Club Mac is the cigar lounge you're there to have a night. It's going to cost you but the atmosphere is upper crust. Also. stay away from getting an old fashioned. Muddled maraschino cherries are a waste of cherries and bourbon. Sorry, but if you're going to charge the prices the least you can do is Google a decent recipe.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Paul Disilvio
Terrific night , awesome feeling to be back home in the big apple at Club Macanudo with incredible friends, soon to be released Prodical Son cigars, Great food, and non-stop laughs. The vibe here is unmatched—pure class, great company, and memories that spark joy. Let's Lightemup NYC!
Paid $80 for a cigar and weak old fashion. They also had a mouse running around, which I mentioned to 3 people and not one person seemed surprised. Never saw the waitress after the first order. I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
Conrad Francis
The epitome of a cigar lounge. Very comfortable with a great menu of food, drinks and cigars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Nola
The fact that you can sit inside get food, drinks and a cigar, while it's pouring rain outside makes it at least 4 stars. The attention you get while there brings it up to 5 stars. Is it pricey yes somewhat if you were comparing this to 3 different locations. Again doing all of this in one spot it's worth every dollar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars, Calamari, Grilled Chicken Quesadilla, Classic New Yorker Nachos
mikec695
Very good experience here as a non member! All staff I interacted with were polite and friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
taha idihya
Only want your money! I have been to many cigar lounges, clubs and even shops, and the cigar community usually is very welcoming, not this place. The whole interaction was soulless. The hostess was very unwelcoming to the point that i walked out before i even saw the cigar. Coming to NYC i wanted to try the cigar lounges in the area. Would highly recommend this place if you want to spend your money just to be treated like they are doing you a favor by letting you into the lounge. My recommendation is to go to Casa de Montecristo , they on the other hand treated me extremely well and allowed me into their humidor to take my pick.
This place brings shame to the cigar community.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
abigail lay
It takes so much for me to leave a place, yet walking out was an easy decision tonight. My boyfriend and I went in to look for a place to enjoy a nice cigar and possibly dinner. The host, a short woman with glasses rudely addressed us asking if we had been in before. After a few minutes my boyfriend had chose a cigar, she goes to find it and shouts “ONLY ONE?” instead of coming and addressing us as customers. As my boyfriend met her at the counter to pay, instead of completing the transaction she begins attending to other customers.. Handing one man his jacket and taking a phone call right after.. She rang up the cigar but was going to wait until after the phone call to cash him out EVEN though he was at the register before the phone call. If you aren't a member at this pretentious over priced “club” they don’t seem to treat you as a customer, which is a shame considering how much good business and money it will cost them. Anyone looking for a good cigar shop with great prices, atmosphere, and SERVICE should check out house of montecristo. We had an amazing experience the day prior. As a tourist, I will be sure not to recommend this establishment to any cigar connoisseurs I know.
Brian Andrade
Great ambiance. Great service. Even when it’s busy - the bartenders and servers are always highly attentive. Very classy. Old New York. And they play a good mix of classic oldies and more newer music
Been to several cigar lounges from Boston to Atlanta and hands down this is still my favorite. Cigar selection is phenomenal and the atmosphere matches it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
George Chaconas
Best cigar bar in NYC. Great service. Fun mingling with the regulars.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
James Zorn
The beautiful wood interior and warm inviting vibe is awesome. The Club allows walk-ins, but there is a $40 minimum per person, and $20 of it has to be cigars. My wife and I had a drink and dessert. The warm chocolate truffles were delicious, and the coffee was also tasty. The service was friendly and helpful, they kep the ashtrays clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
Vinnie Shikapuri
If you want to just chill smoke a cigar with some pairing drinks this is a good place Although we didn't eat from what I could tell, they must have a good kitchen
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carmen Guzman
Went here on a date with a special gentleman during my visit to NY and I must admit that I had an amazing time. Both the atmosphere and the company were phenomenal! I’m not one to drink but during my visit to NY I did make exceptions 🙈. I order The Godmother, I forgot which drink he had but it was very tasty. We also ordered appetizers and an entree that we shared, I’m not a big eater. He was such a gentleman. He even fed me 😜. We each enjoyed a cigar. He had chosen something light for me, one a bit bolder for himself. It was a very relaxed crowd. I had such a great time. We closed out the place. The staff was attentive as well. I would definitely recommend this place hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars, Grilled Chicken Quesadilla, French Fries
Club Mac is the cigar lounge you're there to have a night. It's going to cost you but the atmosphere is upper crust. Also. stay away from getting an old fashioned. Muddled maraschino cherries are a waste of cherries and bourbon. Sorry, but if you're going to charge the prices the least you can do is Google a decent recipe.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Terrific night , awesome feeling to be back home in the big apple at Club Macanudo with incredible friends, soon to be released Prodical Son cigars, Great food, and non-stop laughs. The vibe here is unmatched—pure class, great company, and memories that spark joy. Let's Lightemup NYC!
#NYCNights #ClubMacanudo #BigAppleVibes #CigarLife #FoodieHeaven #LaughsAndGoodTimes #NYCAdventures #LuxuryLifestyle #FriendsNightOut #CityThatNeverSleeps #GoodVibesOnly #CigarLovers #NYCFoodies #UpperEastSide #NightLifeGoals
Paid $80 for a cigar and weak old fashion. They also had a mouse running around, which I mentioned to 3 people and not one person seemed surprised. Never saw the waitress after the first order. I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
The epitome of a cigar lounge. Very comfortable with a great menu of food, drinks and cigars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The fact that you can sit inside get food, drinks and a cigar, while it's pouring rain outside makes it at least 4 stars. The attention you get while there brings it up to 5 stars. Is it pricey yes somewhat if you were comparing this to 3 different locations. Again doing all of this in one spot it's worth every dollar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars, Calamari, Grilled Chicken Quesadilla, Classic New Yorker Nachos
Very good experience here as a non member! All staff I interacted with were polite and friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Only want your money! I have been to many cigar lounges, clubs and even shops, and the cigar community usually is very welcoming, not this place. The whole interaction was soulless. The hostess was very unwelcoming to the point that i walked out before i even saw the cigar. Coming to NYC i wanted to try the cigar lounges in the area. Would highly recommend this place if you want to spend your money just to be treated like they are doing you a favor by letting you into the lounge. My recommendation is to go to Casa de Montecristo , they on the other hand treated me extremely well and allowed me into their humidor to take my pick.
This place brings shame to the cigar community.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It takes so much for me to leave a place, yet walking out was an easy decision tonight. My boyfriend and I went in to look for a place to enjoy a nice cigar and possibly dinner. The host, a short woman with glasses rudely addressed us asking if we had been in before. After a few minutes my boyfriend had chose a cigar, she goes to find it and shouts “ONLY ONE?” instead of coming and addressing us as customers. As my boyfriend met her at the counter to pay, instead of completing the transaction she begins attending to other customers.. Handing one man his jacket and taking a phone call right after.. She rang up the cigar but was going to wait until after the phone call to cash him out EVEN though he was at the register before the phone call. If you aren't a member at this pretentious over priced “club” they don’t seem to treat you as a customer, which is a shame considering how much good business and money it will cost them. Anyone looking for a good cigar shop with great prices, atmosphere, and SERVICE should check out house of montecristo. We had an amazing experience the day prior. As a tourist, I will be sure not to recommend this establishment to any cigar connoisseurs I know.
Great ambiance. Great service. Even when it’s busy - the bartenders and servers are always highly attentive. Very classy. Old New York. And they play a good mix of classic oldies and more newer music
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
Great place for cigar
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
Restaurantji Recommends
Been to several cigar lounges from Boston to Atlanta and hands down this is still my favorite. Cigar selection is phenomenal and the atmosphere matches it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
Best cigar bar in NYC. Great service. Fun mingling with the regulars.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The beautiful wood interior and warm inviting vibe is awesome. The Club allows walk-ins, but there is a $40 minimum per person, and $20 of it has to be cigars. My wife and I had a drink and dessert. The warm chocolate truffles were delicious, and the coffee was also tasty. The service was friendly and helpful, they kep the ashtrays clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars
If you want to just chill smoke a cigar with some pairing drinks this is a good place
Although we didn't eat from what I could tell, they must have a good kitchen
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went here on a date with a special gentleman during my visit to NY and I must admit that I had an amazing time. Both the atmosphere and the company were phenomenal! I’m not one to drink but during my visit to NY I did make exceptions 🙈. I order The Godmother, I forgot which drink he had but it was very tasty.
We also ordered appetizers and an entree that we shared, I’m not a big eater. He was such a gentleman. He even fed me 😜.
We each enjoyed a cigar. He had chosen something light for me, one a bit bolder for himself. It was a very relaxed crowd. I had such a great time. We closed out the place. The staff was attentive as well. I would definitely recommend this place hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Cigars, Grilled Chicken Quesadilla, French Fries
Loading...