Avrilililly's Creamery LLC

1610 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(917) 265-8449

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
Cookies & Cream Vegan Ice Cream
Olive Oil and Basil Gelato
Lemonade Raspberry Sorbet
Pride of the Town Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Amaretti Cookies
Banana Pudding
Hola Nicciola
Sugar Cookie

Featured items
Buy 3 Cookies Get 1 Free
Choose from our sugar cookies, chocolate chip cookies, white chocolate chip & pecan cookies or granola raisin cookies; buy 3, get 1 free
Oh My Apple Pie
Yummy deconstructed apple pie - vanilla gelato with caramelized apples and buttered graham crackers
Hola Nocciola
Hazelnut based gelato with 'Ferrero Roche' and our chocolate chip cookies
Banana Pudding
Delightfully light and airy banana pudding with plenty of bananas and wafers
Almond Brioche Bread Pudding
This is no ordinary bread pudding. It's made with raisins, almond and butter croissants which lend to a rich flavor; it's then topped with our cream sauce.
Tres Leches
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our chocolate chip cookies are baked to perfection; large round cookies, crispy along the edges with a nice and chewy center, with the perfect balance between chocolate and cookie dough.
Cookies, Cookies n" Cream
Sweet cream base gelato with crumbled Oreos and Hershey"s cookies and cream chocolate bar.
Sugar Cookies
These sugar cookies are super delightful, rolled in sugar, nice and crispy along the edges with a buttery, sugary and chewy heavenly center. If sugar cookies are your thing, you will not go wrong with these cookies.
Coonut Flan
Coconut Flan

Vegan Pints
Passionfruit Sorbet - Vegan
A sweet and tangy-tart refreshing sorbet! Delicious on it's own, but can be easily dressed up with a side of bubbly!

Avrililillys Signature Pints
Hola Nocciola
Hazelnut based gelato with 'Ferrero Roche' and our chocolate chip cookies
Vanilla Waffle Cones (2 Cones)
2 vanilla waffle cones in our signature pink. Each cone is handmade and rolled in house.

Avrilililly's Gelato Pints
Cookies, Cookies n" Cream
Sweet cream base gelato with crumbled Oreos and Hershey"s cookies and cream chocolate bar.
Vanilla Waffle Cones (2 Cones)
2 vanilla waffle cones in our signature pink. Each cone is handmade and rolled in house.
Passionfruit Sorbet - Vegan
A sweet and tangy-tart refreshing sorbet! Delicious on it's own, but can be easily dressed up with a side of bubbly!
Oh My Apple Pie
Yummy deconstructed apple pie - vanilla gelato with caramelized apples and buttered graham crackers

Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our chocolate chip cookies are baked to perfection; large round cookies, crispy along the edges with a nice and chewy center, with the perfect balance between chocolate and cookie dough.
Sugar Cookies
These sugar cookies are super delightful, rolled in sugar, nice and crispy along the edges with a buttery, sugary and chewy heavenly center. If sugar cookies are your thing, you will not go wrong with these cookies.
White Chocolate Chip with Pecan Cookies
Buy 3 Cookies Get 1 Free
Choose from our sugar cookies, chocolate chip cookies, white chocolate chip & pecan cookies or granola raisin cookies; buy 3, get 1 free

Dessert
Coonut Flan
Coconut Flan
Tres Leches
Oreo Cheesecake

Puddings
Banana Pudding
Delightfully light and airy banana pudding with plenty of bananas and wafers
Almond Brioche Bread Pudding
This is no ordinary bread pudding. It's made with raisins, almond and butter croissants which lend to a rich flavor; it's then topped with our cream sauce.

Pastries (Monday - Friday)
Almond Croissant
A lovely hand-laminated croissant with almond frangipane and almond paste tucked inside. Baked and delivered daily by balthazar bakery.
Everything Croissant
A delightful croissant dressed in an everything seasoned topping and filled with an herbed cream cheese filling. Baked and delivered daily by balthazar bakery.

Beverages
Hot Chocolate
Cappuccino
Our coffees are sourced from anèri tricafe, a small-batch artisanal Italian coffee company located in Serravalle, Italy which is situated in the Italian region of Piemonte. Anèri is one of 5 remaining wood-burning coffee roasters in Italy. Their coffees are a blend of beans sourced from robustas and aranicas from South America and regions of India and Africa, combined to form a classic European blend.
Tea
Iced Tea
Iced Cappuccino
Latte
Mocha
Matcha Latte
Iced Matcha
Chai Latte
Iced Chai
Iced Latte
Iced Mocha
Americano
Bottle Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: ubereats
+15 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+14 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I’m honestly obsessed with these cookies. They are incredibly delicious and so appetizing. What I love the most is that I’m usually not into sweets at all, but these are just perfect.

They’re not overly sweet — just the right balance. The almond flavor is so rich and comforting, and the cherry adds this slight sour touch that makes everything come together beautifully. It’s such an amazing combination.

I genuinely fell in love with...
March 2026
As a local I’ve only recently went in as I had a sweet tooth. Tried their tres leche gelato and it was delicious. Came back to get a pint and though it was sold out the owner was so kind and gracious on letting me know when they’ll have more. Everything is made in house and I appreciate buying locally and supporting a small business. Will be back to try their coffee
December 2025
My daughter loved the cupcakes, and i loved their price as well as the decor and feel of the bakery. Home has changed lots since ive moved. The only thing that could be better was the person at the register, he was highly engaged in his phone so his responses/interaction was quick short, kind of like he didnt want to be bothered. Overall the place the is 😍
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Oso - 1618 Amsterdam Ave
Mexican, Cocktail Bar, Spanish, Vegan
Fumo Harlem - 1600 Amsterdam Ave
Italian, Pizza, Bar, Vegan
Oasis Jimma Juice Bar - 1620 Amsterdam Ave
Juice Bar & Smoothies, Salad, Juice

Avrilililly's Creamery LLC

1610 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031
(917) 265-8449