Emmett's

50 Macdougal St, New York
(917) 639-3571

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Build Your Own Deep Dish Pizza Chicago
Emmett's Favorites Deep Dish Pizza
Build Your Own Thin Crust Pizza
Housemade Mozzarella Sticks
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza Slice
Chicago Style Hot Dog
Chicago Italian Beef
Deep Margarita Pizza
Pizza Chicago Style

Menu

Starters
Mozzarella Sticks
House Cut French Fries
House Cut Potato Chips

Salads
Caesar
romaine, crouton, shavedaged parmesan, housemade dressing
Greek
Arugula
baby arugula, shallot, sliced apple,lemon, walnuts, shaved grana padano
Wedge
iceberg lettuce, organic tomato,red onion, bacon, blue cheese

Sandwiches & Dogs
Chicago Style Hot Dog
Vienna Beef hot dog topped with pickle spear, sliced tomato, diced white onions, neon green relish, sport peppers, celery salt, yellow mustard on a poppy seed bun
Italian Beef Sandwich
Slow roasted Italian beef simmeredin its own gravy, served dry or dippedwith spicy giardiniera
Italian Sausage
grilled sausage with peppers & onion
"Char" Cheddar Burger
sharp cheddar cheese spread, caramelized onions, sport peppers, relish, tomato, ketchup & mustard
Char-Dog
open-flamed grilled Vienna Beef hot dog
The Burger
pickles, onion, dijonnaise
Combo
Italian sausage and Italian beef together
Grilled Cheese
Roast Beef Sandwich
thinly sliced roast beef, tomato,red onion, horseradish mayonnaise
Blues Burger
blue cheese stuffed patty, caramelized onions

BYO
Build your own Deep Dish
Build your own Thin Crust
it all starts with cheese and tomato sauce...

Deep Dish Specialty
The Sausage Classic
sausage, green pepper, onion
Meat Lover
pepperoni, sausage, Italian beef
Gabe Froman
spinach, 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 sausage
This Buds for You
spinach, white onion, mushroom
The Big O
Italian beef, white onion
Magnum P Eye
pineapple, ham

Thin Crust Specialty
Hot Girl
pepperoni, jalapeño,mike's hot honey
Peggy O'
grana padano, parmesan,pecorino romano, fresh basil
Hot Papi
pepperoni, red onion, jalapeño,homemade paprika ranch
Nadine
buffalo mozzarella, grana padano,parmesan, pecorino romano, basil
Big Gay Al
Italian beef, spicy giardiniera
Mr. Red
red pie with fresh garlic, basil,pecorino romano

Sauce on the Side
Paprika Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey

Sodas
Diet Coke Can
Coke Can
Saranac Root Beer
Ginger Ale
Sprite Can
Topo Chico 12oz
Saratoga Still
Saratoga Sparkling
Topo Chico 25.4oz

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+63 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+62 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

After years of traveling around the country and the world and searching out great spots that care deeply about what they serve, I’ve committed to highlighting places I love. Most everyone loves pizza - I’m right up there in the top 0.1 percentile of pizza fanatics. Living in NYC, I’ve been fortunate to eat at almost every one of the great spots - in all five boroughs. Tonight my daughter and I wanted to try deep dish at Emmett’s on MacDougal. I’ve eaten at this Emmett’s...
January 2026
One of the best tavern thin pie in town, compared to the location on Grove, this spot feels more casual and bar-like which is awesome. Small space with very limited seating so highly recommend make a reservation (even on a weeknight).
January 2026
If you are looking for authentic Chicago deep dish in NYC, this is absolutely the place. I’ve been a regular here for a while because I genuinely crave their pizza. The 30-minute bake time (and wait) doesn't bother me at all—it's usually worth it.
​I’m giving 4 stars instead of 5 only because the consistency varies slightly; every once in a while, the deep dish comes out a little soggy on the bottom. When it’s on point, it’s easily a 5-star meal....
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Raku - 48 Macdougal St
Japanese, Noodles, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
12 Chairs Cafe - 56 MacDougal St
Middle Eastern, American, Israeli, Vegan, Vegetarian
142 Sullivan Bar - 142 Sullivan St
Bar, Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly

Emmett's

50 Macdougal St, New York, NY 10012
(917) 639-3571