50 Best American Restaurants in Brooklyn

“Olmsted is a restaurant with a pleasant atmosphere and unique decor, known for its plants-adorned walls. The menu offers a variety of dishes, including a monkfish entree and a burger that comes with fries cooked in duck tallow, which are a healthier and tastier alternative to seed oils. However, it's worth noting that substitutions are not allowed, and the burger is on the salty side. The restaurant also offers a green goddess salad and a duck banh mi, served on a soft brioche-like bun. Other standout dishes include the grilled asparagus with waffle, rutabaga, and pumpkin kouign-amann. Olmsted has two garden spaces for dining and offers a kids menu. While the service is generally friendly and helpful, there were some issues with communication and wine service during a big party visit.“

“Lingo offers a unique dining experience with tasty cocktails like a Japanese margarita and a whiskey-based pink drink. Their Caesar salad and deep-fried burrata were huge and delicious, with the fried hen and black cod also being tasty choices. The sticky pudding with lime ice cream for dessert was massive but worth it. The Spicy Fried Chicken lacked spice but was still good with extra hot sauce. The warm atmosphere and excellent service make Lingo a must-visit spot for a well-thought-out meal.“

“Win Son offers a delightful blend of Taiwanese and American flavors, with innovative dishes like marinated cucumbers, fried eggplant, and sesame noodles. The atmosphere is great, with fast and friendly service. The cocktail selection includes unique Taiwanese options, and don't miss out on their famous ice cream sandwich. It's a favorite spot for many due to the delicious food and overall enjoyable experience.“

“Nura is a restaurant known for its delicious and impressive dishes. The menu offers a variety of options, with standout choices being the bread and sauces, broccoli rabe, chicken, scallops, and grilled prawns. The restaurant has a stylish open design with floral and wooden decorations, creating a pleasant atmosphere. Nura is accommodating to dietary restrictions and offers wheelchair accessibility, including an accessible entrance and seating. Although some may find the food a bit oily, the flavors are generally praised as excellent.“

“MADRE is a restaurant that offers exceptional cuisine, worthy of a Michelin star. The menu features delicious dishes such as ceviche, flavorful skate fish, and a perfectly seasoned chicken with a smoky and tangy taste. The brunch menu is also praised for its diverse and delicious options, including black truffle croquettes, a signature octopus dish, and decadent French toast. The restaurant's atmosphere is warm and inviting, with friendly staff and a beautiful, airy space adorned with greenery. MADRE is highly recommended for those seeking a top-notch dining experience.“

“The Four Horsemen in Brooklyn offers a memorable dining experience with excellent service and a vast wine list. The menu features eclectic dishes, and the knowledgeable staff can help pair meals with the perfect wine. While the small plates are pricey, they offer unique flavors and ingredients, making it a great spot to try something new.“

“Pecking House serves a variety of dishes, with a focus on fried chicken. The restaurant offers options such as orange pepper wet wings, a picante chicken sandwich, and chili chicken. The chili chicken and fried chicken sandwich have been particularly praised, with customers raving about their unique flavors and crispy texture. The cornbread and potato salad have also been noted as standout sides. However, some reviewers have mentioned that the sauces and extra spicy options come with a warning, as they can be quite strong. While there have been some mentions of high prices and overseasoning, overall, the restaurant has been described as a delicious and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Vinegar Hill House is a European-style restaurant in Brooklyn, offering delicious dishes like quiche and pancakes. The location is great for a casual dining experience. The staff is accommodating and friendly, making it a favorite spot for many customers who have been coming for over a decade.“

“Traif, a restaurant located in Brooklyn, offers a unique fusion menu with delectable dishes. The establishment is known for its outstanding food, with favorites such as gnocchi, salt and pepper shrimp, foie gras, and Japanese red snapper with bao buns. The restaurant also features a wonderful chef's choice tasting menu, which provides diners with the opportunity to sample a variety of the menu's incredible offerings for a reasonable price of $56. The ambiance is described as great, particularly when dining in the back patio. Overall, Traif is highly recommended for its exceptional cuisine and dining experience.“

“Sunday In Brooklyn is an amazing place with great food and service. They make special occasions memorable by giving birthday treats. The breakfast options like avocado toast and poached egg are highly recommended, along with the delicious bloody Mary’s. The staff is attentive and personable, making sure your experience is top-notch. From Mole omelet to cinnamon rolls, everything on the menu is fantastic. If you're in the city, a visit to this restaurant is a must for a delightful dining experience.“

“Gertrude's is a beloved Brooklyn restaurant offering exceptional food, service, and ambiance. Friendly and welcoming staff provide a memorable experience. Enjoy a variety of dishes, such as the leeks, pickle plate, and fries, making it a perfect spot for a night out or repeated visits.“

“Red Hook Tavern offers a great vibe with friendly staff. Annette, an original Brooklynite, provides excellent service. The location on a nice Red Hook street adds to the experience. The burger, though juicy with a perfect meat to cheese ratio, had a slightly oversized bun. Despite this, the welcoming atmosphere and delicious food make for a pleasant dining experience.“

“Leland Eating and Drinking House is a restaurant known for its exceptional service and delicious food. The brunch options, such as the pork hash and unique baked goods, are particularly popular. The staff are friendly and accommodating, even when customers are late for their reservations. The wine selection is impressive, and the waitstaff are happy to provide samples to help customers make a choice. The restaurant offers a variety of cocktails, including a seasonal fireside negroni that can be served hot or cold. The menu features locally sourced ingredients, and the chicken dish, marinated in salsa verde, is a standout. The patio seating is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot to enjoy drinks and food.“

“Marlow & Sons is a cozy restaurant with a fantastic atmosphere, featuring nice music and dimmed lights. The menu offers great vegetarian options and delicious food, including tasty bakery selections. The decor is super hip, and the staff is generally friendly and attentive. While service can be slow at times, the restaurant is capable of seating large parties and is a great spot for casual dining. Overall, Marlow & Sons is one of the best cafe/dining spots in the area, offering a fun vibe and great dinner menu.“

“Gage & Tollner is a historic restaurant in Brooklyn with a timeless ambiance and delectable cuisine. The classic veal for two, fried chicken, and bass with risotto are must-try dishes. The salad wedges, mushrooms, and divine bread make for a fantastic meal. The wine selection is excellent, and the Alaskan cake is unforgettable. The service may be hit or miss, but the overall experience is perfect for a special celebration or a memorable fine dining experience.“

“Runner Up offers an exceptional dining experience with wonderful, well-sourced, and seasonally appropriate food served in a beautifully lit and intimate environment. The chef's simple yet flavorful dishes excite both the visual mind and palate. The wine list complements the food perfectly. The service is attentive and thoughtful, enhancing the overall experience. Located in Park Slope, it's a local favorite with excellent music choices and a rotating menu, making it worth every effort to get a reservation. Definitely recommended.“

“Francie serves exceptional dishes, including the standout duck with crispy skin, paired with tasty sides. The Soufflé cake is a must-try, perfectly paired with seaweed butter and caviar. The beautifully presented dishes are matched by the attentive staff, providing a lovely dining experience with a great view of the kitchen.“

“Hometown Bar-B-Que serves incredible BBQ food with a variety of options to choose from, including brisket, Korean sticky ribs, jerk tips, slaw, and honey cornbread. The smoked BBQ is excellent, with must-try Korean spare ribs, as well as delicious "regular" spare ribs and hot wings. This fun BBQ joint in Red Hook, Brooklyn offers a range of draft beers, sodas, and wines in a self-service setting. Prices are moderately higher, but the tender and juicy meats make it well worth the visit.“

“The Turk's Inn in Bushwick captures a taste of Wisconsin with relocated decor and plates. The food impresses with perfectly prepared steak frites, flavorful eggplant, and whole sea bass. The Pickles tray and Cheese cloud start the meal off right. The Brandy Old Fashioned is a standout drink. While some dishes had humble portions and high prices, the friendly staff and fantastic vibe make it worth a visit. The lamb baklava is an interesting twist. Overall, a place where everything tried is delicious, leaving one excited to return for more.“

“21 Greenpoint is a cozy and warm Brooklyn restaurant with friendly staff and mouthwatering food. It offers a great spot for a date night, Sunday brunch, and delicious classic American fare, including standout dishes like burrata and rigatoni. The service is superb, though some items may be a bit pricey for the quality.“

“Bohemien Bar is a chic and trendy mid-century modern bar in Brooklyn that offers a delightful dining and drinking experience. The menu, though not extensive, features delicious dishes such as fries, tuna crisps, and roasted Brie, all of which are praised for their exceptional quality. The bar also boasts a creative cocktail menu with unique and visually appealing drinks, including the One Love in a woman-shaped cup and the Birdy Num Num in a bird-shaped glass. The atmosphere is enhanced by dim lighting and a live DJ playing music, though the volume can sometimes be a bit loud for conversation. The service is friendly and welcoming, and the prices are reasonable, especially considering the high-quality offerings. Overall, Bohemien Bar is a must-visit destination for those seeking a fun and memorable experience.“

“Winona's, a restaurant in Brooklyn, offers an impressive dining experience with its creative and delicious food, complemented by an excellent wine selection. The service is attentive and relaxed, creating a gem-like atmosphere. However, diners with food allergies should exercise caution, as there have been concerns raised about the handling of allergy information. Overall, Winona's is a great choice for a date night or a shared small plates experience, with standout dishes like the Lobster, fried mushrooms, and raw tuna.“

“Five Leaves is a cute little restaurant in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, known for its iconic brunch. The fluffy and huge pancakes are a must-try, perfect for sharing. With a divine menu, excellent coffee, and great vegetarian options, it's a top choice for breakfast in the area. Enjoy the sunny terrace or covered terrace while indulging in delicious food. Open on Mondays, it's a hidden gem for a satisfying brunch experience.“

“Clover Hill is a high-quality restaurant offering an exceptional dining experience. While the price of the tasting menu may be on the higher side, the attention to ingredients, menu, skills, and service justify the cost. The intimate ambiance and beautiful presentation make it an ideal spot to celebrate occasions. The music and open kitchen add to the unique experience. The food is impeccable, with each course telling a story and bursting with flavor. While the value may be a matter of personal opinion, the food is certainly great.“

“Blanca is a restaurant with an awesome vibe - loved the layout, music, and smokiness of the space. The staff provides great service, sweet and enthusiastic. The food, unfortunately, was mid, with only a few standout dishes out of 16 courses. The uni dish, Spanish mackerel, snail pasta dish, bread with chicharon, and the palate cleanser with apple cider granita were highlights. However, other dishes were not memorable, and some guests experienced stomachaches afterward. After a concept change, the cuisine lacked the magic it once had, with uninspiring flavors and a lack of cohesion. While some dishes like citrus and fermented brussels sprouts and crab empanada were delicious, others like the seafood and pasta courses fell short. Overall, the experience was rated a 5 or 6 out of 10, with better options available elsewhere.“

“Dinner Party offers a unique dining experience with a communal seating area, creating a natural and welcoming atmosphere. The menu features creative and delicious dishes, with vegetarian and vegan options available. The attentive service and cozy ambiance make for a memorable evening, with a Michelin-level culinary experience at an affordable fixed price.“

“Hart's is a restaurant offering high-level food in a cozy and warm atmosphere. The space is small and intimate, with dim lights creating a romantic and private ambiance. The staff are friendly, welcoming, knowledgeable, and attentive, contributing to a great dining experience. The menu includes a variety of dishes, such as a savory donut appetizer, clam toast, trout, lamb burger, and pork. Among them, the trout and lamb burger stand out for their taste and presentation. While the lemon curd dessert may not be preferred by all, the drink and wine selections are commendable. The restaurant may make accommodations for wheelchair accessibility, although the space is small and tables are close together.“

“Colonie is a standout restaurant in Brooklyn Heights, known for its exceptional food, atmosphere, and service. The open kitchen-centered space is very cool, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The menu features a range of delicious options, including the popular Blue Crab Pasta and the impressive Sticky Date Cake dessert. The pasta is made with fresh and flavorful ingredients, and the veggie side dishes are superb. The brunch menu is also unique and delicious, with options that are not too precious. The chef's table in the back offers a unique dining experience, while the booths up front get great sunshine at brunch time. Overall, Colonie is a superb choice for a dining experience.“

“Santa Fe BK offers a charming atmosphere with lovely decor and excellent service. The restaurant serves authentic New Mexican cuisine, featuring real green chile from New Mexico. The breakfast burritos are a highlight, with fluffy, seasoned eggs and flavorful food. The back deck provides a great spot to enjoy a meal. The staff is kind and attentive, and the restaurant is a wonderful gem in the neighborhood.“

“Banter Bar is a lively sports bar, ideal for watching games with a high-energy crowd. It offers a selection of beers, spirits, and food. The menu includes a sausage platter and sausages, which are highly recommended. The team behind the bar is known to be friendly and attentive, providing a proper Guinness pour. It's a great place to enjoy premier league games or have a good time regardless of the event.“

“Faun is a restaurant that offers excellent food and service, making it an ideal location for special occasions. The restaurant has a wide selection of cocktails, wine, and great vegetarian options. One of their standout dishes is the scallop raviolo, and their eggplant and pesto gnocchi are also must-tries. Their wine pairings, such as the Australian Grenache, are highly recommended. Faun has a cozy and chic ambiance, with a beautiful patio that provides a fairy tale-like experience. The restaurant can get quite busy, so reservations are recommended. Overall, Faun is an excellent choice for a date night or a special occasion.“

“Sereneco is a stylish restaurant located in a renovated building with old brick walls and new materials. The menu offers a variety of delicious dishes, including whipped Mascarpone with focaccia, short rib panini with arugula salad and tumeric vinaigrette, French stew, and cheeseburger. The restaurant is accommodating to dietary restrictions, including vegan and vegetarian options.“

“Otway is a beloved restaurant, frequented by locals regularly. Known for its excellent food, team, and atmosphere, it is a popular spot in the neighborhood. The coffee is a highlight, and the baked goods are fresh, delicious, and unique. The chicken schnitzel and sauteed apples have received positive reviews. However, there is a lack of vegetarian entree options on the menu, with only a pasta dish available, which was found to be underwhelming and salty. Despite this, the cocktails are reported to be very good. Overall, Otway is highly regarded and praised for its quality offerings.“

“LoHi Rooftop is a hidden gem with a spacious outdoor area perfect for big groups. The rooftop offers a covered section with heaters, making it ideal even in unpredictable weather. The staff is friendly, and the cocktails are tasty, with the Montego Slay and Sunnyboy drinks being popular choices. The menu, though limited, includes delicious options like the double smash burger and chimichurri steak. This spot also serves as an event space and hosts parties that are always a good time. With plenty of space, good drinks, and great music from DJs, LoHi Rooftop in Brooklyn is a must-visit for a fun night out.“

“Chino Grande is a restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The atmosphere is praised, and the food is the highlight, with everything being shareable and various menu items available, including vegetarian and vegan options. The staff is attentive and accommodating, ensuring a great experience for customers, whether it's a special occasion or a regular visit. The menu features a variety of delicious dishes, including salad, rice and beans, and tofu, all of which are highly recommended.“

“Bernie’s is a popular spot with the best Eggplant Parm in the city. The atmosphere is top-notch, with a buzzing neighborhood vibe. While they don’t take reservations, the waiting list system works well. The Caesar salad and Chicken Parm are highly recommended. The burgers and fries are classic and delicious. The service is friendly and accommodating, with hosts like Oliver ensuring a pleasant experience. It’s worth the wait for a table at Bernie’s for a great meal and a fun night out.“

“Swoony's is a must-visit restaurant with amazing food and even better service. The burger is truly outstanding, from the crust on the patties to the bun. The martinis with blue cheese stuffed olives and creamed spinach are highly recommended. The asparagus with tangy Caesar dressing is a winner, and the French toast dessert is a nostalgic delight. While the fries could use more seasoning and the potato croquettes were a bit lacking, the overall experience at Swoony's is top-notch.“

“Ruthie's restaurant offers a noteworthy dining experience with its revamped menu. The drinks are skillfully prepared and delicious, while standout dishes include a gem and chicory salad, tender and spicy rice and crab, and a highly praised burger. The service is commendable, with attentive staff and an impressive wine selection. The atmosphere is pleasant, and the cost is reasonable considering the quality and portion of the food. Overall, Ruthie's provides a satisfying and memorable meal.“

“Mayfield is a neighborhood restaurant known for its delicious American food and standout brunch options. The steaks and eggs are a popular choice, as they are always well-seasoned and cooked to the desired temperature. During happy hour, customers can enjoy fresh oysters and beer for just $1.50. The servers are attentive, and the bartenders are friendly, making it a pleasant dining experience. The ambiance is lively and can be noisy during the weekends, but quieter and suitable for date nights during the weekdays. The Cuban dish is a must-try, with its buttery and tender meat that melts in your mouth.“

“Buttermilk Channel is a popular brunch spot known for its massive portions and friendly staff. The biscuits with jelly are a great starter, and the pancakes are delicious but generous. The menu also features a tasty Fried Chicken Sandwich that is crispy and juicy. Reservations are recommended, as walk-ins might have a wait. The staff, like Deborah, are accommodating and turn dining into a memorable experience for all ages. The bustling atmosphere can get a bit noisy when busy, but the overall dining experience is worth a visit for a variety of delicious dishes.“

“The Osprey restaurant offers a memorable dining experience with exceptional food, cocktails, and wine. The New York strip loin is cooked to perfection and pairs well with the Green salad with balsamic. The staff, including servers Mitch and Dan Churchill, are friendly and attentive, making celebrations like wedding anniversaries special. The cozy ambiance adds to the overall experience, making it a favorite dining destination for many. Whether for a romantic dinner or a large corporate team dinner, The Osprey can accommodate various group sizes with fantastic service and great timing between courses. Don't forget to check out the rooftop for an added touch to your dining experience.“

“The Narrows is a popular restaurant in East Williamsburg that offers a unique dining experience. On a Saturday night, the restaurant was full but not packed, allowing guests to easily get a table around the corner from the main bar. The menu features a patty melt, fries/salad, and cocktails, including the babushka cocktail. The burger was described as thick and juicy, with thick cheese and soft chewy toasted bread. The restaurant also has a great ambience, making it a good date night spot. With a focus on design, engaged staff, and fantastic music, The Narrows is a great place to enjoy a meal or simply hang out.“

“Meadowsweet is a charming restaurant in Brooklyn, known for its friendly and welcoming staff. The menu features a variety of dishes, including small plates, which are perfect for sharing. The food is fresh, well-seasoned, and expertly prepared, with highlights including the artichoke dish and burrata. The wine list is also impressive, with a selection of international wines. The atmosphere is lovely, with outdoor seating available. Overall, Meadowsweet offers a delightful dining experience, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.“

“Bee's Knees & Honey Lounge is a charming venue that exceeds expectations. The cozy, vintage-inspired lounge features floral and velvet decor, creating a perfect atmosphere for special occasions like Mothers Day or birthday parties. The staff provides great service, and the food and drinks, including the popular house mead, are fantastic. The upstairs event space, known as the Honey Lounge, can accommodate large groups and offers flexibility for last-minute bookings. With its classic music and organized team, Bee's Knees is an ideal spot for parties and nights out.“

“No. 7 Restaurant is a charming neighborhood spot, popular for its delicious food and friendly service. The restaurant has a cozy and relaxed atmosphere, with a welcoming staff that ensures a pleasant dining experience. The menu offers a variety of dishes, with each item having its own unique identity. The vegetarian options, such as the veggie burger and veggie cheeseburger, are particularly noteworthy. The blue cheese fries are a must-try, and diners can indulge in the flourless chocolate cake or snickerdoodle ice cream sandwich for dessert. The restaurant's cocktails are satisfactory, but the wine selection truly shines. The bar is a popular spot, and reservations are recommended for those looking to dine at a table. One of the unique features of No. 7 Restaurant is its location on a bustling Brooklyn street. Diners can sit by the window and observe the lively street scene, making for an enjoyable and memorable dining experience. Overall, No. 7 Restaurant is a great spot for both casual and special occasions, offering delicious food, friendly service, and a unique and enjoyable atmosphere.“

“Otis is a restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The modern and cozy ambiance creates a perfect setting for any occasion, from a relaxed date night to a dinner meeting. The service is top-notch, with attentive and caring servers who go above and beyond to make the night special. The menu features a variety of delicious dishes, including the highly-recommended mussels, burrata, and braised pork shoulder pasta. The housemade bread and spreads, tomato soup, golden beets, and lamb meatballs are also standout dishes. The restaurant's signature drink, "Revenge Of The Line," is a must-try. With great service, great food, and great drinks, Otis is a highly recommended spot for a memorable night out.“

“Runner & Stone offers a welcoming atmosphere with considerate staff who cater to special needs. Their food is "ridiculously good" and they accommodate vegetarian substitutions. The pastries, including the renowned chocolate croissant, are perfectly balanced and delicious. The attentive and patient staff ensure a great dining experience from start to finish.“

“Diner is a restaurant known for its amazing culinary experience and warm, friendly service. The menu features a variety of dishes, from beet salad and country pâté to scrambled eggs and eggs with beans, all cooked to perfection. The pork, cheeseburger, and half chicken are standout entrées. For sides, try the polenta with wild mushrooms. With a constantly updated farm-to-table menu, there's always something new to look forward to. Despite the tight seating, Diner has a great vibe, making it a wonderful spot for any meal.“

“Parlay is a cozy restaurant on 8th Ave, serving a range of meals including breakfast, lunch, and dinner options. Known for its friendly service and good portions at a reasonable price. The menu features dishes such as the cheeseburger and fries, fried chicken sandwich with honey wasabi aioli, and sweetened iced tea.“

“Saturdays at Walter's offer a cozy and contemporary dining experience. The scallops, deviled eggs, and calamari were great picks, though the clams casino fell short. The atmosphere is not huge but adequate, with good service despite a busy night. The fries are a standout, and the French dip is almost perfect, just a few chewy beef parts. The Gem salad and Scallop crudo are also highlights. Sunday brunch features delicious chicken and waffles, a must-try with fluffy waffles and tasty toppings. A spot worth revisiting for a solid 4-star experience.“