Bleeker street pizza is my favorite spot in town for ny style pizza. The nonna Maria is so good and fresh. The cheese they use is amazing and the crust is perfect!
G Zilla
On the search for iconic NY style pizza. Bleeker St Pizza is waaay better than L'industrie Pizzeria.
Will M
Best pizza I’ve ever had! Grandma slice all the way.
R B
New review: everything’s fast food now and comes from a can. There’s no attention to flavor anymore. The texture of the pizza is alright but there’s no sourdough goodness in the crust anymore. The tomato sauce is canned. The cheese isn’t quite stretchy, the basil isn’t fresh. Sad the old owner sold the place. Better than dominos but hardly what it used to be.
Old review: The best pizza of my life. You New Yorkers are so lucky, we have the worst pizza in Vegas. Perfectly crisp crust, fresh mozzarella, real high quality parmeseano reggiano, tomato sauce homemade (and tastes fresh, no over-sourness). I can’t look at pizza the same again.
Greg was also really friendly. Cool to meet the guy who started the restaurant.
Sandra Ore
This will always be the best pizza in New York for me. Simple, with a perfectly crunchy thin crust that never sags. I’ve been coming here for 20 years, and it’s still my number one choice.
Abe Awasthi
First time visit. The Nonna Maria is fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, basil, parmesan. It’s a classic formula. Crust is NYC perfect. Light and airy but solid undercarriage and very little flop. Top looks appetizing and not swimming in oil. The sauce is out of this world. Had the right amount of zing and zip and is not a flat sauce. This is a top 2 slice for me along with Joe’s and arguably up there is John’s down the road and Juliana’s in BRK. Must visit.
Evan Howard
Recently visited NY from Seattle and stayed near Washington Square park. Upon Googling looking pizza joints there were 4 that popped up; Two Boots Pizza, Johns, Joes, and Bleecker St Pizza. My entire stay Johns had a crazy line out the door, upwards of an hour wait in crazy heat/humidity. We decided we only wanted a slice and so stopped at Bleecker St, and boy am I glad I did! Service was friendly, from order to pickup of food was super quick, and the pizza was delicious. The Margherita and Chicken Bacon Ranch were my absolute favorite slices. All in we ordered 4 slices, and 4 beers, and the total was -$50…not bad in NYC I feel like. OH AND the pièce de résistance was Mr. Greg! He chatted with us and asked where we were visiting from and how we liked NYC. He then told us a bunch of stuff to do in New York, and said that we’ll have to come back next year. Great spot, great staff, and even better pizza!
Emily Wall
I got a slice of cheese pizza. The crust was pretty firm but the taste was so-so. The taste of the sauce reminded me more of frozen pizza sauce. It's fine if you're hungry, but for me the taste didn't live up to the hype.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mike C. Chung
I've been living in New York City for quite some time, and Bleecker Street Pizza is one of the best spots in town. The toppings are perfectly portioned, and the crust is delightfully crispy. I still remember my first bite of their Margherita slice—it was truly magical. ?✨ #NYCPizza #
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Cheese Slice
Vojtěch Kocourek
One of the best pizza places in New York. Slice of Nonna Maria is a true must have. Staff is really friendly and Greg is an amazing host. This place has a story, heart and having a lunch here is an amazing complex experience. Wish to be back!
Service was great! Pizza was okay. Felt that it was a little too greasy and the cheese to crust ratio was off (too much cheese and the pizza was floppy). Also got a garlic knot and that was the star
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Slice
Murad Huthali
Hands down the best cheese pizza in NYC after trying 10+ pizza cribs it still wins them all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Nick Woods
We visited here as my wife is coeliac and so needs gluten-free options. They made her a gluten-free pizza with ease and it was really good value for money too. Me and our two teenage boys shared a cheese pie between us and it was great quality. If you want to try an authentic taste of NYC pizza, eat here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jaci Bennett
Always so delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nonna Maria
Mark Samples
Overall amazing, line outside looked discouraging, but it moved quick and the pizza was delicious.
Bleeker street pizza is my favorite spot in town for ny style pizza. The nonna Maria is so good and fresh. The cheese they use is amazing and the crust is perfect!
On the search for iconic NY style pizza. Bleeker St Pizza is waaay better than L'industrie Pizzeria.
Best pizza I’ve ever had! Grandma slice all the way.
New review: everything’s fast food now and comes from a can. There’s no attention to flavor anymore. The texture of the pizza is alright but there’s no sourdough goodness in the crust anymore. The tomato sauce is canned. The cheese isn’t quite stretchy, the basil isn’t fresh. Sad the old owner sold the place. Better than dominos but hardly what it used to be.
Old review:
The best pizza of my life. You New Yorkers are so lucky, we have the worst pizza in Vegas. Perfectly crisp crust, fresh mozzarella, real high quality parmeseano reggiano, tomato sauce homemade (and tastes fresh, no over-sourness). I can’t look at pizza the same again.
Greg was also really friendly. Cool to meet the guy who started the restaurant.
This will always be the best pizza in New York for me. Simple, with a perfectly crunchy thin crust that never sags. I’ve been coming here for 20 years, and it’s still my number one choice.
First time visit. The Nonna Maria is fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, basil, parmesan. It’s a classic formula. Crust is NYC perfect. Light and airy but solid undercarriage and very little flop. Top looks appetizing and not swimming in oil. The sauce is out of this world. Had the right amount of zing and zip and is not a flat sauce. This is a top 2 slice for me along with Joe’s and arguably up there is John’s down the road and Juliana’s in BRK. Must visit.
Recently visited NY from Seattle and stayed near Washington Square park. Upon Googling looking pizza joints there were 4 that popped up; Two Boots Pizza, Johns, Joes, and Bleecker St Pizza. My entire stay Johns had a crazy line out the door, upwards of an hour wait in crazy heat/humidity. We decided we only wanted a slice and so stopped at Bleecker St, and boy am I glad I did! Service was friendly, from order to pickup of food was super quick, and the pizza was delicious. The Margherita and Chicken Bacon Ranch were my absolute favorite slices. All in we ordered 4 slices, and 4 beers, and the total was -$50…not bad in NYC I feel like. OH AND the pièce de résistance was Mr. Greg! He chatted with us and asked where we were visiting from and how we liked NYC. He then told us a bunch of stuff to do in New York, and said that we’ll have to come back next year. Great spot, great staff, and even better pizza!
I got a slice of cheese pizza. The crust was pretty firm but the taste was so-so. The taste of the sauce reminded me more of frozen pizza sauce. It's fine if you're hungry, but for me the taste didn't live up to the hype.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
I've been living in New York City for quite some time, and Bleecker Street Pizza is one of the best spots in town. The toppings are perfectly portioned, and the crust is delightfully crispy. I still remember my first bite of their Margherita slice—it was truly magical. ?✨ #NYCPizza #
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Cheese Slice
One of the best pizza places in New York. Slice of Nonna Maria is a true must have.
Staff is really friendly and Greg is an amazing host. This place has a story, heart and having a lunch here is an amazing complex experience. Wish to be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was great! Pizza was okay. Felt that it was a little too greasy and the cheese to crust ratio was off (too much cheese and the pizza was floppy). Also got a garlic knot and that was the star
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Slice
Hands down the best cheese pizza in NYC
after trying 10+ pizza cribs it still wins them all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
We visited here as my wife is coeliac and so needs gluten-free options. They made her a gluten-free pizza with ease and it was really good value for money too. Me and our two teenage boys shared a cheese pie between us and it was great quality. If you want to try an authentic taste of NYC pizza, eat here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Always so delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nonna Maria
Overall amazing, line outside looked discouraging, but it moved quick and the pizza was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...