Baxter Street Pizza

83 Baxter St, New York
(212) 431-8574

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Grandma Pizza

Pizza
Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza
6 slice. Our delicious homemade vodka sauce finished with calabrian chili, fresh mozzarella and baked rigatoni.
Vodka Margherita Pizza
4.5 slice. Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella. Served round or sicilian style.
Classic White Pie Pizza
4.5 slice. Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.
Margherita Pizza
4.5 slice. Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, touch of tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.
Upsidedown Pizza
4.5 slice. Layers of homemade mozzarella topped with marinara sauce, pecorino romano and extra virgin olive oil.
Grandma Pizza
4.5 slice. Homemade mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, basil, fresh garlic, authentic pecorino romano and extra virgin olive oil.

Beverages

Canned Soda
Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+10 photos
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+9 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Nice little pizza spot, the pizza is crispy and prices are good especially considering the location. All the city employees and government employees probably go to this spot for a quick bite. Give this place a try
May 2025
Happened to be near the court house and was wandering around trying to find a simple inexpensive lunch when I came across the neon Baxter Street Pizza sign.For $3.50, I was super pleased with the crispy thin crust, not too cheesy, just enough pepperoni slice that I took to-go.I messed up by not taking advantage of the lunch special (2 slices + drink = ~$6). I really messed up by not getting the ziti slice, which I’ll try next time!
March 2023
Happened to be near the court house and was wandering around trying to find a simple inexpensive lunch when I came across the neon Baxter Street Pizza sign.

For $3.50, I was super pleased with the crispy thin crust, not too cheesy, just enough pepperoni slice that I took to-go.

I messed up by not taking advantage of the lunch special (2 slices + drink = ~$6). I really messed up by not getting the ziti slice, which I’ll try next time!
March 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pasteur Grill & Noodles - 85 Baxter St
Vietnamese, Noodles, Vegan
Nha Trang One - 87 Baxter St
Vietnamese, Vegan, Vegetarian
Sugarcane Daddy - 87 Baxter St
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies

Baxter Street Pizza

83 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013
(212) 431-8574