Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

23 E 40th St, New York
(212) 338-0818

Recent Reviews

Sort by
donna cromer

Attended a medical meeting today (July 14, 2025)…The food was delicious & service was superb…The disabled restroom, which I needed to use was HUGE, no complaints. I was able to enter & exit using my mobility scooter. Thank you for the accommodation, it is appreciated!!!

Jeff Woodhead

Went here for my birthday steak dinner. I had the ribeye and the wife got her filet. They were both a perfect medium rare and well seasoned. My French Onion Soup was exquisite. The Gruyère they use is the perfect distillation of the type. The sides were perfect. Service was coming from everywhere and perfectly coordinated. The room had the perfect steakhouse vibe with high ceilings and gorgeous wood everywhere. Only complaint, and it’s minor, is that the Brussels sprouts in the online menu don’t exist in real life. Woulda got dem sprouts. I still recommend.

Tihomir Toshev

Great restaurant, high quality food and perfect service!

Josh Jacobsen

I had the best porterhouse of my life here! Jet was a great waiter that was the ultimate professional. He was very thorough and informative without being pushy.
The creamed corn was a level of amazing I didn't think was possible.
Will be back next time I am in the city!

Tim

Fab white tablecloth steakhouse near Bryant. Excellent service all around. Food was perfectly prepared. We mostly had seafood items but the burrata and grilled shrimp appetizers were spot on and enjoyed perfect presented sea bass swordfish and Scottish salmon. Finished w limoncello gratis.

Stephen Slabotsky

Luxury Experience from beginning to end. Incredible food and service

Fritz

Great food but it gets very loud , decor could be better for the price you pay (fake candles and plants)

ann

Very comfortable, seating area, impeccable, service, and  perfectly cooked steak. Great experience it will definitely go back!

Paul

As usual, everything was excellent. Really appreciated the table at the corner of the room. Bruno and Andi were very nice

Guillermo

While there is a quiet ambience, drunk people can be heard all over the place shouting from the bar. Steaks and sides were good, but nothing amazing. Onion soup was watery. Three stars at the most

GregM

Everything about this place was amazing! Took clients for dinner. Seafood appetizer was incredible with the BEST scallops I've ever tasted! Entrees included Yellowfin tuna, 3 Ribeyes and 1 porterhouse. All cooked perfectly and delicious! Our server was very knowledgeable and attentive. Will definitely return the next time I'm in the city!

Richard

Discovered the pecan pie tonight...out of this world! Service and food excellent as usual.

Melissa

With the consideration of the location in mind, I suppose the exorbitant price is what you expect. However with that being said, I do believe the service could've been a little better. Staff was friendly enough. They just were not detail oriented ( had to ask for items multiple times) and were slow. Three hours for dinner is a long time especially when you're out of town and you have a driver and a car waiting for you. If you're not in any hurry or have loads of patience, I would say give it a try. Food was decent.

Stacy

Delicious 12 oz filet cooked perfectly! Great price for the size. The crab cocktail and creamy corn were delightful as well! Our server took care to make sure everything was perfect. Highly recommend!

April

This was our 1st visit to Benjamin Prime. Everything was AMAZING! Started with the crabcake and lobster bisque, the flavors were delicious. Porterhouse for 2, lobster mac n cheese and mushrooms... OMG flavors exploding in your mouth. Perfectly cooked, great crust. We were so full we took a pecan pie to go! The service was friendly and attentive. We'll definitely be back!

Loading...