Bagel Talk

368 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 875-1267

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pedro Sanchez

Fresh out of the oven bagels 😋😋

paul gordon

Bagel was good.

John Lucchese

They put virtually no vegetable cream cheese on my bagel. A real gyp. I was too far away to take it back or I would have

Sami 83

Good bagels.

christopher stokes

If you want variety, quality and flavor go to Bagel & Co. one block up

Penny Black

Dirty place with an old woman who rolls your eyes at you when you return a bagel order that was improperly done. Grow up lady! It’s not a personal insult, you just don’t know how to do your job right. I would not recommend this place for breakfast, rushed lopsided sandwiches and $9 orange juice. might as well go to zabar’s!!

Anna Dykeman

The best of the best bagels in the city. The guys inside are also absolutely amazing!

David Lederman

Bagel Talk sent the wrong order. Won't replace. Not even close to what i ordered.

VICTORIA B

Tried to order from GrubHub they cancelled it bc they didn’t have an item on the order. I ordered an egg sandwich on a bagel and coffee. Yikes. That’s not a good sign.

Kristofer SeppÀlÀ

Loved it! Great experience, everything was delicious.

Phoebe Holland

I ordered a pastrami sandwich for takeout and there was only one slice of pastrami; rest was lettuce and tomato. For $15, it was not enough pastrami. However, the bagel tasted pretty good.

Shaleen Sheth

Good bagels with plenty of different options for cream cheese and bagel type. Ordered a lox and they gave a great amount of salmon.

Frank Price

Wonderful! Came here on the advice of a “best bagels” article and was absolutely not disappointed. Got the ultimate nova on sesame.

Andrew Ericson

I thought I would give it a post-closure try. Ordered a bagel with whitefish. The bagel was good, but the whitefish was merely a think spread layer ... not a sandwich quantity. I thought it was lame. Counter guys were grumpy, not sure if this is new management but I don't remember them being so dour.

Cristina Mitra

Solid bagel spot, but the atmosphere is in need of major TLC with duct tape holding up most of the ceiling. My nova sandwich was very tasty and so much lox it was like they were giving it away.

Loading...