Black Iron Burger Theater District

Amazing burger!!! I always say never go to same place twice in New York since so many choices but will be back here it was that good!

The place is great but they don't serve coffee or tea. WTF?! When the waitress asked if we'd like dessert, I said , “We would - if you had coffee or tea!”

Great Time at Black Iron... food was on point, Wings, Custom Burger, Drinks... will definitely be going back soon!

Outstanding burgers and beer. Try the All American. The Allagash beer was great. I'll be back.

Had to wait for the table- fine for extra 15 minutes. But when ordering, we felt tricked to get bottled water- as if there wasn't a choice of tap- fine, will ask questions. Each of us got a burger- all were too dry! For a place that is meant to be for burgers, serving overcooked, dry burgers is offensive. I get it, Saturday during Theater Rush it was busy so they pre cooked the food seems efficient, but the result felt like cafeteria food. For the price we paid, it should have been custom fresh cook. Additionally, I ordered custom with raw onion & horseradish mayo & neither came. I had to flag down a different waiter after a bit to get it. Will never be back. We've gone to plenty of places for burgers in the area that served far better food. Also, my upscale margarita was total rip off with full ice & small amount of liquid. Will never be back.

Good affordable location to eat when in area or going to Broadway out of Broadway show. Atmosphere is a little little loud but place is sports bar themed.. I had the Turkey burger with toppings and garlic fries and wings appetizer. Fries can be shared. Take food. Manager was nice and accommodating. We had a reservation but don't think it's needed. Would return.

I recently had a wonderful meal here! I loved the AI-Oli fries. The service was amazing, our server was Mateo. Mateo recommended some great menu items and provided excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tasty burgers and great service by Diana at the bar! Thank you!

Loved it! Mateo did an awesome job. I was in town for business and he treated me with kindness and efficiency. Quick, great service! I'll come back soon.

Service: 5

This place has the potential to be a really cool spot. However, I did not enjoy myself. We went during happy hour. I ordered a drink not on the happy hour menu. The server decided that I should order something else to save money and suggested a drink that he said was similar. I was irritated but I obliged. The drink was not similar. It was made with a similar alcohol but not what I wanted. Then another drink appeared and the server said the bartender made the wrong drink and they were giving it to us. That drink was not good. But the kicker is that he moved my drink to my husband and said he would like that and gave me the fruity light drink. I was ready to go then. I do not need my drinks monitored or assigned by the server. We paid and left and went to another bar. I do not intend to go back. They had plenty of space but sat us beside a couple with crying children and another group. If he would have brought me the drink I wanted, this review may have gone differently.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Best Burger i had in my life. Visited few times and loved it every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great atmosphere and friendly staff :) of course with excellent food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of the best burgers I've had in a long time. If you're having the mushroom burger get an egg on top! Staff were great and nice ambience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing place!!! Gluten free options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandy was our waiter, and he was absolutely aMAZing!!!!🔥💜🔥💜🔥💜🔥

Service nice!!! Personality plus!!! Food fabulous!!!! Music on point!!! Atmosphere lt!!!🔥🔥🔥 I visited today with my family, and we loved every aspect of the evening.

I look forward to our next visit!🤟🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5