Liberty Bagels 5th Ave

16 E 58th St, New York
(212) 355-0900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Leonelli

This place was so amazing. And so very friendly. It’s a must try the bagels are so delicious.

Jimin Yeum

I didn't expect too much but it was pretty good. I liked they have more flavored tofu options than other places.

Jeff T. Critic

Liberty Bagels – 5th Ave
French Toast Bagel with Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese:

When I saw a long line, I knew I was going to be in for a treat.

The cinnamon flavored cream cheese is a perfect fit for the French toast bagel.

The sideview appearance looks a little off, but it’s the taste that matters and I was highly satisfied.

#libertybagels #frenchtoastbagel #cinnamonwalnutraisin #creamcheese

Robert Lepping

Fantastic place! Best bagel sandwiches in NYC. Highly recommend!!!

Geoff Chan

Best bagel place in NYC! We've been back several times and never been disappointed!

d J

The food is ok, the customer service & Quality Control are awful. I work nearby and order breakfast frequently from this establishment and almost every single time. I have to walk back and retrieve the missing item , that I’ve ordered and paid for . It’s annoying and is ultimately pushing me to find other options in the area . If you order & pay for, something it should be in the bag!! Unacceptable. Also why are your prices instore way higher then the mobile app? i paid almost $6 extra today when ordering instore ,compared to what i pay in the app ordering the very same items. Very shady!

Stephen Khuu

Not sure what the negative reviews are about. Bagels are good, lox are good, people are good

That's all that matters

Erica Monarres

Absolutely the best! The bagels were so delicious and all the cream cheese were delicious. We went to the ones in Queens NYC The staff were great , Freedie was phenomenal! Will definitely come back!

Corrin S Tomkins

Great food, amazing selection and great service.

Kelly Walker

We went every morning while we were in town! Wish they shipped cause I could really go for once right about now! You have to stop by if you’re in NYC!

Sandra Martin Wright

Absolutely the best experience! The bagels were delicious and so were all the cream cheese flavors! The staff was great, and the owner was phenomenal! Will definitely be coming here every time I come to New York!!

Rich Moorby

Delicious food and really friendly service. The bagels were really excellent and I was surprised to find they even did gluten free bagels so I could eat a Reuben myself and not have to watch the family eat. The queue went down quickly and the host resolved a minor misunderstanding with our order in a really classy way. Would 100% recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jorge Luis Lara Farfan

The best bagels in the city. Juana was so kindly and took the time to explain me all the menu. Five star just for her.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra Brikho

Not worth the line. Avoid. It took a full hour to order and wait for mediocre breakfast bagels. Ordered 6 bagels and when my name was called it was only 4 bagels so I let them know and then he “fixed it” so then I left only to realize we were still missing one. Had to go back and get my husbands sandwich. Not cool. Very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Muhammad Nabil Ar-Rafi

I was so unsatisfied by the order. I’ve waited for one hour and a half just to get my order after I purchase it on-site, yet they finished making 6 bagels for the 20th-ish person behind me first before mine. I’ve asked 5 times with different staff, yet they didn’t make my order ASAP, instead they finished making it for the people behind me. I was so disappointed since I only ordered 3 simple bagels only…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...