The Pie Guy Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours today·

About The Pie Guy Pizza

The Pie Guy Pizza is a popular pizza spot known for its delicious offerings and big flavors. Located at 83-85 Baxter St, New York, this small restaurant serves a thin crust pizza that is a highlight, featuring a good balance of fresh, salty, and sweet flavors in the sauce. The Margherita variety is particularly recommended and has received praise for its delicious sauce and excellent crust flavor. Customers have also enjoyed the Pepperoni Slice, which is topped with an abundant supply of pepperoni cups, ensuring a flavorful bite. The restaurant offers garlic knots with melted parmesan as a tasty side. The crust is crispy on the outside and soft inside, and the toppings are fresh and generous. While the crust can be a bit dry at times, some customers feel that a little extra time in the oven could enhance the crispiness. Overall, The Pie Guy Pizza provides great value and quality, making it an excellent option for a quick, affordable lunch or takeout. The pizza is New York style, and the vibe inside is calm and cozy, with a family-friendly feel. The staff are known for being kind, friendly, and courteous, and service is fast even during busy hours. Customers say the subway station is close by for easy connectivity, making it a welcoming atmosphere where neighbors gather, friendships are made, and every slice is served with a side of kindness.

Menu

Add a Menu
The Pie Guy Pizza Menu
The Pie Guy Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
The Pie Guy Pizza
The Pie Guy Pizza
View All Photos

The Pie Guy Pizza Reviews

4.6
155 ratings
5
74%
4
9%
3
8%
2
1%
1
8%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about The Pie Guy Pizza

This pizza shop is one of my favorite New York style pizza in all over China town. I enjoyed the place & the vibe inside this place was very calm. The staff weren't rushing and it was a pleasant experience. I'll definitely go there when I am in NYC the next time and the MTA Subway station is so close for easy connectivity.
It's a small place. There's only 3 seats. Pizza was good, and friendly service. Very affordable. Slices were about $4.50 ish each
This is one of my favorite stops for pizza, definitely worth it

Read All Reviews(155)

Hours

Monday 10AM - 8PM
Tuesday 10AM - 8PM
Wednesday 10AM - 8PM
Thursday 10AM - 12AM
Friday 11AM - 12AM
Saturday 11AM - 12AM
Sunday 12 - 8PM
Updated on: