Black Iron Burger Theater District

250 W 54th St, New York
(212) 447-1106

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matthew

Great burger and service. Onion rings were a little bland but huge portion. Nutella brownie was “good” not great. Overall great experience with solid bar staff. Would definitely return for a “tasty” burger!

Courtney

Food was delicious and served quickly. Sports on tvs but music playing as well. Great spot before a show!

Christina

Kinda tight in there and didn't get any happy hour drinks after 3 pm same price for drinks sad about that

Jennifer (Fern)

Awesome food and friendly staff! Tried the smash burger and sweet potato fries yum! The warm lava cookie was amazing!

David

My date and I each had the American burger, (medium-well) — one with fries, the other with onion rings. The burgers were cooked to perfection: juicy and flavorful. The onion rings were tasty but greasy. The shoestring fries were delicious with no grease whatsoever. Chips and salsa as a complimentary appetizer were a pleasant surprise. Service was great at the beginning, then our waitress disappeared, but a different server saved the day until she reappeared at the end of the meal.

Artaza

Chill place. 15USD smash burgers set up for success but ultimately ended up dry. Patties were dry and cheese on the lightly melted side. Sauce, onion and pickle combo was the layup for a really good burger. But, as said, the main character was dry, too bad. Can be a 9/10 burger with better patties. Soft gluten free bun. Service was standard, and really helpful. Maybe we got unlucky with the burgers on that serving.

Maryline

Great experience, perfect service and enjoyable food and beers ! The prices are very reasonable, which makes it a very good value for money

Dan

Solid burger. Crappy fries (from frozen) and a tiny portion for a large order. Mediocre service.

Melissa

Burgers excellent and cooked exactly as ordered, onion rings delicious. Cocktails a bit small for the price but draft beer great.

Laurie

Burgers and onion rings were great! Waiter was great too. Service a little slow but overall was really good!

Rose

First visit to Black iron burger, we loved it, 10/10. We had: burger, bacon, fried egg. And burger, bacon+cheese. Sides of onion rings and fries were really tasty also. Black iron aioli and ranch dressing. Dessert; lava cookie...surprised us how delicious this was...we shared it between 2 people. The staff here were sooooo nice and welcoming. The atmosphere was lovely and relaxed. We were here for pre-theatre...would definitely recommend. Loved the whole experience. :)

Alicia

One of the beat burgers I've had! Cooked exactly as requested. Service was friendly and efficient. Decent pricing as well.

Martyn

Nice NY bar with good food options and fast efficient service. Prices reflect overall madness of NY pricing so not great value but on par with other restaurants

Brad

We enjoyed our lunch and our waitress was very accommodating. It was a little warm inside the restaurant. They had a large fan so we figured air conditioning problems. Right next door to Studio 54 if you are going there for a show.

natalie

Very good yucca chips and guac! Yum! Burger was delicious , really good show string fries too! I had the fish sandwich , it was good but I would recommend sauce and Cole slaw on the side !

Loading...

Black Iron Burger Theater District

250 W 54th St, New York, NY 10019
(212) 447-1106