Salvatore's Italian Bakery & Bagel Shoppe

9270 Kellogg Rd, New Hartford
(315) 737-5757

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Vicki Ward

Excellent bagels and tomato pie

Pam Zogby

Great smaller Italian bakery that's BIG on flavor.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liz Davis

Got the special Mother's Day box everything was beautiful and delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Collar Barkerson

The food is good but $9.19 for a Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a plain bagel is insane. Won’t be back. Not to mention the Menu price was $2 lower. Was told the menu written on the wall is outdated.

Joanne Schneider

For Christmas I searched out Italian bakeries within an hour of my house so I could get some old fashioned Italian cookies and pastries and I discovered Salvatore’s. Of course, I bought more than I originally intended and am thrilled with how delicious and fresh everything is. This is a little slice of Italy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Murphy

Great bakery! All the old Italian specialties!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew David Helmer

@followers @highlight Important information - my mother bought this without realizing. They are using Potassium Bromate in their products which is extremely toxic and banned in multiple countries. So let's eat it why don't we 😵‍💫🥴 ☣️ This is criminal and they should be held liable for poisoning people. #FDA #Corruption #RFK #RFKjr #toxicfood #PotassiumBromate #poison

Steven Madrak

I have gone to Salvatore for years and have always been satisfied. However recently I bought a large sausage roll for $18. It had little to no sausage in it, all bread with holes ! I’ve noticed the selection of pastries has been limited too . Too bad .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Birtie Barlowe

I don't like leaving negative reviews but their food literally made me vomit. Horrible stale pastries and the worst sandwiches I ever ate in my entire life! The bread was like old rubber and the meat was greasy, burnt and tasted gamey. Eat here at your own risk!

Doug Trialit

salvatore's is consistently delicious. hard to find. tip: it's BEHIND the sunoco gas station

Victorian Lady Antiques

Their cannoli and pastries are scrumptious! Highly recommended.

Marianne Goodenough

The Easter Bread was absolutely delicious and the pastries are always delicious, best place for baked goods !!!

Furry Kid

Love this place! I got my Dad a coconut cream pie for his birthday & it was delicious! The Italian cookies are incredible! I love their pizza crusts too & have been buying them at the grocery store for years! The cafe has a great atmosphere for having coffee & food! The staff are friendly & amazing as well! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Biscotti, Meatball, Almond Paste, Coconut Cream Pie

Marcelo Fuentes

Pushing your political views on people's faces is not the best strategy to attract customers, especially when that position is about how your love of guns is more important than the lives of other people and their kids.

Анастасія Ізотова

I like it ?

Loading...

Salvatore's Italian Bakery & Bagel Shoppe

9270 Kellogg Rd, New Hartford, NY 13413
(315) 737-5757