuminated menus. American Hotel in Sag has them and they are incredibly considerate to guests.
John
Lunch @ Gigi's on Sept. 10, 2025 - 3 people No maitre d' in attendance - Waited 10 minutes before finally being seated. Restaurant was about one quarter full. Service was polite and attentive. Food was good - I expected better than just good. Whole experience was good but, nothing special. I read the reviews beforehand and was expecting something better.
I was disappointed that my entrée of halibut did not allow me to sub the vegetable. Lentils are not my favorite so therefore I had nothing but halibut. Lack of flexibility in October when there is very little customers was disappointing.
The place was spectacular! The hostesses and waitstaff were all great looking and full of themselves. Very Vanderpump-esque vibes! We watched them set and reset and adjust a table for a large group 5 times. Lots of primping but no real substance. Drinks were good food was tasty but portions on the small side. For the price point- not worth the trip. Better places in Montauk even off season.
My wife and I had a wonderful experience with you and we will bring our daughters there next! Very special day!
Ambience was beautiful. The service was very good. However, the food quality was not as expected for a place like that. The lobster roll bun was completely stale.
Food and service was wonderful. Everything was prepared perfectly. Service was on point. Will continue to make reservations.
Great drinks and food. Steak was cooked perfectly. Desert was delicious. Atmosphere was aesthetically pleasing.
The view from the patio is spectacular, and the wait staff was professional and accommodating. We really enjoyed our shrimp cocktail and oysters. A little different take on an old staple and it definitely made it memorable. My chicken sandwich was so good. Loved how nicely everything was presented and even the fries were perfect. My wife had a watermelon salad and she said it was the best she's ever had. Loved everything about this place.
I dined at Gigi's by myself on a Saturday night in semi-off season. I had booked an outside table and when I got to my reservation time, they said they wouldn't have an outside table for me for another 20-25 minutes but could seat me inside. I was hungry so I chose an inside table but I wish I could've sat outside because inside was very wide and open and I felt very "alone" inside. My steak I ordered and onion rings were amazing. They were perfectly cooked. However, they arrived before my soda. I did feel like because I did not order alcohol, my service was not as good. It was odd that a diet coke was delivered a few minutes after my food arrived and no waiter came back to my table in time for me to ask for it. When my food arrived, my waiter did not come to ask if I needed anything else. He only came when I was just about done and he asked how the temperature was. So, overall, I had mixed feelings about Gigi's but I had a wonderful meal and I guess that's what is most important.
Food was very good, particularly the lobster tagliatelle. We also had scallops, very good but small , and a filet mignon .Delicious tuna tartar and mediocre grilled octopus, nicely charred but not much taste.Dessert was great , beignets and a caramel mousse.
After a long tradition of eating at Gurney's each summer for many years... we couldn't wait to check out the renovation. We sat outside at Golden Hour admiring the magnificent views. The renovation is fabulous- outside lounge and bar is stunning with fire pits. Our food was exceptional and service very attentive. We will be back again.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was excellent! The vibe was great! The service was terrific! Great night!! A little pricy, but would go back in a heartbeat!
Wonderful cocktails and beautiful restaurant! Food and service wonderful - had the perfect table with view for our anniversary!
Great food as always and the epitome of good service..a very nice woman found a hair tie for me because the wind was blowing my hair in my face. And then she offered a pashmina
Great food, service and location. The beignets were awful. Only real constructive criticism, everyone around us had their cell phone lights on, looking at the menu. We were getting blinded from all sides, very annoying. If you want to elevate your game, get illuminated menus. American Hotel in Sag has them and they are incredibly considerate to guests.
Lunch @ Gigi's on Sept. 10, 2025 - 3 people No maitre d' in attendance - Waited 10 minutes before finally being seated. Restaurant was about one quarter full. Service was polite and attentive. Food was good - I expected better than just good. Whole experience was good but, nothing special. I read the reviews beforehand and was expecting something better.
Loading...