Freddie & Pepper's

Name: Freddie & Pepper's
Address: 303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, New York, 10023, US
Telephone: (212) 799-2378
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Pizza, Italian, Fast Food

Hours:
303 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 799-2378

Menu Order Online

About Freddie & Pepper's

Freddie & Pepper's, a small, old-school pizzeria since 1978, serves some of the best pizza on the Upper West Side. Their authentic New York-style pizza has the perfect balance of sweetness and crust that reheats well. Expect a wait during peak hours, but it's worth it for a late-night bite that's as authentic as it gets. The place features a typical New York atmosphere, with a few stairs leading into a small seating area with about two tables and four chairs outside. Customers can enjoy big slices, with prices around $4 for a slice or about $20 for 8 slices. The staff is busy but friendly, providing quick service and explaining the ingredients of each pizza. Many visitors find the cheese pizza delicious and satisfying, while others recommend the pepperoni sausage and bacon pizza for its perfect crust. The restaurant sells by the slice, including vegan options, though some reviews suggest that vegan slices could be improved with vegan cheese. Additionally, the pizza is hot and cheesy, with free toppings like red pepper and garlic available. Overall, Freddie & Pepper's offers a classic NYC pizza experience, perfect for a quick, authentic bite when in the city, and many customers also enjoy the empanada combo for a tasty addition.