Bagel Boys New City

48 Germonds Rd, New City
(845) 624-0000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Abdul Ahmed

waited 45 minutes for one bagel had me so angry not welcoming they were rude after makimg me wait just crazy.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

ziva piltch

Best bagels anywhere.

Roselyn

Didn’t physically go into this restaurant but my friend was on vacation and stopped and brought me home a bagel, when i tell you this bagel is the best bagel i’ve ever had, im in ohio writing this review enjoying the most delicious bagel 💕 my wait was only 1+ because friend drove 10 hours home with my bagel

Food: 5

Frank Eliett

This is a very good place to get your favorite bagels, they are very respectful and the attention is a plus

Jake G

Prices are crazy now, bacon egg and cheese is $8. I did a DoorDash order and got a sausage egg and cheese and a regular egg bagel. I received the sausage egg and cheese bagel, and an actual egg in a plastic cup container instead of an egg bagel. It’s funny but ridiculous lol.

Myla Felle B

Ordered a chicken salad with my salad and they forgot to put the chicken in. I called to have them reimburse the whole thing including the salad because what’s the point of eating a salad if there’s no protein ? Gave me a hard time. Said because I got the salad they can’t reimburse me. Never had this issue with any other location. Soooo… never coming back to this location.

Service: 1

Brian Mirenda

Burritos awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carol Ann Whisker

Staff very friendly and helpful

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Dunn

Everything is overpriced with cheap portions and the food sucks

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Emelia Estelle

Prices keep getting higher but portions keep getting smaller. Paid $20 for two bacon egg and cheeses that had approximately one slice of bacon between the two of them and was charged $2 extra for avocado. We watched them smear said avocado onto our sandwiches which was just the leftover avocado that they still had on their knife. I understand an extra charge for avocado, but I would expect more than a skid mark from someone else's sandwich.

Food: 4

Gabriel P

Everything is great food and ppl working but the girl with tattoos she’s always so serious and not so friendly I actually said good morning and she didn’t even respond.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Ana Ramirez

Specially ordered a certain sandwhich with no egg bc i’m allergic and they gave me so much egg in the sandwhich LOL! A waste of money and i can’t even eat it!!!! 0 attention whatsoever on the phone.

Lo Mein

A rip off…
High prices because they’re near the school…

$10 at min for a regular regular sandwich…

slim Indian guy behind the counter cooking/taking orders seems frustrated/ unhappy.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Shoshanna James

Food was mid. For a 10$ breakfast sandwich I was expecting a lot more. Just 1 slab of cheese, 1 piece of bacon, and eggs thrown on my NON pressed or toasted 2$ extra croissant. Not coming again and would not recommend.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Heavy77

$23 for 3 bagels W/ CC and 3 small drinks is completely outrageous

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...