Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
174 5th Ave, New York
(212) 675-5096
Customers' Favorites
Sándwich de Pastrami
Eggs Cheese and Ham
Pastrami Reuben
Matzo Ball Soup
Pastrami on Rye
Chopped Liver
Hot Pastrami
French Fries
Free Pickles
Turkey Club
Menu
Photos
+58 photos
+57 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Reuben sandwiches were my favorite before becoming vegetarian, and I felt very deprived
... until today! Running errands in the neighborhood, looking for a quick lunch, I discovered the Shop. Sat at the counter, browsed the menu in search of veg options... Broccoli Reuben! Ordered it of course with some macaroni salad. Not the same, yet delicious. Served with a lone pickle.
On the expensive side -$18.50 + $6.
Great atmosphere and extra friendly service.
... until today! Running errands in the neighborhood, looking for a quick lunch, I discovered the Shop. Sat at the counter, browsed the menu in search of veg options... Broccoli Reuben! Ordered it of course with some macaroni salad. Not the same, yet delicious. Served with a lone pickle.
On the expensive side -$18.50 + $6.
Great atmosphere and extra friendly service.
had a tuna melt ($18.59 before i was prompted for a tip) to go. took 10-15 mins. figured it would be an oversized, tasty sandwich for the price + high reviews. the sandwich was small (see picture), and very average. venue + ambiance is definitely the draw. if you want to pay a premium for a mediocre sandwich in a cute venue, stop by. if not, definitely pass on Eisenberg’s.
You May Also Like
S&P Lunch - 174 5th Ave
![]()
Burgers
Juice Press - 1 W 22nd St
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Vegan
Sagaponack - 4 W 22nd St
![]()
Seafood, Bar, American, Specialty Food, Asian Fusion
It's been 8 years since my last visit and everything was as good as ever!The food is just outstanding and the team there are just brilliant. My No.1 eating place in Manhattan!