AmaroneScarlatto

686 9th Ave #1, New York
(212) 730-4535

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Heidi

Great time here with my family before they went to a show! The dip with the bread was great, the salads were nice and different and I loved the bruschetta! The salmon was perfectly cooked too.

Erik

Food and service was average. Salmon was a salty, portion for the chicken parm and spaghetti was small for the price. Waiter took our order and wait was quite some times. Ask another server why taking so long then food came out in 3 minutes.

hilary

First time visit pre-theatre. My friend and I shared both an appetizer and main course which were both copious and delicious. Perfectly cooked grilled calamari and linguine vongole. They were so accommodating by setting aside the shrimp for me so that my friend could have the pasta with just the clams as she is allergic to shrimp. Our server was attentive and helpful. I would definitely return to this neighborhood gem.

Saco

Great find in the theater district. Delicious homemade pasta—lovely staff. Can't wait to go back!

Elizabeth

I would not recommend this restaurant. To start, the glass of wine was the smallest I've ever been served. While the bread and bruschetta were delicious, our entrées were edible. My husband ordered a New York strip cooked medium rare, but it arrived raw inside and cold. I had the Chicken Milanese, which was just okay at best. We were disappointed to say the least. Service and ambience were good.

NICKY

Service was poor. There was virtually no one in there but waiter failed to bring the pepper and parm cheese. I had to go find him and request it. There was no soda as the pump had no air (then you stock some cans, right). Food was good but again the service was atrocious!

Derek

We had a wonderful dinner here after our trip to the city, the food was delicious and the service exceptional. I would highly recommend this establishment.

Louie Huang

Delicious food. Amazing staff. Had a great date and we lost track of time but they didn't bother us or even try to rush us out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

SIMON MAIN

booked last minute it was busy with a great atmosphere food and wine priced great puddings were to die for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carter Lee

Amarone was amazing. Tremendous atmosphere and service. Took great care of our Table of 8.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ted Powers

Made a reservation via Opentable and arrived a bit early. Staff was friendly and let us sit early, filled our water. Space is fine typical Italian style. We waited 10 minutes for the rest of our party to arrive and in the meantime tried to order wine. We were told that they only had 1 bottle in the whole restaurant ($125), but they had wine by the glass. Fine, we ordered a martini and a red wine. When our party arrived, I tried to order some calamari and other appetizers. It was then that the restaurant told me they did not have calamari, salmon, meatballs, and chicken parm, and some others. The maitre d apologized and said they didn't get their seafood delivery. At this point, I paid the bar tab and we left. The menu is not extensive and they didn't have a number of items and didn't let us know when we came in. I don't know how they didn't have chicken parm or meatballs.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Michelle Dossett

Great find, azalea chicken so good!
Great staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dr Potatoe

Service was excellent. Food was ok, but for the price would of expected better. In addition a steak was ordered medium and came out well done. Portion sizes were to be expected small. Atmosphere was nice but very drafty.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Janet

Welcoming environment, staff is accommodating, delicious food, nice neighborhood and good for pre-theatre meal. Would recommend it.

David Pennella

A Manhattan restaurant that interprets “extra dry Martini” as adding extra dry vermouth—even after clarification, twice—is done ⚰️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Loading...