Maggie Mae's

215 Huguenot St, New Paltz
(845) 255-1960

Recent Reviews

Sort by
MJC

onion soup burnt, garden salad chx dry, avocado toast not sure what that was crab cakes and fish and chips greasy
service ok he was overwhelmed 1 server and bartender. drinks tara awful. place was dirty and full of flies. would not recommend

Sara

Great service and spectacular view! This place is a hidden gem. I highly recommend it!

Christina Schaller Towsley

We ate here tonight and the food was delicious, service was also fantastic. We will definitely return!

CEREN ZORLU

Had after graduation lunch here after graduating SUNY NEW PALTZ! Absolutely awesome and affordable! Love this !

Eric Bracken

This place is great, kinda tucked away but worth it. Was recommended by a couple locals we met while hiking. The best garlic Parm wings ever! They were great. And the burger was also fantastic. The Mac and cheese is too much, so many cheeses it just is two meals unto itself.

Dayna Mudge

Waitress was by herself,I should have left after the other people said they were sitting for 15 minutes and a blonde girl came with menus and never came back, finally another waitresses came in,we had chicken franchise,the chicken was thick and not pounded out,with a weird neon yellow gravy and no lemon taste, definitely would not order again,I guess the bar food would have been a better choice

Gerard Delia

French onion soup and chicken quesidilla was top notch! Waiter was a gentleman and we had a great view of the golf course. We are definitely going back.

Elizabeth HD

I would give this more stars if possible. The view, staff and food were fabulous. I can't decide if the quesadilla or the onion soup is better. Cant wait to come back for dinner!

E_ P_rry

We truly enjoyed the great service, good food, Guinness and an excellent homemade chocolate cake. It's a beautiful setting in the golf course at the end of historic Hugeunot street.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Fish and Chips

Shawn Sullinger

Best Rueben sandwhich we've ever had ,service was great , we will be back!! Love the golf course as well

Sue Gilmore

My husband and I went there for lunch. It was outstanding. I recommend the Malaka Burger if you like banana peppers and feta cheese. I ordered it rare and it came out rare! My husband ordered the pulled pork sandwich and before I knew it was gone from his plate. We sat outside on a late October afternoon in the sun looking over to the Gunks. You can't beat that. Our server was the best!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marti

The crabcake sandwich for $20 was nothing but a can of crab meat fried and put on a roll with some strange smelling spread. It was recommended to me by the establishment, and it’s not even lump crab… It had a slightly bitter taste

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Kelly Brooker

Another amazing dinner and drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Kerutis

Casual with great food. We go late afternoon and it's usually not too crowded. Great views of the golf course

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken and Waffles, French Onion Meatloaf, Fish and Chips

louis ferrara

Try the crabcake sandwich with homemade seasoned potato chips. Wash it down with a Sam Adam's

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...