50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brooklyn

“EXCELENTE SERVICIO MUY ATENTOS, SALUDOS DE KEYLA B FOSTER“

“This is the best pizza I have ever had, nice crisp, light crust with just the right amount of toppings, no grease at all. I live in CT and thought no pizza was better than our New Haven ones, boy was I wrong!!! Looking forward to returning……soon!“

“Love this place: amazing food, nice atmosphere and friendly service!“

“Best Italian food & pizza in Brooklyn“

“We dropped by Ace's Pizza around 3pm., Brooklyn, 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 5th Ave NYC and it was such a great experience! The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating—amazing service all around. We ordered the Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a 14-inch Pepperoni Pizza. Every single item was delicious! The quality of the food was outstanding. The pepperoni pizza especially stood out—crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. We really enjoyed everything we ordered, and the overall vibe of the place made the experience even better. Highly recommended if you’re in the area and craving great pizza!“

“Had a pasta and pizza and they were both amazing. We are from Australia and found it hard to find a good restaurant in the Marina bay sands area and this did not disappoint. 5 stars“

“seriously, one of the best, if not the best. I have tried in other states, and still exploring. This is definitely close to making the cut.“

“One word DIABLO !!!🙏❤️ Frost Beer was ice cold !!!“

“the place is phenomenal the pizza is outstanding you get treated with love like family once you walk through those doors the cocktails are creative and delicious Caesar salad oh my God but the pizza unbelievable I recommend this place to the world🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“My husband and I were visiting our daughter in Carroll Gardens, and she took us to one of her favorite neighborhood spots, F&F Restaurant and Bar. The place was packed with locals enjoying great food and drinks, so we knew we were in for a treat!
We ordered the pepperoni “pie,” rigatoni with vodka sauce — seriously, one of the best vodka sauces I’ve ever had — burrata with tomatoes, and tuna crudo. Everything was absolutely delicious. What a fantastic dinner!
We loved it so much we wanted to go back the very next day, but we already had reservations somewhere else. We’ll definitely be back on our next visit to Carroll Gardens!“

“100% the best pizza this whole planet has to offer, hands down. The service and atmosphere is always the best.“

“Had an awesome experience for my first Brooklyn, NYC slice and it was everything I expected to be and more. My family and I tried many different slices and the prices are super affordable and reasonable. The 2 employees working and making the pies were extremely nice and helpful all while pumping out the fresh pies when the store opened for the day.“

“Fun indoor/outdoor dining environment and delicious food make for a nice night out!“

“Been a Chrissy’s guy since the fun pop-up days, picking up late night pies at Chris’s house in BK, the times I lucked out in the unique “lottery” system to get a reservation for pick up lol. I miss those days, but so glad he got an actual store to showcase his pizza. All the pies are excellent with fresh ingredients, the best tomato sauce around and perfect crust. I love many, but my favorite is the new-havenish. That ignorant review that slammed the pie annoyed me, when it was prepared exactly as the reviewer admitted it was described!!! This pie is brilliance for those of us that love a tomato pie, but the stakes are raised with the briny delicious pecorino and Calabrian chili flake. Mozz does not go on this pie nor does it belong on it! Chrissy’s pies are out the door at about $40, but I don’t know the last even casual quality meal out in NYC that cost less than $50 - $60 per person at the minimum. Let me split a Chrissy’s pie with a friend for $20 each…have a beyond satisfying meal, and go to sleep happy. Keep doing what you’re doing brother!“

“I love this Slice Shop! So tasty! I love the regular, the sausage, the pepperoni, the Mootz, Jake's, Freddy Prinze, Hellboy.“

“Aromi in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn is the kind of place that instantly makes you grateful.

The owners Alessandro, Andrea, and Sarah are incredible. Their warmth and pride show in everything, and you feel it in how the whole restaurant runs.

The service is exceptional, genuinely attentive without ever being overbearing.

The food is exceptional, flavorful , thoughtfully made, and just plain satisfying.

Most of all, the kindness of the entire staff is exceptional. Everyone feels welcoming and genuine.

And the vibe is perfect , it’s ideal for a family dinner, but it’s also absolutely perfect for the best romantic night you’ve ever had. I’m truly grateful I get to go to a place like Aromi!!!“

“Just started coming here and it became my new go to pizza place. I love the service and energy me and my bf get when we come in. Everyone is welcome. And the pizza is soooo good and always so well done when I ask , the crunch is soooo right. Gotta give it a visit if you’re nearby. Shoutout to Melly and Lily 🥰🧡“

“Delicious wood fired pizza with amazing toppings including vegan options. Wonderful, cozy environment and eclectic playlist. You won’t be disappointed!!“

“Was such a good slice. Came in after an evening of dancing. And Orel and his staff were so nice and sweet. The place was incredible and really hit the spot. Perfect ratio of cheese to dough to sauce. Will be coming back and visiting the Greenpoint location as well! Thanks !!“

“Went there with family. Service was fast and they let us sit corner table which I asked for the kids. I liked the employees being nice and friendly. They keep the table clean, refilled our drinks. Food was amazing as always. Keep up with good work guys…“

“really excellent pizza and dessert“

“Their Caesar slice is one of the best unconventional slices I've ever had. First of all, they don't reheat it, so if you're expecting a hot slice for this one you will have to wait for a fresh pie.

The slice stays completely upright, and this is key for the enjoyment of it. If the slice got soggy or floppy it would be a terrible experience. It doesn't taste like regular mozzarella on the pizza. Maybe they use a cheddar blend or something, but the choice of cheese compliments the tangy salad perfectly. They're also generous with the Parm.

Be wary when eating the Caesar slice, Parmesan cheese will fall off and possibly get on your clothes.

The other slice was the spicy vodka. Upon the first few bites this one didn't wow me like the Caesar, but towards the end I was appreciative of it. Just a solid slice, but I would likely try something different next time.

The interior is fantastic, it's unfussy but well thought out. Clearly a throwback with the patterned floor, red cups, and old school trash can. Booth and table seating. I really appreciated the self service water station which implies they care about people coming and dining in. The other amazing detail was a hand washing sink next to the trash can. No need to use the restroom after enjoying a greasy slice, and you can return to your day clean as a whistle.

The other slices looked just as inventive as the Caesar. Classic gimmick slices with a chef's touch.

Don't tell other people about this place. It would be ruined with a line out the door.“

“Been there couple of times and burger is mind-blowing. Pizza also ok.“

“Local pizza shop that smelled amazing and everyone in the area is a fan of. Their tomato bruschetta pizza is amazing. Would get again. Their white honey & cheese is good but only because of the white sauce. Wasn’t a huge fan of the crust but it’s good when the pizza is fresh from the oven. Crust is paper thin. Typical nyc pizza style.“

“eally enjoyed the pizza and it was just as good the next morning with the slices we took home!“

“Tony and the staff are always incredibly welcoming. Espresso has become my favorite pizzeria in the neighborhood for the no nonsense consistent quality that other spots in the neighborhood lack. One of the last old school slice shops you’ll find in the neighborhood.“

“My friend and I saw this place going viral on TikTok so we decided to check it out! I highly recommend looking through the menu carefully and reading their reservation policies before visiting. We booked our reservation a month in advance so please be aware of their cancellation policy and any associated fees.

When we first walked in, the atmosphere was warm and cozy, with beautiful interior design and a relaxing vibe. The staff were friendly, attentive, and professional. The customer service was excellent from beginning to end. We ordered Chicken Karaage Tartar with Sauce & Ginger Koji, Spaghetti with Oyster & Seaweed Cream Sauce, and Four Cheese with Natural Honey.

Overall, we had a wonderful experience at Pizza 4P’s! I would definitely recommend checking it out especially if you’re looking for a unique dining experience in New York. We will be back soon in the future when we visit New York and will definitely try out something new.“

“Pizza was perfectly cooked“

“fantastic place for a private event, super reasonably priced and very accommodating. i booked a birthday party saturday night without too much anticipation and they were able to accommodate. the pizzas are great and easy to share with a large group, highly recommend. just a heads up they do charge extra for plates if you bring outside food (like birthday cake). overall great experience.“

“Classic authentic Brooklyn slice! Very Few spots left serving up an OG tasting cheese slice worth the money and they aren't over charging either! they got it right! Staff is also super friendly and welcoming! If in sunset it’s a must.“

“Had dinner at Rosticceria Brooklyn last night and it did not disappoint. The chicken was perfectly roasted, juicy inside with crispy, well-seasoned skin. We got the focaccia on the side, which was soft and pillowy with a great olive oil flavor.

Everything felt fresh and made with care. This is exactly the kind of neighborhood spot you want in Brooklyn. Will definitely be back!“

“Mancini Wood Fired Pizza is a true gem in Bay Ridge! Their wood-fired pizza is unmatched. Owner Frank is incredible, always welcoming you with a smile and making sure everything is just right. Whether you're stopping in for a slice or planning a big event, this spot delivers every time. If you're searching for the best pizza in Bay Ridge, Mancini's is the place to be!“

“Quaint atmosphere. Great food and service. Shout out to Jose for his attentive service. I was in the area for an errand and decided to see what was nearby with a Restaurant Week menu. I left full and happy. I highly recommend the lavender martini. The dishes for the other diners looked appetizing.“

“Only take out to go. Pick up . Small space. The food is good , I got the garlic parmesan wings. Wings were small but good. Would have liked bigger portions for the price they charged.

Parking: No parking lot , only street.

Wheelchair accessibility: Big entrance so you can go in , in a wheelchair.“

“Great pizza and atmosphere!“

“Some personal notes:
- Buratta Pomodoro: buratta is 86 so get mozzarella. Didn’t expect it had fresh tomato so make it like salad vibe. 3/5
- next time try Randazo(eggplant), bianca(white sauce with onion), pesto burrata, toretta, tiramisu or cannoli“

“Food was great! And bonus, the husband/wife team at Concrete were so welcoming and made you feel like they had you over for dinner.“

“The BEST Sicilian square sourdough pizza on the planet 🌎 their sauce is organic and phenomenal, the cheese is wonderful, olives and if you feel like it Add some sausage, and the yummiest pecorino Romano shreds just topped it off. The crispiest crust and So incredibly digestible, because it’s sourdough. Sourdough is fermented and your gut loves fermented food… Love their little gem lettuce salad with their homemade dressing. Very simple here I think we ordered 3 square pies and of course brought some home The Sicilian squares heats up beautifully Just love OPS on Himrod Bushwick Brooklyn!!!! We brought our son who lives in Louisville and this time brought our daughter and boyfriend who live in San Diego and their rock star Pal who is on a tour with THE WHO. All give the square pizza A+ Excellent! The staff is warm and friendly!!!“

“I was in town for a concert and was craving some good pizza. One of my favorite things on a pie are caramelized onions. This place was an 8 minute walk from the lot that I parked my car. So I ordered online about 15 minutes before I arrived at the parking lot. That part was very smooth and I left a tip too. When I got there, the area by the register was very small. So there are at least 4 people hanging around so you don’t know if they’re waiting for the initial encounter or what the story is. So a couple of people paid and then a guy opens the door and literally steps right in front of me despite there being very little space. So the guy behind the counter says next and I asked the woman in front of me if she was waiting and she said yes. There was NO way I was letting that guy who stepped in front of me go first. I don’t understand people even if it’s NYC. Wait your turn. So then I told the guy it was an online order under my name. He was courteous and quick and very thorough. He gave me all the requested cutlery and plates and napkins I had included in my online order. My plan was to eat it there if there was a seat but every spot was taken. I had to walk back to my car in the rain and eat it there. Thank goodness I had used self-park; otherwise I’d be eating my pizza in the rain. The thinish crust, cheese and onions really hit the spot. I wasn’t a fan of the sauce though. It wasn’t sweet at all. I’m not sure how to describe it-maybe too tart? I like a mix of both sweet and tart but that’s just my preference I’m sure there are plenty of people who like their sauce this way. So overall very good. The line situation could be better-it’s just too small there so maybe a rope would help to organize that so you know when people are waiting off to the side and aren’t in the line. Excellent service otherwise. I’d definitely go back to try some other stuff next time. This is a solid 4.5 for me.“

“EXCELENTE SERVICIO MUY ATENTOS, SALUDOS DE KEYLA B FOSTER“

“I had a great time at Circa the staff was very attentive food was excellent. Thank you for great service.“

“Great Spritzers 🍸 Sat in the sun ☀️ 😎“

“When Cento Uno Pizzeria opened up in my neighborhood, I was beyond ecstatic. The food is amazing and fresh (the white slice is my favorite), and the owner is extremely friendly and conversational. There’s a nice atmosphere and upbeat music always playing. I’ve been going there every week for over a year now, and will continue forever. 100/10 recommend!!!“

“Great pizza. Didn’t like the white pizza but that is just my personal taste. The cheese slice and pepperoni slice were excellent. Loved the sausage. Spicy just like I like it.“

“The pizza is aaaaammmaaaazzziiinnnggg!“

“Hands down , the greatest pizza spot in all of NYC and Long Island. Every single slice is better then the next. Staff is always great , place is extremely clean , and the food is absolutely astonishing ! If you don’t know , ya better find out about Fini 🤙🏼“

“Good pizza and a good atmosphere in a good spot“

“I've been fortunate to experience this restaurant a multitude of times from 2018 to now I've had so many memorable meals at Wheated (and even pickup experiences during lockdown were highlights at the time).

I've never seen a dip in the level of quality, service or attention to customer satisfaction. This is despite the huge influx in business they've received over the past couple years, that was well deserved and long overdue.

Drinks are a strong suit and i always find a whiskey that I've never tried as they have an eclectic and constantly rotating selection. Pizzas are always so consistent and just the right amount of chewiness and flavor for my personal taste. The specials go quickly most nights so consider trying something different if they are available.

If I ever move away from the area, Wheated will be one of the things I miss the most. Never had a less than friendly experience with the staff and the coziness of the location is unmatched.“

“I was in town for a day and didn’t realize there was a manhattan location but wanted to try them so bad I travelled 40 mins to Brooklyn and it was SO WORTH IT! They even gave me an extra slice 🥹 I did the sweet Thai chili oxtail and the brown stew oxtail pizza and it was so good even the crust was delicious on its own! I see why this place went viral now! I wish we had one in Cleveland but then again maybe not cause I’d gain 40lbs eating this weekly 😍 music was bumping and great selection, the staff was so chill and kind and didn’t make me feel like a tourist 🤣 loved the vibes here. Highly recommend if you’re in the nyc area to try this at least once before you go!“

“Just came back from Mother's Day Brunch with my sons and husband. Food was excellent as was the service! Beet salad was so good, burgers cooked to perfection, shakshuka with merguez sausage was delicious, the white truffles pizza with poached eggs was amazing!! Thank you Wild for a 100% gluten free restaurant with 100% great food!“