Il Pesce

101 Liberty St, New York
(212) 879-2895

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Terry

Great, fun, delicious! Maybe a little noisy... Oh, the print on the menu is hard to read, it could be darker.

Ken

Perfect Margarita pizza, son has pasta that was superb, only let down was the cheese/cracker/meats plate. Was light on everything & for $50 expected something with better presentation & girth!

Robert

A solid choice but an odd setting in a grocery store with jumbled layout. Good food and great service.

Karen

They did not have our reservation but did seat us at the correct time. Our waiter was horrible. One of our guests is a vegetarian. There were two items on the menu and neither of them were the pasta Fresca. We thought there was an item on the menu that was vegetarian so it was ordered AFTER we said she was vegetarian. The waiter did not correct us, and actually said it was a good choice. He never did he ever come back to the table until we flagged him down. We got a vegetarian replacement that took an extra 15 minutes. The waiter still never returned to the table. I went to talk to the manager who was FABULOUS. He took care of everything from there on out.

Brandy

Wonderful, delicious experience. Our waiter knew we had theater tickets and had our appetizer and meals served quickly and efficiently.

Kristin

Our group of 8 loved Eataly! Service was extremely attentive and we never had to ask for a drink cup to be refilled or to remove dirty plates. Food was excellent- Lasagna Emilina, Fettuccine Alfredo and Tagliatelle Truffle! Highly recommend especially if you're visiting the 9/11 Memorial, as you can have a table overlooking the reflection pools and museum.

Heather

Had a truly great experience. The setting was serene, the food was delicious, as were the drinks, and our waiter could not have been nicer. Highly recommend this spot!

Vicky

Haven't been to La Pizza La Pasta in a few months. Brought two clients for lunch and pleasantly surprised that the food was delicious for everyone and service was exceptional as expected. I appreciate the window table as my guests were very overwhelmed with the view. Thank you as always Eataly.

Lawrence

It was price fix meal and portions might be small for hungry people. The food was delicious and flavorful and cooked well specially the Gnocchi. Ravioli was very good. Kale salad was good as well. Optional drinks do add up. I will do it again.

Viktoriia

Me and my friend went for $26 restaurant special. What a waste of money. Terrible food. Service lacks speed. 2 hours for sandwich and pasta is not acceptable. I don't understand how with simple ingredients they made such a terrible dishes. I get it that you go for special price but it could be at list tasty. I didint finish nothing that I had. If I knew that for this much money they would give you sh....I would order from regular menu. So disappointed. Not going there ever. If you do crappie food for little money I don't want to spend there bigger one.

Tkeyah

This was our second time dining at La Pizza & La Pasta and we were a little disappointed. The food did not live up to our prior experience and our server was not attentive. It was lunch hour on a Wednesday and was pretty busy, so I'm hoping that was the reason for the shortcomings.

heidi

Great meal and great service. I've tried to use my Open Table rewards for MONTHS and not one restaurant would accept it. Pedro, the manager, came by and I explained the “rewards card” and he immediately said yes and worked to process the rewards card plus my credit card, making sure the server was provided gratuity in the total amount. Class act manager. Thank you, Pedro.

Opentable Diner

Service was not good... they delivered wrong food... had to take it back and make an entire pizza after that whole time!

Ben

Normally don't leave reviews, but feel like I should as I see it's a trend on Eatlys reviews. The pizza wasn't cooked, wasn't cut and came out about 45 mins before the pasta. By that time the pizza was cold. Normally you bring 2 entrees out together. The server was also absent most of the time. This was during restaurant fest

Catherine

Menu changed since last year no more pasta being made table side. Staff turned over mid meal. New waiter had zero personality. Seemed like no one cared. What a shame could be a nice place

Loading...