AmaroneScarlatto

686 9th Ave #1, New York
(212) 730-4535

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+86 photos
+85 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We ate here for lunch on a slow day and had the entire restaurant to ourselves. The restaurant had very cute decor, with flowers & wine bottles, and videos of Italy were shown on the TV screen. Service was prompt and personable. We ate the Arancini and Pear Salad appetizers, both excellent. The Rigatoni was also very tasty, but the standout dish was the Chicken Azalea! The house Chianti was good and inexpensive. Location was in Hell's Kitchen and very close to most shows.
A real disappointment compared to our experiences from years ago, which were exceptional. Tonight, food was mediocre, way too salty, many items on the menu were not available. Service was good. Not going back.

Some of the worst Italian food I've ever had -- branzino was probably the worst fish I've had anywhere, mostly salt with some fish, really bad.

A number of much better Italian restaurants nearby including Nizza and Mamma...
Food was totally adequate. Service was fine. Nothing special. Not a rip off, but not something that is going to get any blow out food reviews. Given its proximity to Time Sq, not a terrible option, but try harder if you are looking to for something special.

More Reviews