Gooey on The Inside Cookies
163 Chrystie St, New York
(646) 972-0409
Customers' Favorites
The Bueno Bueno the Good Good Cookie
Molten Cake Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip Chunk
Bueno Bueno Cookie
Biscoff and Cream
S’Mores Cookie
Chocolate Chunk
Birthday Cake
Apple Pie
S'Mores
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Pricing is pretty high in 2025 for a cookie. Below is the pricing over the years.
$5 - 2020-2022
$6 - 2023
$7 - 2024
$8 - 2025
It is nice and thick but a bit too decadent for 1 person. I also dont think it worth it for $8. Thats the price for a meal!! It is bit too sweet for me.
$5 - 2020-2022
$6 - 2023
$7 - 2024
$8 - 2025
It is nice and thick but a bit too decadent for 1 person. I also dont think it worth it for $8. Thats the price for a meal!! It is bit too sweet for me.
Bought a couple flavors and sure it was definitely gooey but I could taste the raw flour. So almost too gooey. I wouldn't be able to even hold onto the cookie; it just kind of melted into the paper packaging. It was a disappointment because the lady upfront seemed so nice and I was recommended by Stephanie Soo in her videos
You May Also Like
Dixon Place - 161A Chrystie St
![]()
Performing Arts, Bar, Venues & Event Spaces
Cocoron - 16 Delancey St
![]()
Japanese, Noodles, Comfort Food, Soup, Gluten-Free
Ray’s - 177 Chrystie St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar, Pool Halls
The chocolate chip cookie tasted homemade, not overly sweet like most popular cookie spots in the city. I usually can only take a few bites and end up sharing because it’s too much, but with this one, I didn’t want to stop eating. It was warm, had the perfect balance of crunchy edges...