Il Mulino Prime

331 W Broadway, New York
(212) 226-0020

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Brussels Sprouts with Crispy Pancetta
Spaghetti Cacio E Pepe
Bone in Filet Mignon
Veal Chop Parmigiana
Ricotta Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan
Chocolate Cake
Tuna Tartare
Prime Ribeye
Porterhouse

ANTIPASTI
CALAMARI
PICCANTE
CAULIFLOWER
ROASTED WITH ITALIAN HERBS
CRAB CAKE
LUMP CRAB MEAT, AIOLI MUSTARD
EGGPLANT ROMANO
EGGPLANT, TOMATO SAUCE, BASIL, MOZZARELLA
GRILLED OCTOPUS
FRISÉE, FENNEL, ORANGE
RICOTTA MEATBALLS
TOMATO BASIL SAUCE
STEAMED CLAMS
WHITE WINE, CHERRY PEPPER, TUSCANY BREAD
BLISTERED SHISHITO PEPPER
TRUFFLE AIOLI
CHEESE & CHARCUTERIE
CAPRINO MOLISE, CLOVER HONEY, GORGONZOLA DOLCE, KALAMATA OLIVES, PROSCIUTTO, ROASTED WALNUTS, SOPPRESSATA

CRUDO
JUMBO SHRIMP
COCKTAIL SAUCE
STEAK TARTARE
PARMIGIANO CRUST, QUAIL EGG, HORSERADISH
TUNA TARTARE
BABY FRISEE, AVOCADO
SEAFOOD TOWER
OYSTERS, MAINE LOBSTER, SHRIMP, LUMP CRAB MEAT

INSALATE
ARUGULA
ORANGE, FENNEL, SHAVED PARMIGIANO, LEMON VINAIGRETTE
BEETS
ARUGULA, GOAT CHEESE, ROASTED WALNUTS, BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE
CAESAR
TRADITIONAL
CAPRESE
BEEFSTEAK TOMATOES, BUFFALO MOZZARELLA
HEIRLOOM TOMATO
SWEET ONION, CRISPY BACON
ICEBERG WEDGE
GORGONZOLA, BACON, RED ONION, TOMATO

PASTAS
BUCATINI AMATRICIANA
GUANCIALE, ONIONS, RED WINE, TOMATO SAUCE
CACIO E PEPE
RISOTTO, BLACK PEPPER, PECORINO ROMANO
CAVATELLI
BROCCOLI RABE, SAUSAGE, GARLIC, EVOO
FUSILLI CARBONARA
GUANCIALE, ONIONS, PARMIGIANO REGGIANO, EGG
GNOCCHI AL PESTO
PINENUTS, PARMESAN BASIL SAUCE
SPAGHETTI ALLA NERANO
PECORINO ROMANO, ZUCCHINI
PAPPARDELLE
BRAISED SHORT RIBS
LOBSTER RAVIOLI
HOMEMADE LOBSTER BROTH
HOMEMADE RIGATONI
SPICY VODKA SAUCE
LINGUINE FRUTTI DI MARE
BLACK INK LINGUINE, LITTLE NECK CLAMS, CALAMARI, SHRIMP, BABY SCALLOPS

STEAKS & CHOPS
8oz. BLACK PEPPERCORN FILET MIGNON
OFF THE BONE
12oz. CENTER CUT FILET MIGNON
OFF THE BONE
16oz. NEW YORK STRIP
BONE IN
18oz. PRIME RIBEYE
BONE IN
BARBECUE BABY BACK RIBS
WAGYU TRUFFLE SANDO
IL MULINO CHOPPED STEAK
CARAMELIZED ONIONS

SECONDI
BRANZINO
LEMON, SPINACH
HALIBUT
GRILLED VEGETABLES, LEMON SAUCE
ROASTED CHICKEN
ITALIAN HERBS, CARROTS
POLLO PARMIGIANA
THE ORIGINAL
SALMONE ALLA GRIGLA
MUSHROOMS, CHERRY PEPPERS
SHORT RIBS
POLENTA, BAROLO REDUCTION
TUNA
EGGPLANT, BLACK OLIVE, CHERRY TOMATO

SIDES
BAKED POTATO WITH MASCARPONE
CRISPY BACON
BROCCOLI RABE
BRUSSEL SPROUTS WITH CRISPY PANCETTA
ROASTED GARLIC MASHED POTATOES
SAUTÉED SPINACH
SAUTÉED WILD MUSHROOMS
TRUFFLE FRENCH FRIES

DESSERTS

TIRAMISU
FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE
GLUTEN FREE
ITALIAN RICOTTA CHEESECAKE

Signature Pasta Sauces
Marinara Sauce 24 oz.
Blending San Marzano tomatoes, sea salt, garlic and signature herbs, this gourmet red sauce is sought after by top chefs and home cooks to bring their creations to life.
Pomodoro Sauce 24 oz.
Blending San Marzano tomatoes, sea salt, garlic and signature herbs, this sweet red sauce is sought after by top chefs and home cooks to bring their creations to life.
Vodka Sauce
Blending San Marzano tomatoes, sea salt, garlic and signature herbs, this creamy pasta sauce is sought after by top chefs and home cooks to bring their creations to life.
Sugo Collection - 3 24 oz. Jars
A sampler of our Signature Sauces: 1 Jar each of our Marinara, Pomodoro, and Vodka sauces.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: foursquare
+82 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+81 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Service was sloppy. Having dined here many times before I was very upset seeing my ordered cocktail sitting on the bar for 10 minutes before I got up to get it myself. Staff did not seem to care. We asked for cold apps then hot apps which we are always accommodated with and were met with resistance by waiter who then brought a cold salad with hot polpette. Our waiter was seemed to basically ignore us and was totally wrapped up with a large table. We chose to have our anniversary...
October 2025
Our dinner experience was exceptional. We were greeted and seated promptly, our service at the table was amazing and our dinner was served in a timely manner and all our dishes were very good.
September 2025
We had an exquisite Italian meal at El Molino. My wife had Pollo Parmesano though, and it was the best presentation of this meal she has ever had... And she orders it at many many restaurants. Our waiter was very knowledgeable. We would return here many times.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Papatzul Soho - 55 Grand St
Mexican, Bar, Vegetarian
A Pasta Bar - 330 W Broadway
Italian, Bar, Vegetarian
Toad Hall - 57 Grand St
Bar, Pubs, American, New American

Il Mulino Prime

331 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013
(212) 226-0020