16 Handles

1569 2nd Ave, New York
(646) 863-2522

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Daydream Frozen Yogurt No Sugar Added
Juniors Cheesecake Frozen Yogurt
Pomegranate Tart Frozen Yogurt
Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt
Original Tart Frozen Yogurt
Classic Tart Frozen Yogurt
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
Mint Chocolate Chip
Peach Sorbet Vegan
Taro Frozen Yogurt

Soft Serve Classics
Original Tart Frozen Yogurt
Tart and fresh fro-yo with a classic yogurt taste that balances tart and sweet flavors
Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt
Our fro-yo take on a classic cake batter ice cream
Old-Fashioned Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
Classic and creamy chocolate frozen yogurt made with real cocoa
Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
Delicious, silky sweet cream folded full with real OREO® cookies makes what might be our most delicious ice cream yet
Made with Nutella Frozen Yogurt
Chocolate-hazelnut frozen yogurt made with real Nutella swirled in

Specialty Soft-Serve
Oh My, Pumpkin Pie Frozen Yogurt
A seasonal classic made with real pumpkin, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, nutmeg, and fresh baked graham cookies. You're sure to fall in love!
Strawberry Fields Frozen Yogurt
Strawberry frozen yogurt with a summery, sweet taste you're sure to love
Graham Cracker Frozen Yogurt
Enjoy our sweet, cinnamon packed graham cracker frozen yogurt. A fan-favorite with real graham cracker pieces swirled in

Low & No Sugar Added Soft-Serve
Mint Chocolate Chip Frozen Yogurt
Who doesn't love the refreshing combination of mint and real chocolate? Our mint chip flavor is all natural and ultra-flavorful
Arriba Coffee Frozen Yogurt
Rich, dark roast coffee frozen yogurt made with 100% Arabica coffee beans
NSA Simply Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
Vanilla fro-yo made with no added sugar

Vegan (Dairy Free) Soft-Serve & Sorbet
Oatly Chocolate Soft Serve (V)
Chocolate lovers, prepare to be delighted. This chocolatey 16 Handles x Oatly oatmilk soft serve has all of the decadence but none of the dairy. Indulgence awaits-you just have to order it!
Oatly Caramel Apple Soft Serve (V)
Apple, caramel, and cinnamon flavors blend together to make an oatmilk soft serve as classic as apple pie. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
Coconut Water Sorbet (V)
A light, refreshing sorbet made with pure coconut water-no dairy, nothing artificial
Watermelon Sorbet (V)
Juicy, sweet, and summery watermelon sorbet. It's like a frozen picnic for your taste buds

Smoothies
Tropic Thunder Smoothie
Made with pineapple and mango
Brr Berry Smoothie
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries
BFF Smoothie
Made with strawberries and bananas
Surf's Up Smoothie
Made with strawberries and pineapple
Acai Elixir Smoothie
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and acai berries with guarana
Oh Kale Yeah! Smoothie
Made with pineapple, bananas, kale and spinach

Milkshakes
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Made with crushed Oreos
Chocolate Milkshake
Made with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce
Strawberry Milkshake
Made with fresh strawberries
Vanilla Milkshake
Made with premium vanilla syrup

Edible Cookie Dough by DO
Salty & Sweet Cookie Dough
Sugar cookie + salted caramel + dark chocolate chips + sea salt. 8 oz. container. Made by DO, Cookie Dough Confections.

Bottled Beverages
Can of Diet Coke
Water Bottle (16.9 oz)
Please note: brand my vary by location
Can of Sprite
Large Water Bottle (1L)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+46 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+45 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Very tasty frozen yogurt, lots of varieties! The staff don't serve you very well but the environment is very good. Plus it has a good price! The only problem is the staff, trust me! but the place is fantastic, love it!
April 2025
It’s a staple and a go-to of the area.
A kid-favorite for sure for self serve frozen yogurt and many toppings choices.

Cost will add up super quick so caution.
Good news is you don’t need much to enjoy.

The place’s age is starting to show a tad bit, needs a little TLC but it’s still ol’ reliable in terms of good quality frozen yogurt and the overall experience.
January 2025
16 Handles has a great variety of help-yourself toppings and the yogurt and ice cream flavors are delicious. Their store is clean and well run and it's comfortable and welcoming.
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

BurgerFi - 1571 2nd Ave
Hamburger, Burgers, Hot Dogs, American
Amura Japanese restaurant - 1567 2nd Ave
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Hutch and Waldo - 247 E 81st St
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Venues & Event Spaces, Pet Friendly, Vegan

16 Handles

1569 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
(646) 863-2522