Black Iron Burger

540 E 5th St, New York
(212) 677-6067

Recent Reviews

Emmanuel M.

This small burger spot between Ave A &B is now a local favorite. The 'kitchen' is behind the bar so you can watch your food being made right in front of you. They also have plenty of seating for parties of many sizes including window seating and a single booth. The service was quick and exceptional.

Ben M.

Wow! These burgers were ridiculously good. I had a burger with Portobello mushrooms and sautéed onions and the house mayonnaise. The service was great and very fast and the waiters were very friendly. Would 1000% recommend.

Brian De Jesus

Great burgers and fries. Staff is exceptional. They have won awards for a reason!

Cesar Calderon

burgers and service here is great. Great location to chill, eat some good food. I had a brother come into town and he asked me to go back here. Prices are decent. Feels like a place in Los Angeles I liked.

Sherry Bray

burgers... so tasty. The service here is outstanding. They have so many great reviews for a reason.

Elise Sanders

One of my top locations for quality burgers. looking forward to coming back with my friends. i can see why they have a lot of great reviews.

David U.

So my buddy Andrew Burban brought me here a couple of years ago and I've been regularly coming back ever since. The burgers, especially the mushroom truffle burger, melt in your mouth. Favorite burger in NYC currently. Also I don't really leave reviews ever, but this place deserves it.

Emi B.

Masterpiece burger was pretty good. Caesar Salad was not, they used cheap quality dressing. Sweet Potato Fries was TUMMY delicious, crispy and soft and sweet! Sometimes bad sweet potato could be flavorless.

Hannah G.

These guys are my go to takeout now when ordering off Seamless! The burgers are so good! I'm the type of person to always order the same thing when I find something I like so I always order the Black Iron classic burger with horseradish mayo! My boyfriend usually gets the Masterpiece which includes a fried egg and then we usually order two sets of fries - the garlic and the loaded! Always excellent, always tasty and I'm always satisfied after....although massively full that I tend to slip into a food coma. But that's a positive in my eyes

Nicholas Orluk

They make a good burger and fries which is presumably why you're going to a burger restaurant. As with most burger joints, the burgers are pretty extensively customizable and their signature burgers are also great. Loaded fries are solid as well. The wings and the horseradish cheese sticks were both kind of meh for me but stick to burgers, fries and beers and you really can't go wrong.

Marcin R.

Had the master piece burger. Top 5 burgers I ever had. Aside from the delicious burgers the home made hot sauce is out of this world. I can not express how amazing this sauce is!!! A bbq/hot sauce blend... Just fantastic. Go try if and bring home the hot sauce.

Andrew Salazar

Nice place for a burger and drink at night. Stumbled across this place on my birthday one night when I was visting New York. I really loved the atmosphere of the place and I was serviced perfectly and couldn't ask for a better crew! I can't remember what the burger I got was called but I did love it and really wish I had another at this time! I was full by the time I was done eatting I highly recommend this place if you are in New York for food and sports. A great birthday for myself and can't wait to go back!

David Wallach

Tasty burgers. A good selection of beers and good fries. If you're looking for something that isn't a burger this isn't the place but I shouldn't have to tell you that.

Andrew B.

Yet another magical experience. Sure, we waited a little bit for our table. It's a popular place after all. But, once we were seated? Oof. We went to town. At least, I did. I got the mushroom truffle burger, but I got a triple patty for 1 lb of burger. It was inhaled in under a minute. So fresh, so hot, so juicy... it's a pure explosion of flavor going off in your mouth. Epic. We also got some of their loaded fries, which are always great. The truffle aioli goes well with them too. Staff are A+ as usual. Our waitress was super accommodating. She had our waters ready before I even had a chance to ask. Overall, another great time. This isn't the last time I'm coming back here.

Mary P.

I found this place on a whim. I went with a few friends and we all thoroughly enjoyed our food. The loaded fries were absolutely amazing! The burgers were delicious, and didn't feel heavy after eating. Service was great. Not overpriced & worth the money! This was also a good location as it wasn't too crowded. It's been a few days and my friends and I are still talking about the food, most definitely will be going back.

Load More