Amish Market

731 9th Ave, New York
(212) 245-2360

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Terry Brennan

Nobody was wearing a bonnet. That's disappointing.

Cazzyp P

Nice stocked store

Harvey Messing

I like to take food home from their hot and cold food bar. The supermarket is located on 9th Avenue, between 49th and 50th Streets, and is on two levels. That store's street location offers a view of the tallest residential building in the world. I found that their salmon was very pleasing in taste. It seems to be available every day. When I was there they had 12 items available from the food bar that are traditionally served at home warm/hot. Pay with cash to save money. Their grocery prices are less than most of the hells kitchen area stores.

Abie Sayas

This marks the fifth occasion on which I have placed an order through DoorDash. Unfortunately, it appears that there have been oversights in processing the incoming orders. Upon contacting their customer service, I was informed that they are occasionally overwhelmed with requests. It is evident that improvements are necessary in their system. Regrettably, my assigned delivery driver had to wait for over an hour to collect a sandwich. I have decided against placing any future orders with them.

Dalton Skach

The ultimate hidden gem of grocery stores in midtown manhattan. I may never shop at Whole Foods again. Amish Market had every healthy option I could ask for and more. I’m genuinely excited to go back.

Ashani

Second time here and I got the salmon and was constantly picking out bones from the fish, I couldn’t even enjoy my food. It wasn’t like this when I got the salmon yesterday. Would not come back. Not worth the price

America H Borda

This place is great

Mark Wilson

Look at the naan with mold. I’m disgusted! Do they check the shelves? Had just stopped in to get fruit.

Smitty Knickerbocker

Cool place in the city, walked by so many times never noticed it

Carmelo Marco Sferrazza

It was recommended to me by a friend.
I had dinner taking "take away" food and I had a great time.
Furthermore, I also paid little.
Recommended and cheap

Tong Liu

Pretty solid little grocery shop, good stuff

Sara Ch.

Loving the selection of jams, honey, and yogurt here especially.
.
Fresh fruits and hot-cooked meals are also great and very affordable in NYC.
.
I just love the experience of walking in here and peaceful grocery shopping, and the staff is nice as well.
.
One of the good points is they have cutlery for you and a place to sit and eat in front of the market!

Fatima Zafar

Nice place to grab fresh food

Alaiddin Kölgesiz

We were going because the owner was Turkish. The most beautiful market around. There are also Turkish dishes in the dining options. For tea drinkers, we were drinking shake tea for 50 cents for hot water.

Kristofor Fan

When ordering from this store through Seamless, it goes through a separate app called Mercado that doesn't allow substitutions. I showed up and had to request a refund for the specific items they didn't have and then put in another order with substitutes. This whole process took 30 minutes for what should've been in and out. The whole time the staff was unhelpful and unfriendly about it and seemed pissed at me for something that is 100% not my fault.

Loading...