Carragher's

Basement Bar, 17 John St, New York
(646) 414-6223

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jack Grange

They charge 50 dollars cash entry on a game day. They have a cash machine down there which only gives out 20’s and charges you a 4 dollar fee. You’re $64 down before you enter. It includes a scarf and a drink ticket so okay, maybe it’s not so bad.

You get to the bar with the included drink ticket you’ve been given and order a pale ale. The drink ticket does not include a pale ale. The guy looks like he’s ready to snap and says “well I’ve poured it now” and walks off, ignoring you. You find someone else to serve you a lager and try to pick a spot to stand (it’s standing room only) where you’re not in the way.

Because of the amount of people there’s a decent atmosphere and it’s the only dedicated place for Liverpool fans. But I cannot think of somewhere further away from the spirit of Liverpool than a rip-off bar with moody staff than this. Go watch the game in a proper bar that doesn’t just want to fleece you.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

HomeIPstore

Scam alert. From the UK and came here to watch a game. The guy at the door demanded $50 to let me in to watch it. This is completely against what Liverpool FC represents. This place should be boycotted by real Liverpool fans.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Edward Byrne

Not a Liverpool fan and would never set foot in the place. However, after reading that they are charging fans fifty dollars to watch a game here, it is apparent that the place is owned by absolute scumbags, who know nothing about the great city of Liverpool and how friendly and hospitable its residents are.

Niladri Chakraborty

Nothing out of the ordinary. Just basic

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

jHshs Neue

I recently stopped by this pub to grab a drink for a friend's birthday. Despite a somewhat unpleasant initial odor – likely a result of years of accumulated spills – the atmosphere was fantastic, especially considering its size in bustling New York City. The pub has a great ambiance overall. I'd suggest a thorough floor cleaning to address the lingering smell, but otherwise, it's a lively and enjoyable spot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips

Jessica Smith

Great big space, food is pretty good, lots of places to hang with friends. Only issue is karaoke ends at midnight. But service is always great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Chip VonBurg

Great NYC spot, good drinks, atmosphere, good folks. Definitely worth checking out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tony Power

Possibly the worst pint of Guinness I’ve ever experienced, lager we left half drank Food was the smallest portion we came across in manhattan , decor I feel Jamie must of been on a massive ego trip ( me myself and I ) if you were a South American you wouldn’t have a clue who this garragher is

Peter Gib

Really nice food with reasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Carragher's Burger and Fries

Elif Ak

I come to this bar all the time & the customer service keeps getting drastically worse. They don’t care for customer satisfaction, they refuse to open additional rooms as they have multiple available, the food crew serving is so spiky and have much attitude and almost to a level of yelling at their customers. Liverpool is a good cult and an fan of the team but this bar is horrible and not worth the price. I come from Greenpoint, BK to be here and it is always a shitshow, they make customers’ experience so terrible, leaves a bitter taste in the mouth.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alexander Csorba

Wouldn’t recommend the place. Didn’t have food, but service for drinks was substandard and there was a bad smell in the pub that grew during our stay prompting us to leave.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 2

Nick Wilkinson

Short stay NYC, but this was on my list of places to go.. Cant wait to go back, hopefully on a match day !!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Neil Fisher

A great bar to unwind. Brilliant Guinness too!

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

James Reynolds

Great service and staff. Spacious pub with a great atmosphere and choice of drinks/food. Would recommend to any football fan during match days and anyone looking for a pleasant drink/meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris McGeachin

Called in to watch the LFC WHU match. The negative is that they don’t accept Apple Pay and I had come out without my wallet or any cash. I only discovered this little issue as I swallowed my first mouthful of the finest bottled lager from the Netherlands.

Josh, the Liverpool fan from Denver, very kindly paid for my bottle and then, later on, the exceptionally pleasant Irish bar lady gave me a second with instructions to “pay it forward”. A great bar, especially if you’re a Liverpool fan, just make sure you bring some cash or a card.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Loading...