Tasty Pizza and cozy atmosphere. outdoor seating available. I highly recommend the Penne vodka pizza!
Jenny Yang
Ordered pizza for delivery and it took more than an hour to arrive. The driver who was picking up my order texted me saying that they just started to make my order when he arrived. The pizza was okay, nothing really special about it.
Harrison Vivas
Mediocre - decent dough but cheese sub par. Oily
Will E.
Returned recently and had the Margherita & the Vodka slice. Both tasted very good; they were crispy and well balanced in terms of cheese and sauce. Thumbs up again.
Seth Rose
I ordered a plain pie thru the app at 8:00. It said the pizza would be here between 8:29-8:44. Its now 9:10 and no pizza. They’re not answering messages or the telephone AND Google says that they’re closed now. So they took our money for the pizza & delivery fee & tip & another fee $34+ and then closed up shop without a word.
Seth R.
I ordered a plain pie thru the app at 8:00. It said the pizza would be here between 8:29-8:44. Its now 9:10 and no pizza. They're not answering messages or the telephone AND Google says that they're closed now. So they took our money for the pizza & delivery fee & tip & another fee $34+ and then closed up shop without a word.
Antonius Oki Wiriadjaja
I had a slice here and it tasted like cardboard. I couldn't finish it. It's sad because the people seem really nice, and the location is convenient. But I would just walk a little north to Nolita and grab a slice from there instead.
chloe nash
This was truly the best slice of pizza I have ever had. I have thought about the pizza every single day since i had it and will 100% be going back. The employee was also very nice
DAILY ARSLAN
Chloe Nash
Gina Baurile
Happened to be near the court house and was wandering around trying to find a simple inexpensive lunch when I came across the neon Baxter Street Pizza sign.For $3.50, I was super pleased with the crispy thin crust, not too cheesy, just enough pepperoni slice that I took to-go.I messed up by not taking advantage of the lunch special (2 slices + drink = ~$6). I really messed up by not getting the ziti slice, which I’ll try next time!
This is a family pizza joint. Kids loved it and the employees are so friendly. We enjoyed the cocktails and we were even offered one on the house. So sweet. We’ll be back.
Meg Hoplin
Amazing tasting pizza! Best kept secret!
Leslie W.
The vodka sauce pizza was amazing! Quick service and food choices to suit and grab a slice (or two).
Cervante B.
A delicious pizza, with great flavor. Highly recommend the New Yorker! Customer service was good as well.
Jon O.
Hidden spot and away from the madness that's on Canal St and Mulberry right next to the park. Great slices and prices. Wouldn't have known this place was here due to the construction across the street but glad to found this spot. A must go.
Tasty Pizza and cozy atmosphere. outdoor seating available. I highly recommend the Penne vodka pizza!
Ordered pizza for delivery and it took more than an hour to arrive. The driver who was picking up my order texted me saying that they just started to make my order when he arrived. The pizza was okay, nothing really special about it.
Mediocre - decent dough but cheese sub par. Oily
Returned recently and had the Margherita & the Vodka slice. Both tasted very good; they were crispy and well balanced in terms of cheese and sauce. Thumbs up again.
I ordered a plain pie thru the app at 8:00. It said the pizza would be here between 8:29-8:44. Its now 9:10 and no pizza. They’re not answering messages or the telephone AND Google says that they’re closed now. So they took our money for the pizza & delivery fee & tip & another fee $34+ and then closed up shop without a word.
I ordered a plain pie thru the app at 8:00. It said the pizza would be here between 8:29-8:44. Its now 9:10 and no pizza. They're not answering messages or the telephone AND Google says that they're closed now. So they took our money for the pizza & delivery fee & tip & another fee $34+ and then closed up shop without a word.
I had a slice here and it tasted like cardboard. I couldn't finish it. It's sad because the people seem really nice, and the location is convenient. But I would just walk a little north to Nolita and grab a slice from there instead.
This was truly the best slice of pizza I have ever had. I have thought about the pizza every single day since i had it and will 100% be going back. The employee was also very nice
Chloe Nash
Happened to be near the court house and was wandering around trying to find a simple inexpensive lunch when I came across the neon Baxter Street Pizza sign.For $3.50, I was super pleased with the crispy thin crust, not too cheesy, just enough pepperoni slice that I took to-go.I messed up by not taking advantage of the lunch special (2 slices + drink = ~$6). I really messed up by not getting the ziti slice, which I’ll try next time!
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a family pizza joint. Kids loved it and the employees are so friendly. We enjoyed the cocktails and we were even offered one on the house. So sweet. We’ll be back.
Amazing tasting pizza! Best kept secret!
The vodka sauce pizza was amazing! Quick service and food choices to suit and grab a slice (or two).
A delicious pizza, with great flavor. Highly recommend the New Yorker! Customer service was good as well.
Hidden spot and away from the madness that's on Canal St and Mulberry right next to the park. Great slices and prices. Wouldn't have known this place was here due to the construction across the street but glad to found this spot. A must go.