Emmy Squared Pizza: Upper East Side - New York, New York

Best pizza I've ever had. Try the vodka sauce.

Well rounded mocktails a kick to the throat and that's some the food is amazing The chef is even better and the staff are to die.

Amazing food! Amazing service! And a great date spot!

Came to Emmy’s for a dinner party. First of all, the staff was so understanding and kind. I had come from my reservation being cancelled and Emmy’s came in clutch. I would recommend going on a weekday night. It was not as busy. The food was delicious and I had not tried anything like it before. The environment was so nice and welcoming. Overall, a great experience with the team, dinner, and restaurant.

Came here for a dinner. It was great service. Food came in good time and it had a nice atmosphere. Would recommend

We had a last minute reservation for 20+ adults & teens, Eileen the bartender got us in contact with the manager Kairsten & set up for the next day. When we arrived, Elieen & Kairsten greeted us and introduced us to Robert our waiter. The food was amazing: the salads, the pizza, the waffle fries, the breaded chicken, and the brownie desserts. And the service was amazing. I recommend Emmy Squared UES 💯 We're definitely going back.

Food was delicious. Great Portions and such kind service people. Great for big parties.

We loved this place! Our waiter, Emma was so great!! We absolutely loved our food.

Hard to say whether this was a one time issue, but we placed a delivery order of the larger size pizza and the dough was much thinner than usual (hard to even call it Detroit style) and had a rubbery texture. Hoping this is a one time issue, but if it persists I will no longer be ordering from here.

Food: 2

I am not typically one to leave a review, but I have to say this place went so far beyond my expectations that I just had to talk about it. I decided to go to Emmy Squared for my birthday. We had a party of seven and when we got to the restaurant, it was so busy and for good reason. This is an extremely popular restaurant. We had to wait a couple of minutes for them to get our table ready and the manager, Kairsten, came over to apologize for this minor inconvenience and brought out two caesar salads for the table. We all got drinks and we ordered four pizzas which was enough to feed all seven of us. The pizzas were absolutely wonderful and the espresso martinis were delicious. We got the big ang, margarita, vodka, and truffle pizzas. My personal favorite was the truffle, but everyone at the table had so much trouble deciding which to choose. The restaurant also put my birthday cake in the fridge and when they brought it out, they offered to cut it for us. They ended up also bringing me a very delicious skillet. Apple dessert with ice cream. The entire staff saying happy birthday to me. I can’t thank everyone at Emme Squared enough for making my birthday so special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza and kid friendly. I could eat their pizza all day long. The Ceasar salad is great and can be shared. Best to sit outside with children.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Waited 2hrs for a takeaway. Ridiculous! Called 2 times to only he told it will be another few mins.

Once it arrived it was cold and the appetizer was missing a sauce. Awful awful awful.

Service: 1

Ordered from them tonight around 6:30 from UberEats. After about an hour, my delivery person was told 5 more minutes. An hour later, my order was fully cancelled. I understand it gets busy but to have me wait two hours only to cancel the order is simply unacceptable

excellent service and setup/vibe. forgettable pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Good food, a bit pricey but they cannot handle busy nights and if you order takeout there is a decent chance it will take over an hour but they will never communicate that because they are overwhelmed. They also might give you order to someone else without checking! Total mess, only order on non-peak hours but I will never be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1