50 Best Pizza Restaurants in New York

“Ci Siamo is an amazing Italian restaurant, known for its delicious and satisfying dishes. The caramelized onion Torta, Cast Iron Focaccia, Rye Ravioli, and smashed potatoes are highly recommended. Fish dishes are also excellent, and the service is impeccable. A must-visit for a light and delicious meal.“

“Una Pizza Napoletana is a restaurant known for its excellent Neapolitan-style pizzas and welcoming ambiance. Upon arriving, guests may need to wait for a table, but the friendly and efficient service makes the wait worthwhile. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, with a standout dough that is considered by many to be exceptional. The sauce, while praised by some, has been criticized by others for lacking the rich flavor of homemade sauce. The temperature of the pizza has also been noted to cool down quickly, affecting the overall dining experience. Despite these minor criticisms, the desserts, such as the Almond Cremolata, have been highly recommended. The restaurant's peaceful and quiet atmosphere, combined with the attentive staff, create a soul-nourishing environment. In summary, Una Pizza Napoletana offers a unique pizza experience, with its standout dough and toppings, making it a recommended destination for pizza lovers.“

“Scarr's Pizza is a popular New York pizza spot known for its delicious pies. The restaurant offers both takeout and dine-in options, with a cozy seating area in the back. While the pizza is consistently praised as excellent, some customers have noted the staff can be hit or miss, with varying levels of friendliness. Overall, Scarr's is a beloved local favorite, with one reviewer even having the pizza catered for their wedding.“

“Mel's offers delicious dishes, including a variety of pizzas such as guanciale and shrimp scampi. The atmosphere is lively and perfect for groups, as evidenced by a fun-filled birthday celebration. Standouts include the mushroom pizza and rhubarb dessert. Attentive service and great cocktails contribute to a memorable dining experience.“

“Pasquale Jones is a cozy Italian restaurant in Soho known for its clam pizza and attentive service. While some dishes like the lemon pasta and salad fell short, the fish sashimi appetizer and beets salad were fresh and tasty. The staff, especially waiter McCabe, went above and beyond to accommodate strict dietary needs, ensuring a delicious meal for a happy customer. The ambiance is charming, with a clean bathroom and friendly service. Overall, Pasquale Jones offers a mixed dining experience with hits and misses, but stands out for its personalized attention to customer needs and standout dishes like the clam pizza.“

“Loring Place is a lovely restaurant a few blocks from Washington Square Park. The food is elevated, clean, and precise, with highlights like crudo, asparagus fries, hummus, and grandma-style pizza. The atmosphere is welcoming and peaceful, with warm minimal design touches. The staff is kind, thoughtful, and accommodating, providing great service. The cocktails are very good and reasonably priced. The atmosphere offers great spacing, lighting, and acoustics for any occasion, making Loring Place highly recommended for a flavorful and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Rubirosa serves delicious food in a comfortable and homey atmosphere. The staff is fast, friendly, and laid-back. Pizza lovers will enjoy the thin and crispy crust, with options like half-and-half flavors. Other popular dishes include family-size pasta, caprese, rice balls, and tiramisu for dessert. A great spot for a authentic New York dining experience.“

“Lil' Frankie's is an amazing spot in NYC with good energy and fantastic food. The atmosphere is beautiful and authentic, perfect for a late-night hangout. The legendary lemon pasta and handmade spinach ravioli are especially delicious. The truffle pizza is average, but the burrata pizza is a must-try. The eggplant appetizer and ravioli pasta with homemade tomato sauce are also top picks. Despite the small and visually uncomfortable space, the service is great and the inclusive vibe makes it a pleasant experience. Recommended for Italian food lovers, pizza enthusiasts, vegetarians, and late-night diners. Just be prepared for difficult parking and small, but clean bathrooms.“

“Double Zero is a favorite restaurant in the city, known for exceptional vegan food that doesn't disappoint. Dishes like truffle cashew cream pizza and salads are perfectly made. The blood orange spritzer comes highly recommended. The staff, especially Sha, provides top-notch service, making each visit a pleasant experience. Whether eating soy/dairy-free or not, Double Zero guarantees a delicious meal that leaves you full and happy.“

“John's of Bleecker Street is a highly-recommended restaurant in New York, known for its freshly made pizzas with delicious sauces and smooth cheese. The pizza has a perfect ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings, with a nicely charred bottom and crunchy crust. Vegetarian options are available, with the option to add meat on the side. The restaurant has a great atmosphere, and the service is fast and friendly. It is known to have an amazing coal-fired pizza crust that gives it a unique flavor. The restaurant has been a staple in the city for a long time and is a must-visit for pizza lovers.“

“L'industrie Pizzeria West Village is a popular spot that consistently draws a crowd. Despite the online hours being incorrect, the restaurant is worth visiting for its amazing pizzas with perfect dough and great toppings. The burrata slice is a must-try, and the desserts, including the tiramisu, are exceptional. The wait times can be long, but visiting during off-peak hours, like the afternoon, can result in a shorter wait. Overall, the West Village location is just as good, if not better, than the original Williamsburg location, with everything on the menu being a hit.“

“Kesté Pizza e Vino offers a cozy, rustic ambiance with wooden furniture and exposed brick walls, creating a homely atmosphere. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing great recommendations. The menu includes a variety of options, with the Vegetariana pizza being a standout choice. The 8” pizza option is filling for a single person, although customization is not available. The gluten-free crust is a hit, and the pomodo pizza is described as exquisite. The mozzarella & prosciutto pizza fell short, but the Diavola was worth trying. The overall experience is like a journey to Naples in the heart of New York City, with walkable distance from WTC.“

“Fumo Harlem is a top-rated restaurant that consistently delivers great customer service, ambiance, and food. The menu offers a range of options, including lunch specials that are economical and delicious. Standout dishes include the spicy calamari, penne with mushroom and truffle, lobster spaghetti, and the popular "Roni" pizza. The Fried Mozz and Kale Caesar salad are also recommended as appetizers. While some reviewers have experienced slow service, the staff is generally helpful and friendly. With its great energy, consistent food quality, and reasonably priced drinks, Fumo Harlem is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal and a good time.“

“Joe's Pizza Broadway serves authentic NY-style pizza that's really good. Be prepared for long lines, but the service is super fast and efficient, allowing the lines to move quickly. Individual slices are a good option, as they're cooked to perfection. Despite the wait, the pizza is great, making it a worthwhile experience, especially for its iconic atmosphere and celebrity-filled decor. Pack some patience and stop in for a memorable visit.“

“La Lanterna di Vittorio is a charming restaurant located on MacDougal Street in the West Village. The atmosphere is unique, with a lovely enclosed patio and a rich history. The menu offers a wide variety of options, including Neapolitan-style pizza, which is cooked to perfection with a delightful chewiness. The drinks menu is also impressive, with a hard coffee being a particular highlight. The cheese and pate plate is a solid option, although the presentation may not be the most visually appealing. Despite being a bit crowded and noisy, the restaurant is a solid choice for a night out, with good food and a nice patio to enjoy.“

“Stretch Pizza offers an inventive and creative take on pizza, with a focus on quality ingredients and attention to detail. The staff is described as awesome, and the restaurant is considered kid-friendly. While the pizza has received mixed reviews, with some finding it just fine and others considering it the best in the city, the overall experience is praised for its unique approach to pizza-making.“

“Ace's Pizza offers fresh, hot, and delicious Detroit-style pizza with a delightful caramelized crust. The menu features a white sesame pizza that is creamy, cheesy, and well-balanced. Service is efficient, and the restaurant has a friendly and inviting atmosphere. Enjoy your meal while people-watching at this iconic NYC spot. Prices are reasonable, and the wait time is short.“

“Pepperoni Tony's in Midtown NYC serves hot and delicious food, including phenomenal classic pepperoni pizza. Be prepared for crowds, especially during peak hours, and consider arriving early to avoid waiting. Despite occasional lapses in service, the quick and friendly staff make up for it with great food that's definitely worth the wait.“

“Joe & Pat's NYC is a pizzeria known for its super thin and crispy pizza with high-quality, fresh ingredients. The restaurant has an old school vibe with friendly staff and a full bar. The service can be slow when the restaurant is busy, but the food, including the Sausage broccoli rabe pie, is worth the wait. The tri pie and bruschetta are also popular menu items. The lighting is a bit dim, creating a specific aesthetic. The restaurant has a limit of 500 ratings, which adds to its exclusive feel.“

“Motorino Pizzeria is a gem for pizza lovers, offering a delightful balance of traditional Italian flavors and innovative twists. The pizza features a perfectly charred crust, fresh ingredients, and friendly, attentive staff. The vegan pizzas are a hit, especially when paired with a Chardonnay. The cozy spot in EV is perfect for Neapolitan style pizza lovers, with favorites like the meatball and amatriciana pizzas. The dough is thin, chewy, and crispy, making it a must-visit for those craving a slice of Italy in the heart of the city.“

“Brunetti Pizza West Village offers exceptional service with friendly staff like Antonio. Their pizzas, such as the crimini mushroom with caramelized onion and goat cheese, are top-notch. They cater well to dietary restrictions like gluten-free options. Each visit promises a new standard of excellence in every bite, making it a must-visit spot in New York for pizza lovers.“

“Two Boots Pizza East Village offers a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff and good prices. The Newman pizza, with a thin crust and white sauce base, is a must-try item on their menu. They also have vegan options available, although more variety would be appreciated. The place attracts a diverse crowd, from groups of friends enjoying pizza to young boys playing cards without any phones in sight. The chicken bombini and Spin-Art bombini are flavorful and satisfying choices for a light meal. Overall, Two Boots Pizza East Village is a great spot in New York City for pizza lovers.“

“Gelso & Grand is a casual spot with a charming outdoor seating area on a traffic-blocked street. The service is attentive and speedy, making it a solid choice for a chill evening out. Their Brussels sprouts and pasta dishes are particularly popular, and the tiramisu is a sweet treat. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it's a great spot to enjoy a meal with friends or celebrate a special occasion. The staff, led by manager Chris, go above and beyond to ensure a memorable experience.“

“Daddies is a small, intimate restaurant in the West Village. The menu offers a variety of options, including pizza, pasta, and Italian-inspired dishes. The restaurant accepts credit cards, despite the chalkboard menu indicating it is a cash-only establishment. The atmosphere is lively, with loud music that can make it difficult to converse with dinner companions. The food is fresh and satisfying, with options like the vodka sauce pizza and Limone Pasta. Despite some minor issues, Daddies is a great option for those looking for a unique dining experience.“

“Emmett's on Grove is a popular restaurant serving unique pizzas with thin crust and crispy semolina base. The menu features creative topping combinations, such as the "hot papi" and "hot girl" pizzas. The restaurant's atmosphere is lively, but can be loud, making it more suitable for gatherings with friends rather than dates. The service is genuine and lovely, with standout staff members. In addition to the great pizzas, the bleu cheese stuffed olives are a highlight. Be prepared for a bustling atmosphere, especially on weekends, and consider ordering a reasonable amount of food, as the pizzas don't reheat well. Overall, Emmett's on Grove is a great spot for a fun dinner with friends.“

“Mama's TOO! is a popular restaurant in New York known for its thick, square-shaped pizza slices. A slice costs $6 and is large, offering good value. The restaurant is often busy, with a line outside, but it moves quickly. Seating is limited, so diners may opt to stand outside or find a nearby park to enjoy their meal. Mama's TOO! offers unique flavors like poached pear, as well as classic options such as cheese, pepperoni, and vodka. The cheese steak and bruschetta are standouts. The "Angry Nonna" slice is a customer favorite. The pizza has a crispy crust and generous toppings, making it a popular choice for groups who can easily share the large slices. However, there is no indoor seating, which may be a drawback on cold or rainy days.“

“The Marshal is a beloved neighborhood restaurant in Hell's Kitchen, known for its delicious American-style cuisine. The menu features a variety of comfort foods, including wood-fired pizzas with generous toppings and a soft, charred crust. The pesto is made from scratch, and the bread sticks are freshly baked on the spot. The staff is friendly and chatty, and the cocktails are expertly crafted. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with tightly packed seating, making it a great spot to meet new people. With its reasonable prices and excellent service, The Marshal is a great choice for anyone looking for a satisfying meal in the area.“

“Marcellino offers a lively atmosphere with excellent service, great food, and a variety of options. Vegetarian choices include pizza, pasta, and bruschetta. Standout dishes include salmon and meatballs, while the mozzarella appetizer and raspberry blossom drink are also popular.“

“Sotto 13 is a highly-recommended restaurant known for its exceptional service and delicious food. The staff, including Alessio, are attentive and friendly, ensuring that diners feel taken care of throughout their meal. The menu offers a range of options, including pizza, pasta, and signature dishes like the smoked salmon and Prosecco Tray. With a beautiful and cozy atmosphere, including a stunning room with a skylight, Sotto 13 is a great spot for a special occasion or a night out with friends.“

“The Frenchman's Dough serves exceptional dishes, including the out-of-this-world pizza and burrata. The Primavera pizza and Margaritha are popular choices, alongside the unique and delicious Lemon Pizza. The restaurant offers a simple yet elegant menu with perfect portion sizes. While service can be slow, friendly and enthusiastic servers like Coco provide a great experience, making it a must-return destination.“

“Vic's offers a great atmosphere and excellent food. The service is wonderful, with standout staff like Tony and Alex. The cacio e pepe is a must-try, even better than in Italy. The escarole salad is exceptional. While the panna cotta dessert may not hit the mark for some, Vic's remains a top favorite spot to revisit.“

“Di Fara Pizza is a highly recommended spot for delicious European-style pizza in Manhattan. Friendly workers provide good service, making it a great place to grab a slice or take a pie to go. With the best ingredients, recipe, and bake, it's hard to beat. Even on a low-traffic day, the pizza remains better than most in the city.“

“Noi Due Cafe is a highly regarded kosher dairy restaurant known for its authentic and delicious food. The portions are generous, although the prices can be a bit high. The menu offers a variety of options, including mozzarella sticks, chop chop salad, and funghi gnocchi pasta. While the service may occasionally miss small details, the overall dining experience is positive and worth a visit.“

“Little Charli is a must-visit restaurant that serves superb Italian-inspired dishes. Their meatballs are reminiscent of homemade Italian cuisine, and their watermelon salad is refreshing and flavorful. The Diablo pizza is a highlight, with a thin crust, great ingredients, and a spicy kick from the honey. The restaurant offers an authentic Italian wine and beer selection, including Menabrea birra and Franciacorta. The atmosphere is cozy, with Italian tunes playing in the background. The service is great, and the dessert options, such as the Nutella s'more and cannolis, are not to be missed.“

“NY Pizza Suprema offers a variety of delicious NY-style sliced pizza ranging from $6-7.50 per slice. With 12-15 different varieties available, including Burrata, Meat Lover, BBQ chicken, and grandma, customers can enjoy a flavorful experience. The cheese pizza is especially recommended, with one customer claiming it to be the best they've ever had. Despite the cash-only policy for purchases under $10, the quality of the pizza surpasses other famous locations in NYC. The hot honey slice was particularly memorable, leaving a lasting impression on the customers.“

“Malaparte is a popular Italian restaurant that consistently serves excellent food. The menu features a range of dishes, including mussels, salads, rigatoni pesto, spaghetti with mushrooms, lasagna, and whole branzino. The portions are generous, and the flavors are intense and fresh. The staff is attentive and generous with their time, even when the restaurant is packed. The atmosphere is cozy, making it a great spot for dates or casual gatherings with friends. While it can get hot on warm evenings, the restaurant's popularity and reasonable prices make it a great value. Reservations are recommended, but it's worth the wait.“

“Appas Pizza is a Korean-inspired restaurant in NYC that offers unique pizza creations and savory dishes. The casual sit-down spot provides a modern and friendly atmosphere with touchscreen ordering available. Customers have praised the delicious flavors, friendly service, and clean environment. Popular dishes include the Kimchi Bacon Risotto and various pizza options like bulgogi and shrimp/sausage combinations. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Appas Pizza offers a satisfying experience with quality food and generous portions. With a diverse menu and a welcoming ambiance, this hidden gem in the East Village is worth a visit for a taste of Korean-infused comfort food.“

“Uva Next Door offers a delightful dining experience with a diverse menu, including delicious appetizers like Caesar salad and calamari, as well as tasty pasta dishes and tempting desserts. The restaurant is known for its exceptional service and accommodates vegetarian and gluten-free diners. Customers praise the restaurant's outstanding event hosting capabilities and recommend the DF espresso martinis.“

“Joe's Pizza is a bustling New York-style pizzeria that serves delicious pies with a crispy crust and generous toppings. While there may be a wait, especially during peak hours, the lines move quickly and the atmosphere is lively. The menu features a range of options, including vegetarian choices like fresh mozzarella, caprese, and veggie pizza. The pasta sauce can be a bit overpowering in some areas, but the pizza is overall great. With a variety of slices to choose from, including the popular White pizza with spinach and Supreme, Joe's Pizza is a must-try for pizza lovers visiting the city.“

“Song' E Napule in NYC is a favorite spot with amazing food and atmosphere. Customers love the polite staff and attentive manager. It feels like being back in Italy with lively vibes and incredible food. The Neapolitan pizza and pasta are authentic and delicious, especially the grilled squid. The restaurant is small, so reservations are recommended. This place is a must-visit for a taste of Italy outside of Italy.“

“Capizzi offers amazing food and a friendly atmosphere. The Burrata salad, arugula & prosciutto pizza, and Tiramisu were highlights. The pizzas and rocota crepes with sauce are highly recommended. The 'loaded' pizza was mouthwatering, and the staff are welcoming and knowledgeable. Specializing in pizzas, Capizzi also offers other great options. A definite must-visit for delicious meals in a cozy setting.“

“Unregular Pizza offers delicious, crispy pizzas with a must-try Burrata add-on. The Cacio e Pepe fried pasta is also highly recommended. The staff, Chris and Catherine, provide amazing service, making the experience even better. The restaurant has a mix of traditional and nontraditional flavors, perfect for a taste of NYC. Friendly and quick service adds to the total NY vibes.“

“L'Amico offers an enjoyable dining experience with friendly and attentive service. The calamari and scallops are standouts, being fresh and expertly prepared. The skirt steak is also commendable, noted for its tenderness and flavor. The mashed potatoes and tiramisu are worthy accompaniments. However, seating may feel a bit cramped, and some may find the Neapolitan pizza overcooked, with a burnt crust and a less-than-fresh tomato sauce taste. Nonetheless, the seafood and steak dishes earn positive remarks.“

“Emily's West Village is a charming restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The pizza is a highlight, with its perfect crust and fresh toppings. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it suitable for any occasion. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a wonderful dining experience. The menu features creative and delicious options, such as the mozzarella and breadsticks, which are a departure from the usual bar fare. The burger is also a standout, with a unique sauce that adds an extra layer of flavor. Other options, like the Detroit pub pizza and meatballs, are also worth trying. Overall, Emily's West Village is a gem that is sure to please.“

“San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar offers a delightful dining experience with great margarita and neapolitan pizzas, as well as delicious burgers. The cozy Italian restaurant serves crispy Fritto Misto and fresh San Matteo Salad, along with mouthwatering Pappardelle Funghi and Lasagna. Known for authentic Italian cuisine, the new location is heaven for pizza lovers, especially the prosciutto e buffala pizza.“

“Joe's Pizza offers delicious pizzas by the slice, priced around $5 each as of June 2024. The restaurant only accepts cash payments and has limited seating, both indoors and outside. While the service is described as friendly, the lack of card payments and limited seating might be challenging for some visitors. The pizza's standout feature is its base and crust, providing a unique chewy, crunchy, and crispy texture. Both the pepperoni and cheese pizzas have been praised.“

“B Side Pizza Bar serves very good pizzas, with options like the Killer Bee, Shrimp Scampi, Marge, and Spicoli 2.0. The pizzas are freshly made and generously topped with ingredients. The restaurant also offers other dishes like macaroni meatballs. The service is top-notch and friendly. Despite not taking reservations, walk-ins are accommodated, even on busy Saturday nights. Overall, B Side Pizza Bar is a great spot with delicious food and no complaints.“

“Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza is a restaurant offering delicious pizzas with unique flavors. The Shroomtown and Salcissa Dolce pizzas are standouts. A side of broccoli with lemon is also available. The service is generally friendly and attentive, with staff providing good recommendations. However, there have been some reports of rushed service and lack of follow-up. The restaurant does not offer a children's menu. The Mac and cheese could use more salt, but it is still enjoyable. The atmosphere is welcoming and pleasant. Overall, Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza is a recommended dining destination for those seeking delicious and original pizzas in a comfortable setting.“

“Celeste is a restaurant known for its delightful dining experience and fresh, savory food. Anastasia, the gracious host and waitress, is commended for her exceptional service and skill in recommending dishes such as the spectacular halibut and incredible scallops. The menu offers a variety of options, from pasta dishes to vegan pizza, all made with fresh ingredients and served with love. The restaurant's cozy, rustic ambiance adds to its charm, making it a perfect spot for a memorable meal.“